©2014 Baishideng Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.
Epilepsy associated tumors: Review article
Marco Giulioni, Matteo Martinoni, IRCCS Institute of Neurological Sciences of Bologna, Division of Neurosurgery, Bellaria Hospital, 40139 Bologna, Italy
Gianluca Marucci, Department of Biomedical and Neuromotor Sciences (DiBiNeM), Section of Pathology “M.Malpighi”, Bellaria Hospital, University of Bologna, 40139 Bologna, Italy
Anna Federica Marliani, Francesco Toni, IRCCS Institute of Neurological Sciences of Bologna, Section of Neuroradiology, Bellaria Hospital, 40139 Bologna, Italy
Fiorina Bartiromo, Department of Specialistic Diagnostic and Experimental Medicine (DIMES), Section of Neuroradiology, University of Bologna, 40139 Bologna Italy
Lilia Volpi, Patrizia Riguzzi, Roberto Michelucci, Guido Rubboli, IRCCS Institute of Neurological Sciences of Bologna, Division of Neurology, Bellaria Hospital, 40139 Bologna, Italy
Francesca Bisulli, Ilaria Naldi, Agostino Baruzzi, Paolo Tinuper, IRCCS Institute of Neurological Sciences of Bologna, Bellaria Hospital, 40139 Bologna, Italy
Francesca Bisulli, Agostino Baruzzi, Paolo Tinuper, Department of Biomedical and Neuromotor Sciences, University of Bologna, 40139 Bologna Italy
Guido Rubboli, Danish Epilepsy Centre, Epilepsi hospitalet, 4293 Dianalund, Denmark
Author contributions: Giulioni M, Marucci G, Martinoni M drafted the article; Giulioni M, Marucci G, Martinoni M, Marliani AF, Toni F, Bartiromo F, Volpi L, Riguzzi P, Bisulli F, Naldi I, Michelucci R, Baruzzi A, Tinuper P and Rubboli G contributed to data analysis, to separate heading of the article and to revised the article.
Correspondence to: Marco Giulioni, MD, IRCCS Institute of Neurological Sciences, Division of Neurosurgery, Bellaria Hospital, Via Altura 1/8, 40139 Bologna, Italy. email@example.com
Telephone: +39-051-6225111 Fax: +39-051-6225347
Received: July 29, 2014
Revised: September 17, 2014
Accepted: October 1, 2014
Published online: November 16, 2014
Brain tumors, mostly low grade tumors, are associated with epilepsy in more than a half of cases and approximately 30% of tumor-associated epilepsy are pharmacoresistant.
Recent advances in neuroimaging and neurophysiology have allowed the recognition of subtle epilepsy-associated focal structural lesions, and have improved our understanding of the complex functional relevance of these lesions for seizure generation. Among this group of lesions the concept of long-term epilepsy associated tumors (LEAT) describes the wide group of low grade tumors in patients associated with chronic focal epilepsy[1-5]. Indeed, developmental brain lesions, in particular glioneuronal tumors (GNT), often associated with malformations of cortical development, in particular focal cortical dysplasia (FCD)[1,3,4], are among the most common causes of pharmacologically intractable epilepsy. In the setting of epilepsy surgery a brain tumor is the second most common cause of focal epilepsy and it could be encountered in approximately 30% of patients operated on for refractory focal epilepsy[5,7,8].
Epilepsy associated-tumor is a debilitating condition, causing distress and adversely affecting the quality of life[3,5,9-17].
Epileptic seizure incidence varies according to tumour location and hystotype. Furthermore low-grade tumors often are more epileptogenic than high-grade tumours[8,10,12,13,16,18].
Epilepsy associated with brain tumours can be divided into two groups: tumors without other symptoms (usually low-grade tumors affecting children or young patients) or tumors together with neurological deficits (more frequently high-grade tumours in middle-aged and older patients).
In the group of epilepsy associated with low grade tumors it is useful to further distinguish between the preeminence of oncological and epileptic logical aspects. In the group of the “diffuse low grade glioma” (LGG) the oncological aspects should prevail according to the progressive course of the neoplastic brain disease[10-12,15,16,19-22]. On the contrary in the group of LEAT, mainly represented by glioneuronal tumors (GNTs), epilepsy control should be the main goal[1,3-5,8,23-28].
The group of LEAT, is currently enlarging not only for the recognition of new, often rare, histotypes but also for the identification of tumors having hybrid and/or mixed features[3,29-32]. The biologic behaviour of LEAT is generally benign even if some tumors could present recurrence or malignant transformation[5,33]. New tumoral entities have been recently introduced and there is ongoing debate on improving consensus for diagnosis of LEAT between specialized centers[3,30]. While LEAT rarely coexist with hippocampal sclerosis (2%-25% of cases ) they may often be associated with FCD (40%-80% of cases)[2,23,24,29,34-36].
LONG TERM EPILEPSY ASSOCIATED TUMORS
The histological characteristics of these tumors influence their propensity to generate seizures.
