Chondromyxoid fibroma of the temporal bone: A case report and review of the literature

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Chondromyxoid fibroma (CMF) is a rare benign bone tumour of cartilaginous origin, which usually affects the metaphysis of the long bone. Involvement of the temporal bone is extremely rare. Patients with CMF in the temporal bone can present some neurological deficits due to involvement of surrounding neural structures.

CASE SUMMARY

We present the first case of histopathologically proven CMF originating in the temporal bone and involving the hypoglossal canal in a 40-year-old woman. Hypoglossal nerve paralysis was identified on the cranial nerve examination. The patient underwent surgical excision and was neurologically normal except for mild left facial palsy on 5-mo follow-up examination after surgery. In the current report, the major characteristics and computed tomography/magnetic resonance imaging features of the lesion are discussed. Furthermore, previous literature regarding this pathology is reviewed.

CONCLUSION

The current study presents the first case of temporal bone CMF involving the hypoglossal canal.

Key Words: Chondromyxoid fibroma, Temporal bone, Hypoglossal canal, Magnetic resonance imaging, Case report

Core tip: Chondromyxoid fibroma (CMF) involving the temporal bone is extremely rare. We herein present the first reported case of a histopathologically proven CMF originating in the temporal bone and involving the hypoglossal canal in a 40-year-old woman. The major characteristics and imaging features of the lesion are discussed in this report.

INTRODUCTION

Chondromyxoid fibromas (CMF), a rare benign bone tumour originating from cartilaginous tissue, more frequently arises in the metaphyseal region of long bones[1,2]. A CMF encountering in the skull base, especially in the temporal bone, is extremely rare[3]. Neurological deficits are unusual in temporal bone CMF until the tumour involves adjacent cranial nerves, such as facial nerve and vestibulocochlear nerve[4]. To the best of our knowledge, no cases of temporal bone CMF involving the hypoglossal nerve have previously been reported. Here we present a rare case of CMF originating in the temporal bone with the ipsilateral hypoglossal nerve, facial nerve and jugular foramen invaded simultaneously. Special attention is given to the major characteristics and computed tomography/magnetic resonance imaging (CT/MRI) features of temporal bone CMF. In addition, a review of the previous literature regarding this rare disease entity is presented. Written informed consent was provided by this patient.

CASE PRESENTATION

Chief complaints and history of present illness

A 40-year-old woman presented to our neurosurgery clinic with a 5-mo history of left facial nerve paralysis and a 3-mo history of dysphagia showing up as water choked coughing. She also reported a dysarthria for a period of 2 mo and a headache for 1 mo. The patient had no history of past illness, and had no family history of specific diseases.

Physical examination

The patient was noted to have an intact cranial nerve examination bilaterally. Hypalgesia was identified in the left half of her face. The tongue deviated to the left on attempted midline protrusion. The ipsilateral atrophy of the tongue was also identified.

Laboratory examinations

Measurements of routine laboratory examinations, including routine blood tests, routine urine tests and blood biochemistry, were within normal levels. No valuable laboratory data was found.

Imaging examinations

CT imaging revealed a lobulated soft tissue mass with a sclerotic rim and calcification. The tumour eroded the left mastoid air cells and the ipsilateral hypoglossal canal, as well as invaded the left mastoid portion of the facial nerve canal and jugular foramen (Figure 1). On magnetic resonance imaging without contrast enhancement, the lobulated lesion measured 4.4 cm × 2.3 cm × 4.0 cm and involved the left hypoglossal canal, exhibiting diffuse hypointensity on T1-weighted imaging and heterogeneous hyperintensity on T2-weighted imaging (Figure 2). The mastoid segment of the left facial nerve could not be demonstrated separately from the lesion. After contrast agent [gadolinium-diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (Gd-DTPA)] administration, the mass showed peripheral contrast enhancement, apart from the central area of hypointense that did not change in intensity.