Gangliogliomas (GG) are the most common neoplasm causing chronic focal epileptic disorders (about 40%)[5,37-39]. GG can occur in any part of the central nervous system, although the temporal lobe is the most common location[5,33,40] followed by the frontal lobe, the optic pathway, the spinal cord, the brainstem, the cerebellum and the pineal gland.
Dysembryoplastic neuroepithelial tumors
Dysembryoplastic neuroepithelial tumors (DNT) are grade I WHO tumors with cystic components, described by Daumas-Duport et al in 1988 as a typically cortical tumor affecting children and young adults with long-standing, drug-resistant epilepsy. Most frequently DNT are sited in the cortex of temporal lobe above all at the temporo-mesial site[42-46]. Rarely DNTs have been described in ectopic locations (septum pellucidum and the caudate nucleus) in the pons, thalamus, basal ganglia, cerebellum, third ventricle, and brainstem. Familial occurrence of these neoplasms have been described.
Recently also pleomorphic Xanthoastrocytoma (PXA) has been considered part of this group of tumors. In fact, in addition to the astrocytic nature, there is growing evidence that PXA exhibits some histological, immunophenotypic and ultrastructural neuronal features[48,49]. Furthermore occasionally, FCD can be associated with PXA.
Papillary glioneuronal tumor
Firstly described by Kim et al 1997, Papillary glioneuronal tumor (PGNT) most frequently arises in a supratentorial locationwith rare case showing multilobar involvement. At MRI they appear as a cystic enhancing lesion with solid areas and often a mural nodule. PGNTs affect young adults.
Supratentorial pilocytic astrocytoma (PA) is frequently presents with chronic epilepsy. PA are included within the common histological entities encountered in series of tumor-associated epilepsy cases[3,5,30,51].
Diffuse astrocytomas mostly arise in the cerebral hemispheres of young adults (frontal and temporal cerebral lobes) and seizures represent one of the most common symptoms. It has been described in the group of LEAT. Some author stated that initial presentation with seizures could influence long-term survival[30,53].
Oligodendrogliomas usually arise in the cerebral hemispheres of young adults. They belong to LEAT group. Seizures represent a common presenting symptom[3,5,30].
low grade cerebral tumor mostly affecting children and young adults and it is more and more frequently identified in the setting of chronic epilepsy. Angiocentric gliomas (AG) have a cerebro-cortical location, often with involvement of the fronto-parietal and temporal lobe.
This rare entity, may be considered in the spectrum of GNT associated with focal epilepsy.
LEAT with mixed tumor features
“Hybrid” tumors constituted by mixed forms of ganglioglioma and DNT but also PXA and ganglioglioma, PXA with DNT and, PXA with an oligodendroglioma have long been recognised, representing an increasing group of tumors in epilepsy surgical series. Cases where a PA developed within a DNT, as well as PA grew in combination with a low-grade oligodendroglioma, have been noted[54,55].
In the setting of low grade tumors associated with epilepsy, diffuse LGG (WHO grade II gliomas) are mainly found in the insular, fronto-insular, temporo-insular regions (namely paralimbic structures) representing the iso-mesocortical transition zone.
Instead, LEAT mainly arise in the temporo-mesial structures (namely limbic lobe) in the site of allo-isocortical transition, harboring more frequently a neuronal differentiation maybe due to their proximity to the hippocampal granular layer where neurogenesis during adult life takes place[56-62].
In our findings[8,26,28,36] according with others[62-65] in the mesial temporal lobe both the lesion and hippocampus seem to be epileptogenic even if there are no other MRI abnormality (hippocampal sclerosis) and pathological examination shows normal findings.
PATHOGENESIS OF TUMOR-ASSOCIATED SEIZURES
Epileptogenesis of brain tumors depends on the histotype and location, even if the complexity of structural and molecular changes implies a multifactoriality of the pathogenesis[10,28,66,67] and may differ according to histologies (GNT vs diffuse low grade gliomas)[4,10,15,16,68,69]. The comprehension of the epileptogenesis in GNT is crucial to treat effectively pharmacologically intractable epilepsy (as discussed above) represents the initial, and often the only, clinical manifestation of the tumor and critically affects the patient’s daily life.
LEAT are often large tumors, with a high propensity to develop seizures when located in temporal or frontal lobes[10,70]. GNT are composed of peculiar cellular components with hyperexcitable neurons, functionally integrated into excitatory circuitries, and neurochemical characteristics that can be relevant for epileptogenesis. Data provided by intralesional EEG recording have demonstrated intrinsic epileptogenicity of GG and DNT[71,72]. In addition, immunocytochemical studies showing high expression of specific glutamate receptors (GluR) subtypes suggest a hyperexcitability in the neuronal constituent of GNT[73,74]. An additional mechanism that can sustain epileptogenesis is related to an unbalance between excitation and inhibition due to to a prominent expression of mGluR5 and downregulation of several gammaaminobutyric acid (GABA-A) a receptor (GABA-AR) subunits that suggest an impairment of GABAergic inhibition[75,76]. Furthermore, a disturbed ion homeostasis and transport could represent an additional potential mechanism leading to increased excitability in GNT[9,77].
Another potential epileptogenic mechanism is related to a possible role of inflammation in the pathophysiology of human epilepsy. Proinflammatory molecules have been shown in experimental models to decrease the seizure threshold[78,79] and may be involved in the generation of seizures in brain tumors, particularly in GNT. Different mechanisms can cause an increment of neuronal excitability, for instance by enhancing the extracellular glutamate concentrations, as well as modifying the function of both glutamate and GABA receptors. Furthermore in GNT, particularly in GG, inflammatory changes have been showed to be associated with evidence of alterations in blood-brain barrier (BBB), with albumin extravasation and uptake in tumor astrocytes[66,81]. Interestingly, some data have shown also a prominent upregulation of the mTOR pathway, known to be a key regulator of cellular changes involved in epileptogenesis in GNT, particularly in GG[82,83].
Several other additional mechanisms have been hypothesized to account for enhanced excitability in GG, such as for example, hypoxia and acidosis, ionic changes, and deposition of hemosiderin in the peritumoral region. Enzymatic changes may also occur in peritumoral tissue, impairing neurotransmitter synthesis and storage, and contributing to tumor-associated epilepsy. Finally, association with cortical dysplasia (as discussed below) also has to be considered in the evaluation of the epileptogenicity of GG. Indeed the identification of a coexistent pathology may be clinically relevant since it has been extensively reported that the tumor itself may be electrically silent and the origin of seizures is from a pathological tissue adjacent to the tumor[42,77,84]. The implication is that excising the tumor and leaving in place the nearby abnormal epileptogenic tissue, may give unsatisfactory results on the seizure outcome. Young age and long duration of illness are associated with an increased risk of secondary epileptogenesis. GNT can be intrinsically epileptogenic, even when associated with FCD.
CLINICAL AND EEG FEATURES OF FOCAL EPILEPSY ASSOCIATED WITH LEATs
Focal epilepsy is the most common and often the only symptom of LEAT. Neurological deficits are relatively uncommon, varying from 0% to 15% according to different series: the neurological sparing might depend on the indolent and slow course of LEAT that might allow compensation of possible brain impairment by slowly developing plastic processes, particularly in the young age. Epilepsy can appear at any age: however, the majority of cases present with an epilepsy onset in adolescence and young adulthood. In DNET, seizures appear almost always and more than half of the patients have focal seizures with alterated consciousness, with or without secondary generalization. Regarding GGs, 80%-90% of patients seizures represent the only clinical symptom (mainly secondarily generalized tonic-clonic seizures)[86,87]. As already reported, the most common location of GG is the temporal lobe where they are frequently positive to CD34 glycoprotein staining. On the contrary it is not reported the association with CD34 for GG located in other sites of the brain[37,86-88]. It could be argued that this protein might represent a marker of dysplastic differentiation and that it could contribute to epileptogenesis. Seizure semiology is related to the site of tumor. In general, complex partial seizures with aura are more common in LEAT located in the temporal lobe, whereas secondary generalization is more common in epilepsies associated with extratemporal LEAT. However, the extension of the tumor-related epileptogenic area may vary according to the anatomical location of the neoplasm: in fact, several data suggest that epileptogenic zone may be more widespread and complex in focal epilepsies associated to LEAT in the mesial temporal lobe in comparison to neocortical temporal lateral locations[36,40,61,65]. Occurrence of status epilepticus has been reported to be rare. Clinical parameters that differentiated patients operated on in childhood from patients operated on in adulthood were: (1) aura that was reported more often in the adult group, but it should be noted that this finding might at least partially depend on the fact that, in general, children are less able to refer their auras; and (2) mean age at seizure: probably due to the fact that developing brain has a low seizure threshold which leads to early and frequent seizures. Moreover, in pediatric age, malformations of cortical development are most often the basis of lesional epilepsy that is characterized by a high seizure frequency that can facilitate an early diagnosis and that can lead to early evaluation for a surgical approach. No differences between the clinical features of epilepsy associated with DNET and with GG have been reported[42,89]. A favorable seizure outcome has been observed in cases with a short duration of epilepsy, only partial seizure and the lack of secondary generalization . Response of GNT-associated epilepsy to antiepileptic treatment is variable, but drug-resistance is quite common[5,39,42,90].
Task Force of the ILAE Commission on Therapeutic Strategies defined drug resistant epilepsy as the failure of adequate trials of two tolerated, appropriately chosen and used antiepileptic drug (AEDs) schedules (whether as monotherapies or in combination) to achieve sustained seizure freedom.
Several explanations could be at the basis for drug resistance. AEDs could be affected by the biochemical milieu of the peri-tumoral space.
Furthermore significant interactions between AEDs and other drugs (i.e., chemoterapeutics) may decrease antiepileptic effectiveness, while increasing side effects interfering with the hepatic cytochrome P450 system. Furthermore AEDs resistance might result from over expression of multi-drug resistance-related proteins (MRPs) in tumors (particularly in capillary endothelial cells and astrocytes), which restrict the penetration of lipophilic substances into the pathologic tissue.