Figure 1 Axial computed tomography scan demonstrates a well-defined mass with a sclerotic rim and a scalloped margin originating from the mastoid portion of the temporal bone. A: The ipsilateral hypoglossal canal (arrow head) and the jugular foramen (arrow) were eroded by the mass. The contralateral hypoglossal canal (blank arrow head) and the jugular foramen (blank arrow) were normal; B: The left mastoid portion of the facial nerve canal was invaded by the tumour (blank arrow). Intratumoral calcification was noted in the tumour (arrow head).

Figure 2 Magnetic resonance imaging findings of the lesion. A-C: The lesion is hypointensity on axial T1-weighted image (A, arrow), heterogeneous hyperintensity on axial T2-weighted image (B, arrow), and enhances peripherally (C, arrow); D, E: The coronal contrast enhanced MR images show that the tumour invaded the left hypoglossal canal (D, arrow) and the left jugular foramen (E, arrow). The contralateral hypoglossal canal (D, blank arrow) and the jugular foramen (E, blank arrow) were normal.

FINAL DIAGNOSIS

Histopathological analysis revealed a myxoid lesion consisting of cartilage material, admixed with bland stromal cells and fibroblastic tumoral cells. Immunohistochemical stains were positive for vimentin and S-100, but negative for GFAP and NF (Figure 3). These pathology results were consistent with a diagnosis of CMF.

Figure 3 High-power view of resected specimen showing a myxoid lesion consisting of cartilage material, admixed with spindle-shaped cells and bland stromal cells (H and E staining, ×200).

TREATMENT

Given uncertainty in diagnosis, the patient underwent mastoidectomy and surgical excision. At surgery, a left postauricular incision, which extended down to the level of the upper neck, was performed. Interfascial dissection was then used to expose the mastoid. The intraoperative appearance of the mass was irregular and lobulated with erosion of the mastoid air cells. Frank invasion of the ipsilateral hypoglossal canal and hypoglossal nerve was seen. The mastoid segment of the left facial nerve was compressed and invaded anteriorly by the mass. Using microscopic dissection and image guidance, excision of the tumour was performed. The portion of the tumour that had involved the hypoglossal canal and left facial nerve was also resected.

OUTCOME AND FOLLOW-UP

After the surgery, the patient reported improvement in dysphagia and dysarthria but still had some decreased sensation on the left side of the face and was discharged uneventfully. No other treatment was performed after the surgery. The patient was neurologically normal except for mild left facial palsy on 5-mo follow-up examination after surgery and no evidence of residual or recurrent lesion was identified on MRI scans (Figure 4).

Figure 4 Postoperative magnetic resonance imaging scans. A, B: The axial T1-weighted image (A) and gadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted image (B) show that the mass originated from the mastoid portion of the temporal bone and displayed contrast enhancement before it was excised (arrow).

DISCUSSION

CMF, a least common benign bone tumour characterized by chondral, myxoid and fibrous differentiation, is usually found in the metaphysis of long bones[5]. The temporal bone is an extremely rare location of CMF. Our review of the literature identifies that there have only been 13 reported CMF cases with the temporal bone involvement[1,3-14] (Table 1). CMF in the temporal bone is believed to arise from areas of synchondrosis and suture sites in the temporal bone which have embryonic cartilaginous residue[7]. Patients with skull base lesions usually present in the fourth decade of life[5]. In our case, the patient was 40 years old. The mean age of the patients in the 13 cases reported in previous studies was 36.54 years (range, 12 to 67 years). No gender predilection is found in temporal bone CMF[9]. Of these 13 patients reported, 8 patients are male.

Table 1 Summary of published cases of chondromyxoid fibroma in temporal bones.