Usually interictal EEG shows spikes and/or, sharp waves, sometimes intermixed with slow activities; in some instances normal EEG have been reported. These abnormalities, in preoperative EEG are commonly lateralized to the tumor side, less often to the correct lobe. However, Morris et al (1998) reported that the occurrence of interictal EEG abnormalities and ictal EEG onset in correspondence of the site of the tumor may not be predictive of seizure outcome; indeed, in some cases a post-operative poor seizure outcome has been reported in patients with EEG interictal and ictal findings perfectly concordant with tumor location. On the other hand, also patients with EEG slow or epileptiform abnormalities distant from the tumor site or with ictal EEG onset non-localized or widespread to a whole hemisphere improved regarding seizure outcome after tumor resection. In temporal lobe GNT, long-term video-EEG monitoring may allow recording of seizures and identification of the epileptogenic zone; indeed, several data suggest that in mesial temporal lobe GNT a tailored resection that include, besides the tumor, the epileptogenic area as defined by the anatomic and electroclinical correlations performed on the ictal video-EEG data, provides better post-operative seizure outcome as compared to simple lesionectomy[36,45,61,92,93]. In cases of undetermined lateralization of seizure focus, invasive EEG investigations may provide useful information, although in GNT-associated focal epilepsy the main goal of intracerebral recordings is usually to map eloquent cortex in proximity of the neoplasm. Several reports focused on prediction of poor postoperative outcome by identifying ECoG spike discharge patterns in FCD and the persistence of seizure patterns or continuous epileptiform discharges in post-resection ECoG recordings . There are little evidences about the ECoG discharge patterns in patients with GNTs because of the small numbers of patients investigated[89,93,94]. Different disorders (LEAT and FCD) may have similar electrocorticographic abnormalities probably due to the common developmental origin. In these cases have been observed continuous spiking (more often in FCD), bursts, and recruiting discharges. When continuous spiking is found in GNT, it is likely to be due to associated dysplastic regions with a high neuronal density[45,93]. A recent study employed MEG to investigate possible differences in whole brain topology of epileptic glioma patients, comparing them to patients with non-glial lesions and healthy controls. LGG patients showed decreased network synchronizability compared to healthy controls in the theta frequency range (4-8 Hz), similar to patients with non glial lesions. Network characteristics are associated with clinical presentation (seizure frequency in LGG), and with poorer cognitive performance (both low grade and high grade glioma) suggesting that histology could partly determine differences in epileptogenesis and epileptic probably due to differences in cortical plasticity. Interestingly, it would seem that low grade glioma and non tumoral lesions have a decreased synchronizability that could predispose to a high occurrence of seizures and cognitive decline.
Gangliogliomas and gangliocytoma
The differentation between GG and gangliocytoma (GC) is mainly based on histology. They may have variable tumour size (2-3 cm) and a typical location at the periphery of cerebral hemispheres. There is usually little associated mass effect and peripheral vasogenic edema and superficial lesions may expand cortex and remodel bone.
The MR signal of GG is variable and inhomogeneous due to the presence of a combination of solid, cystic and calcified components[46,95] (Figures 1-4).
Figure 1 Ganglioglioma World Health Organization grade I of the right posterior middle temporal gyrus.
Axial FLAIR T2-w (A) and coronal IR T1-w (B) images show inhomogeneous cortical-subcortical mass extending within the deep white matter and reaching the ependymal layer. The tumor presents a combination of solid, cystic and calcified components. The latter is better identified on coronal T2*-w sequence (C). Post-contrast axial T1-w image (D) shows no pathological enhancement and axial CT scan (E) confirms the calcified component. Coronal IR T1-w image (F) demonstrates lesion resec-tion; G: Histological examination evidences a biphasic neoplastic population, with neu-ronal and glial elements.
Figure 2 Gangliocytoma and Mesial Temporal Sclerosis MTS (dual pathology).
Coronal Flair T2 (A) and T1-w images (B) demonstrate a right hippocampal atrophy with signal hyperintensity on FLAIR. The ipsilateral temporal horn is dilated. Axial T1-w pre- (C) and post-contrast injection (D) show a non-enhancing multicystic lesion with calcification near the optic tract. The right mammillary body is atrophic (arrowhead); E: Neoplastic ganglion cells exhibit disorganized clusters and show abnormal cytologic features; F: Hippocampal specimen displays ILAE hippocampal sclerosis type 1, with severe pyramidal cell loss in both CA1, CA3 and CA4 sectors.
Figure 3 Ganglioglioma World Health Organization grade I of the left temporo-mesial cortex.
The tumor shows heterogeneous cortical-subcortical high signal on axial proton density weighted image (A). It appears partially cystic on coronal IR T1 (B) FLAIR T2 (C), T1 (D) weighted sequences. Post-contast T1-w image displays nodular, intense and homogenous enhancement (E). Low-magnification view shows a vaguely lobulated, hypocellular vascularized neoplasia, with scattered lymphocytic infiltrates (F).
Figure 4 Ganglioglioma and associated focal cortical dysplasia IIa.
Coronal FSE T2-w (A, B) demonstrate a temporo-mesial heterogeneously hyperintense lesion. Post-contrast coronal T1-w (C) shows enhancement of the tumor and adjacent leptomeninges. A signal abnormality extending from the surface of the ventricle to the pole (arrowheads in D) and adjacent anomalous sulci (arrow in A) were suspicious for FCD, subsequently histologically confirmed. Microscopy evidenced a tumor composed of ganglion cells intimately intermixed with astrocytic elements (E) and focal cortical dysplasia with dysmorphic neurons (FCD Type IIa) (F).
Calcifcations can be more conspicuous as areas of hypointensity on T2* gradient echo weighted images, or even more evident at unenhanced CT (Figure 1E).
Medium contrast enhancement could be variable: nodular, intense and homogenous (Figure 3E); “ringlike” appearance (Figure 4C) but also nonenhancing (Figure 1D). Although extremely rare GG may show focal leptomeningeal involvement (Figure 4C).
Dysembryoplastic neuroepithelial tumor
DNET are well-demarcated, wedge shaped, multinodular, “bubbly” intracortical tumors often similar to other LGG.
DNET may show a multicystic morphology more frequently than GG. Absent or very slow increase in size over time is typical of DNET, and recurrence is also extremely rare. Contrast enhancement could be found in about 30% of cases.
On CT scan the tumor appears as a cortical-subcortical hypoattenuating mass with sporadic calcifications. Scalloping of the adjacent inner table of the skull may also be present. At MR imaging, DNET most commonly manifest as pseudocystic, multinodular cortical masses that are hypointense on T1-weighted images and hyperintense on T2-weighted images with minimal or without mass effect and surrounding vasogenic edema (Figures 5 and 6).
Figure 5 DNET of the right uncus.
Axial T2-w (A) and sagittal 3D T1-w (B) reveal a cystic cortical mass well-demarcated, without perilesional oedema or mass effect. On coronal FLAIR T2-w image (C) the tumor is variably hypo- and isointense. Post-contrast axial T1-w sequence (D) shows no enhancement. Histological examination shows a tu-mor characterized by the “specific glioneuronal element”, typical of DNET, (E), while the cortex adjacent to the tumor displays cortical lamination abnormalities compatible with FCD type IIIb (F); the latter was not depicted at MR study.
Figure 6 Extra temporal DNET.
Sagittal 3D T1 (A) coronal IR T1 (B) and FLAIR T2-w (C) demonstrate a cystic wedge-shaped lesion in the right fronto-orbital gyrus. On FLAIR T2-w the tumor is slightly hypointense with a faint hyperintense rim. On post contrast coronal T1-w images there is no enhancement uptake (D); E: Post-surgical scan on cor-onal IR T1-w; F: Microscopic study evidences the presence of floating neurons, a feature of DNET, in microcystic areas lined with oligo-like cells.
Some lesions may expand involving cortical gyri and, producing a soap bubble appearance at the cortical margin. (Figures 5 and 6).
PXA classically, although not specifically, appear as cystic supratentorial mass containing a mural nodule and involvong cortex and adjacent leptomeninges. PXA is usually a circumscribed and slow growing lesion, that rarely recurs; size and morphology are variable.
At unenhanced CT the tumor appears as a hypo or isoattenuating mass. Calcifications are rare. On MRI T1- WI PXA are usually hypo to isointense displaying inhomogenous, mainly iso-hyperintense, signal intensity on T2-weighted sequences. Peritumoral edema is relatively uncommon. They usually enhance after gadolinium injection (Figure 7). Leptomeninges contrast enhcement is highly characteristic.
Figure 7 Pleomorphic xanthoastrocytoma World Health Organization grade II.
Axial T2 w (A) and coronal IR T1-w (B) images show temporo-polar mixed signal intensity cortical mass with a small cystic component anteriorly (arrow in A). Post-contrast coronal SE T1w (C) shows a well-delineated, peripherally located enhancing nodule. (D) Microscopically the tumor is characterized by huge cytologic atypia, a vaguely fascicular arrangement and scattered eosinophilic granular bodies.
Extraventricular neurocytoma may be difficult to differentiate from other types of low-grade tumor, such as GGs or DNET. It could be a well circumscribed, heterogeneous and variably enhancing mass. CT and MRI aspects depend on the cellularity and degree of calcification. They may have peritumoral oedema and intralesional cyst but rarely intralesional bleeding[29,98,99].
Pilocytic astrocytomas are the most common form of glioma in childhood and most frequently manifest in the first two decades of life. They may arise anywhere within the neuraxis, but among the pediatric population they are more frequently found infratentorially. Optic nerves, optic chiasm and hypothalamus, basal ganglia, and thalamus represent other common localtions. Cerebral hemispheres involvement has been less frequently described.