Ref.	Location	Age/gender	Neurological symptoms/ abnormalities on physical examination	Treatment	Follow-up outcome
Oh et al[5]	Left mastoid, extending into left external auditory cannal	38/F	Hearing loss	Complete resection	Persistent conductive hearing loss
Sharma et al[6]	Left temporal region in the floor of the middle cranial fossa	12/F	Headache and left-sided otalgia	Complete resection	Completely relived
Gupta et al[7]	Left mastoid, eroding left bony canal of the facial nerve	42/M	Right-sided otalgia	NA	NA
Ozek et al[8]	Left petrous apex and left cerebellopontine angle	17/M	Headache, diplopia, left VI and VII cranial nerve paralysis and hearing loss	Subtotally resection	Mild left facial palsy and hearing loss
Thompson et al[3]	Left mastoid, eroding the left mastoid portion of the facial nerve canal	32/F	Left facial nerve paralysis	Complete resection	NA
Otto et al[9]	Right mastoid, eroding the posterior fossa plate	58/F	Vertigo and syncope	Complete resection	No evidence of recurrence 6 mo after operation
Tarhan et al[1]	Left temporal bone, tympanic region	44/F	Left facial pain	Complete resection	NA
Suzuki et al[10]	Left squamous temporal bone	49/M	Visual disturbance with right homonymous upper quadrantanopia	Preoperative embolization and resection	NA
Patino-Cordoba et al[11]	Left mastoid, eroding the external auditory canal	20/M	Hearing loss	Complete resection	NA
LeMay et al[4]	Left mastoid	22/M	Headache and left-sided otalgia	Resection via left temporal craniotomy	Persistent conductive hearing loss
Maruyama et al[12]	Right petrous temporal bone, extending into the jugular foramen	67/M	Right bulbar palsy, right facial palsy, complete right-sided hearing loss and trigeminal hypoesthesia	Incomplete resection due to jugular foramen involvement	Resolution of all cranial neuropathies except hearing loss and hoarseness
Kitamura et al[13]	Left mastoid, extending into the occipital bone and invading the foramen magnum and jugular foramen	48/M	Left aural fullness, tinnitus and transient dizziness	Staged resections (1 yr apart) secondary to bleeding	No recurrence 2 yr after first procedure
Frank et al[14]	Left petrous apex, extending into the sphenoid sinus, clinoid process, sella, cavernous sinus and retrosellar area	26/M	Diplopia and abducens nerve paresis	Complete resection	Resolution of abducens palsy

NA: Not available.

Depending on the location within the temporal bone, the presentation of these lesions are usually insidious and various. Headache, hearing loss, facial pain, facial nerve paralysis, otalgia, tinnitus, diplopia due to compression and involvement of the neural structures are described symptoms (Table 1). Our case is unusual in that the patient presented with hypoglossal nerve paralysis due to the involvement of the hypoglossal canal. A review of the English-language literature identified no reported cases of temporal bone CMF involving the hypoglossal canal. In addition, the patient complained of dysphagia and dysarthria, which may be due to the involvement of the ipsilateral jugular foramen and are the symptoms of IX and X cranial nerve compression. Maruyama et al[12] also reported a temporal bone lesion with the jugular foramen involved and the patient in that case also presented with dysphagia and dysarthria. There is a reported case of facial nerve paralysis directly related to the involvement of the facial nerve canal[3]. Facial nerve paralysis was noted in three of the temporal bone cases reported. The patient in our case also presented facial nerve paralysis due to the involvement of the facial nerve canal and facial nerve by the mass.

The CT and MRI are useful for the preoperative diagnosis and can show the borders of the temporal bone CMF and the relationship between tumour and surrounding structures. The imaging features of CMF in the temporal bone are well described[1,3,5-7,9,15]. CT imaging can effectively demonstrate the details of bone structures surrounding the lesion. Most CMFs in temporal bones on CT images are well-defined tumours with sclerotic rims and scalloped margins, but locally invading surrounding vital structures, such as cranial nerves[1]. Intratumoral calcification has been reported in up to 75% of CMFs of the skull base[3]. In our case, the intratumoral calcification was not only appreciated on CT images but also demonstrable histologically. MRI is superior to determining the extent of the disease. CMFs typically display hypointensity on T1-weighted imaging and heterogeneous hyperintensity on T2-weighted imaging. Heterogeneous T2 signal is attributed to varying chondroid, myxoid and fibrous elements within the lesion. Furthermore, temporal bone CMFs usually display gadolinium-based contrast enhancement. Similar CT and MRI observations were displayed in our case.