Pilocytic Astrocytomas are commonly characterized by fluid accumulation, with subsequent cyst formation and by mural nodule or a rim of tissue surrounding the cyst that enhances on post-contrast imaging. Predominantly solid mass lesions with minimal or no cyst have been described (Figure 8).
Figure 8 Pilocytic astrocytoma World Health Organization grade I of the right frontal lobe.
Axial FLAIR T2-w (A) and coronal lR T1-w (B) images show a cortical-subcortical lesion, with cystic component, with minimal mass effect. The tumor appears well de-marcated (C) on 3D sagittal sequence and displays nodular and homogeneous en-hancement on post-contrast axial T1-w images (D). Perfusion study doesn’t show any rCBV increase within the lesion (E). MR Spectroscopy (MRS) study (F) reveals elevation in choline and reduction in NAA. (G) Histological examination shows a tumor com-posed of areas rich in myxoid material, elongated glial elements with uniform nuclei and numerous eosinophilic granular bodies.
Calcification may be seen in up to 25% of cases and haemorrhage has been reported. On MRI the solid portion of the neoplasm is typically isointense to hypointense on T1 weighted images and hyperintense on T2 weighted sequences to grey matter and it enhances after gadolinium chelates injection (Figure 8D). The signal intensity of the cystic portion is often not suppressed on FLAIR T2 weighted images due to its protein content.
MR spectroscopy reveals elevation in choline and reduction in NAA, with minimal elevation in lipid peak (Figure 8F). Lactate peak could be elevated, representing alteration in mitochondrial metabolism or variability in glucose uptake.
Diffuse astrocytomas are diffusely infiltrating primary brain neoplasms of astrocytic origin that are classified as WHO grade II.
Diffuse astrocytomas are usually at unenhanced CT iso to hypoattenuating lesions. They do not enhance on post-contrast imaging. Calcifications may be present in approximately 20%; cyst formation is rare.
MRI demonstrates astrocytomas as relatively homogenous mass involving and expanding more typically cerebral hemispheres cortex and adjacent white matter. The lesions are high in water content, thus appearing as hyperintense on T2 weighted images and hypo isointense on T1 weighted sequences. They usually lack peritumoral oedema (Figure 9).
Figure 9 Temporo-mesial astrocytoma World Health Organization grade II.
Axial FLAIR T2-w (A) shows a left temporal hyperintense mass, involving mainly the hippocampus. The lesion is slightly hypointense on T1-w image (B) and does not demonstrate enhancement after gadolinium injection (C). Perfusion study reveals no significant rCBV increase (D). MRS study shows a faint NAA reduction, a slight Cho elevation and high mI, expression of low grade glioma (E). Postsurgical axial FLAIR T2-w (F). (G) This histological picture exhibits in the left side a portion of hippocampus and in the right side an infiltrating astrocytoma, composed of fibrillary elements with varying degree of hypercellularity.
Well differentiated Astrocytomas has a variable appearance after contrast agent administration, but usually shows no significant contrast enhancement (Figure 9C). In general, contrast enhancement is not recognized as a reliable indicator of the grade of infiltrative astrocytomas. MR perfusion imaging however seems to be more informative for distinguish low- and high-grade astrocytoma and for identifying low-grade lesions that could more likely behave aggressively.
On dynamic contrast enhanced T2* weighted MR perfusion imaging study rCBV is typically less than 1.75 (Figure 9D).
MR Spectroscopy should display Cho elevation and NAA reduction. A High myo-inositol to Creatine ratio (Myo/Cre) in also present (Figure 9E).
FOCAL CORTICAL DYSPLASIA AND LEAT
LEAT and focal cortical dysplasia FCD are common findings in drug-resistant focal epilepsies, and frequently coexist[1,6,8,24,34,36,104,106-109].
Rarely MRI features of LEAT could be misinterpreted as FCD. Generally most important neuroradiological findings in FCD are increased cortical thickness, blurring of the cortical-white matter junction, increased signal on T2-W, a radially oriented linear or conical transmantle stripe of T2 hyperintensity, cortical thinning, and localized brain atrophy[34,110-112] (Figure 10).
Figure 10 Focal cortical dysplasia with balloon cells (Taylor).
Axial (A) and sagittal (B) reformatted fat-saturated 3D FLAIR images show a left temporo-mesial cortical thicken-ing (arrow) and white matter tapering to the temporal horn of the lateral ventricle (arrowheads). MR spectroscopy shows normal metabolite concentrations (C). (D) Histol-ogy demonstrates the presence of typical balloon cells, showing large and opalescent glassy eosinophilic cytoplasm.
Some limitations are encountered in the correct identification of different FCD types or subtypes[111-114]. A high number of false negatives is detected with FCD type I and slightly fewer with FCD type IIa (about 50% sensitivity). FCD IIb is much more easily identified (about 90% sensitivity)[112,113] (Figure 10).
Association between LEAT and FCD poses further issues into its correct identification. In a limited serie of patients with LEAT, who underwent surgery at our Institution associated FCD has been correctly identified in the majority of cases (Figure 4). In a few cases peritumoral edema and neoplastic infiltration both caused subcortical white matter signal alterations, determining false positives (FP) and false negatives (FN) FCD results. Indeed, the signal abnormality is able to mimic a blurring, but it could hide a FCD contiguous to the tumour (Figure 11).
Figure 11 Gangliogliomas World Health Organization grade I of the left temporo-mesial region and focal cortical dysplasia IIa subtype associated.
Axial and coronal T1-w images (A-B) show thickening of amygdala and uncus (arrow in B). Axial and coronal FLAIR T2-w images (C-D) present blurring and adjacent subcortical high signal abnormality compatible with a focal cortical dysplasia (FCD). Microscopy evidenced a glioneuronal tumor, with scattered binucleated ganglion cells, compatible with a gan-glioglioma (E) and dysmorphic neurons in the adjacent cortex (FCD Type IIa) (F).
These limitations were more evident when tumour size is larger (Figure 12). MRI sensibility can be reduced by an incomplete protocol too.
Figure 12 Gangliogliomas and focal cortical dysplasia IIa.
Sagittal 3D T1-w (A), coronal FLAIR T2-w (B) and axial T2-w (C) reveal an inhomogeneous mass, involving the right hippocampus and the temporal pole. Due to the size of the tumor, the associated dysplasia is not clearly visible. Histological examination demonstrates the presence of a glioneuronal tumor with small ganglion cells in a desmoplastic stroma (D) and of dysmorphic neurons in the adjacent cortex (focal cortical dysplasia Type IIa) (E).
MOLECULAR ASPECT OF LEAT
The following molecular markers may facilitate differential diagnosis of LEAT: (1) IDH1 and IDH2 mutations: common in low grade diffuse gliomas (70%-80%), while they are generally not present in PA and GNT; (2) LOH 1p/19q: constitutes the keystone in diagnosis of oligodendrogliomas (> 70% of tumors), while it has not been detected in DNT, a useful difference in those cases in which histological aspects do not permit a conclusive diagnosis; and (3) BRAF V600E mutations: frequently found in PXA, GG and PA, whereas diffuse grade II gliomas harbor only rarely these mutations.
As recently observed these BRAF-mutant grade II diffuse gliomas seem to present with refractory seizures and frequently are located within the temporal lobe.It as been proposed that BRAF mutations could be strictly linked to epileptogenesis.
Interestingly we found that BRAF mutations could be present in the FCD associated with LEAT, suggesting a pathogenetic role of BRAF mutations in cyto-architectural dysplasia and in the tumorigenesis of LEAT.
SURGICAL STRATEGIES FOR LEAT
Epilepsies associated to LEAT are usually unsatisfactorily controlled by antiepileptic drugs, whereas excellent results can be achieved by surgery[4,5,26,28,42,65,92,119]. Various surgical approaches have been adopted for the radical resection of these tumors. The choice of surgical approach is also related to the goal of surgical strategy.
The surgical strategy may be directed only to oncological issues and/or to resolve epilepsy. In this last condition we must have an epilepsy surgery oriented approach.
A non-invasive presurgical study and neuropsycological assessment, may define the extension of the epileptogenic zone and may address the choice of the better surgical strategy to optimise seizure control (lesionectomy or tailored resection)[24,26,28,36,120].
Rarely in the setting of epilepsy associated tumor may be necessary an invasive presurgical study (using subdural grid, depth electrodes, or stereo-EEG)[24,64,121-123]. LEAT are certainly the prototype of cases where epilepsy is the main problem. However, in recent years, even in cases where the main problem is oncological, it is becoming equally important trying to preserve brain functions and to best cure even epilepsy (especially when tumors involve mesiotemporal structures, the insular lobe, or the central area) in order to improve the quality of life[15,63,64,124].
Several authors analyzed epileptological outcome according to surgical treatment in tumor-related chronic epilepsy. While some argue that lesionectomy alone is enough for good seizure control others say that the best management should include additional resection of epileptogenic zones adjacent to the tumor[26,28,36,39,40,44,62,119,120,125,126].
In Epilepsy-associated tumors it reaches a special meaning for the epileptogenicity and surgical strategies, the site of the lesion, i.e., temporal, mesio-temporal (or limbic), temporo-lateral, paralimbic, extratemporal, eloquent areas[8,26,28,36,40,44,45,56,63,119,125,126].
Regarding limbic and paralimbic system, the role of hippocampus in the epilepsy network is pivotal since that could play a pivotal role in epileptogenesis even without obvious neuroradiological and pathological changes (i.e., hippocampal sclerosis)[26,28,36,61,64,127].
The limbic system consists of the following elements, which are all directly or indirectly interconnected: the temporo-mesial structures (hippocampus, the parahippocampus,giryus) and the cingulate gyrus[58,60,61,128]. The paralimbic system is composed of 3 independent anatomical parts: the orbitofrontal cortex, the temporopolar cortex, and the insula[58,60,128]. The limbic system is connected via the entorhinal cortex and the uncinate fasciculus to the paralimbic system. In the setting of low-grade tumors associated with epilepsy WHO Grade II gliomas are mainly found in the paralimbic system while glioneuronal tumors are found in the limbic system (temporomesial structures)[8,57].