There is still a challenge for differentiating a CMF from other diagnostic considerations in patients with temporal bone lesions. The differential diagnoses would include chordoma, myxoid chondrosarcoma and facial nerve schwannoma (Table 2). It is not difficult to distinguish a CMF from a chordoma which usually arises from the central areas of the skull base and has more extraosseous extension[5]. Moreover, chordoma can be differentiated easily from CMF by immunohistochemistry. Chordoma usually expresses epithelial antigens such as keratin and epithelial membrane antigen, whereas CMF does not stain with antibodies against these proteins[16]. The distinction between a CMF and myxoid chondrosarcoma is important due to their different management. However, distinguishing a CMF from a myxoid chondrosarcoma can be difficult, as they have similar MRI features and both of them stain positively for S-100 protein on immunohistochemistry[9,11]. An obviously infiltrative growth pattern in addition to bone destruction may be useful to distinguish these two pathologies. Additionally, a chondrosarcoma would be unlikely in the temporal bone[5]. The typical pathological features of CMF are the biphasic arrangement of the myxoid or cartilaginous areas and the peripheral condensation of spindle and stellate cells with eosinophilic cytoplasm imparts a lobular silhouette, which are lacking in chondrosarcoma[17]. In order to decrease the risk of diagnostic error, an accurate diagnosis must be established on the basis of careful correlation of clinical, radiographic, pathological and immunohistochemical findings. A CMF in the mastoid portion of the temporal bone can mimic facial nerve schwannoma in this location. Thompson et al[3] reported that a CMF of the mastoid facial nerve canal which was misdiagnosed as a facial nerve schwannoma. Intratumoral calcification, which is less commonly seen in a facial nerve schwannoma, but has been reported in up to 75% of CMFs of the skull base, can be used to distinguish these two pathologies[3].

Table 2 The differential diagnosis of tumours in the temporal bone.

	Chondromyxoid fibroma	Myxoid chondrosarcoma	Chordoma	Facial nerve schwannoma
Pathological findings	Multilobular arrangement of stellate or spindle-shaped cells in an abundant myxoid background or chondroid intracellular material	Well-differentiated hyaline matrix; an absence of a fibrous component. The cells in chondrosarcoma are almost exclusively chondroblasts	Tumour cells are arranged in sheets or cords or float singly within an abundant myxoid stroma with an abundant pale vacuolated cytoplasm	Schwannoma is composed of spindle cells with wavy appearing nuclei. Areas of hypocellularity may alternate with areas of hypercellularity
Immunohistochemical findings	Positive staining for S-100 protein and vimentin	Positive staining for S-100 protein and vimentin	Positive staining for S-100 protein, pankeratin, low-molecular cytokeratins, and epithelial membrane antigen	Positive staining for S-100 protein
Radiographic findings	Well-defined tumours with sclerotic rims and scalloped margins; intratumoral calcification; low signal intensity on T1-weighted images and heterogeneous high signal intensity on T2-weighted images	Ill-defined tumours without sclerotic rims; an obviously infiltrative growth pattern and bone destruction; intratumoral calcification; low signal intensity on T1-weighted images and heterogeneous high signal intensity on T2-weighted images	Ill-defined tumours with obvious bone destruction; intratumoral calcification; low signal intensity on T1-weighted images and heterogeneous high signal intensity on T2-weighted images	Well-defined tumours without intratumoral calcification; isointensity to muscle on T1-weighted images and heterogeneous high signal intensity on T2-weighted images with well defined margins

Complete surgical resection should be the first treatment of choice for temporal bone CMFs[5,7,9]. The patients in our case underwent complete resection for the lesion and no evidence of recurrent lesion was found at 5-mo follow-up. Of the 13 reported cases of temporal bone CMF, 12 had been treated by surgical excision and no recurrent lesion was identified at follow-up. Radiation therapy is not considered as a primary treatment, because of the potential for inducing malignancy[5,9].

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, CMF of the temporal bone is a very rare benign tumour which can cause some neurological symptoms due to involvement of vital intracranial structures. The current study presents the first case of temporal bone CMF involving the hypoglossal canal. CT and MRI are necessary for preoperative diagnosis. An accurate diagnosis of CMF must be established on the basis of careful correlation of clinical, radiographic, pathological and immunohistochemical findings. Surgical excision is the treatment of choice for CMF in the temporal bone.