LEAT are frequently associated with type I or type IIa cortical dysplasia which, in contrast to focal cortical dysplasia type IIb, are more difficult to identify with MRI[1,8,24,36,109,111,113]. It means that the anatomical structural lesion can be larger than what have been detected by MRI[110,113].
For this reason the target of the surgical resection should be the epileptogenic zone defined according to neuroradiological, clinical, neurophysiological and neuropsycological findings[40,129].
In case of LEAT located near or in eloquent area, the surgical approach is usually directed only to the anatomical structural lesion. Regarding the more frequent site of these tumors, i.e., the temporal lobe, several approach have been used. The surgical strategy used in temporal lobe tumors includes lesionectomy, extended lesionectomy, tailored resection, anterior temporal lobectomy.
The majority of authors agree that lesionectomy alone provides the best seizure outcome results in LEAT located in the extratemporal and temporo-lateral site[40,42,44] while its results for temporomesial lesions are questionable[5,8,26,28,40]. Some authors suggested that the involvement of temporo-mesial regions may extend and make more complex the epileptogenic zone.
For this reason the amount of tissue removed in temporomesial surgeries is considered crucial to gain good postoperative results[5,8,60,62,63,65,125,130,131].
One important and persistent problem are the conflicting needs of the necessary extent of resection and the avoidance of neuropsychological deficits[126,131,132].
Focal epilepsy associated with LEAT and particularly GG and DNT shows the best seizure outcome after surgery[5,18,28,36,92,95,119,132-134]. Some authors observed improvement of seizure outcome in young patients whereas others found no correlation with age at the time of surgery[4,28,38,132].
A recent literature meta-analysis about epileptogenic gangliogliomas in adult showed that an early surgical intervention of less than 3 years from the onset of seizure is significantly associated with improved seizure control.
Several studies reported that lesionectomy plus temporal tailored resection seems to offer the best results for seizure outcome[8,24,26,28,36,40]. Several authors insist that the the temporal pole has a pivotal role in epileptogenesis in temporomesial epilepsy[130,135,136].
The higher effectiveness of an extended resection beyond the LEAT might depend on the frequent association of this tumor type with other epileptogenic pathologies, such as the spectrum of cortical dysplasias that might represent the origin of a widespread epileptic network[8,24,34,36,68].
The new class FCD Type IIIb, which includes cases with abnormal cortical layering associated with a glial or glioneuronal tumor, has been introduced by the ILAE classification.
However in light of the frequent association of FCD Type II with LEAT and the immunohistochemical evidence of a common pathogenesis linking LEAT and FCD Type II[8,24,36,105], the possibility of creating a unifying class also for this kind of FCD should be considered.
With respect to oncological behavior, LEAT are usually indolent WHO Grade I lesions, although several reports have demonstrated that gangliogliomas may potentially have an evolving course and may demonstrate malignant transformation[33,40,70]. Pleomorphic xanthoastrocytoma can carry a higher risk of early recurrence when it is characterized by numerous mitoses and/or necrosis[137-139].
We believe that the adjective “long-term” included in the acronym LEAT could be prospectively confusing or misleading. Nowadays patients with LEAT are operated 5 years earlier compared to mid 1990s (mean of 7.4 years vs 12.9 years, respectively)[1,2].
The further increase in knowledge and a better recognition of these lesions among the scientific community (neurologists, epileptologists, neuropediatrics, neuroradiologists, epilepsy surgeons, neuropathologists) will lead to modify the present concept of “pharmacoresistance”vs a “tailored concept” of pharmacoresistance related to the underliyng pathology submitting many more patients to an early surgical treatment[107,132,140].
As a pathology-based approach to epilepsy surgery will be increasingly adopted[2,28,36,107,132,140,141] an early surgical treatment will become unavoidable.
In the near future this prototype of “surgically remediable cause of epilepsy” will be properly operated early, irrespective of the concept of pharmacoresistance, making the adjective “long-term” obsolete and not appropriated.
An early surgical strategy can achieve various aims, namely to obtain a definite diagnosis, to contrast epilepsy progression (including psychosocial consequences and/or adverse effects of pharmacological treatment) and even to prevent the risk, present although uncommon, of tumor growth and malignant transformation. In addition, early surgery may reduce the risk of sudden unexplained death (SUDEP) or seizure-related injuries.
Such predictable future approach will modify the clinical history of these patients, and features of epilepsy as “chronic” or “long term”, nowadays adopted in the definition of epilepsy-associated tumors, will loose sense. Neurophysiological aspects together with a proper histological and molecular characterization will become increasingly necessary for an accurate diagnosis of these epileptomas[25,34,85,142].
Therefore, what characterizes and makes up special for this group of tumors it is not the “chronic” or “long term” epilepsy history, but their pathological-biological features (i.e., sharing of immunopositivity for CD34 and of BRAF (V600E) mutation[109,143].