Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2019.
World J Clin Cases. Sep 26, 2019; 7(18): 2704-2711
Published online Sep 26, 2019. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v7.i18.2704
Table 1 Demographic characteristics of the combined group and control group
CharacteristicCombined groupControl groupt/χ2 valueP-value
Age (yr)48.958 ± 12.68550.208 ± 9.86-0.3810.705
Gender
Male/Female10/1415/92.0870.149
Body weight (kg)68.368 ± 9.73864.451 ± 8.6521.4730.148
ASA grade0.5430.762
I/II/III4/15/56/13/5
Incision length (cm)8.194 ± 0.4157.992 ± 0.4221.6740.101
Operative time136.083 ± 11.836135.833 ± 11.4840.0740.941
Intraoperative bleeding volume81.716 ± 14.73779.116 ± 14.5750.6150.542
Maximum diameter of tumors12.641 ± 5.07510.705 ± 4.8161.3560.182
Table 2 Visual analogue scale scores at rest and during movement, and cumulative sufentanil in the combined group and control group
Characteristic0 h6 h12 h24 h36 h48 h
VAS score at rest
Combined group2.421 ± 0.5682.24 ± 0.3942.064 ± 0.2151.984 ± 0.3791.967 ± 0.1521.997 ± 0.095
Control group2.853 ± 0.5662.619 ± 0.3732.448 ± 0.242.233±0.3532.398 ± 0.1631.957 ± 0.108
t-2.636-3.427-5.824-2.353-9.4561.349
P-value0.0110.001< 0.0010.023< 0.0010.184
VAS score during movement
Combined group3.281 ± 0.4513.375 ± 0.8163.359 ± 0.4923.176 ± 0.4613.033 ± 0.5382.967 ± 0.257
Control group3.715 ± 0.413.49 ± 0.6953.754 ± 0.6143.764 ± 0.6173.033 ± 0.613.061 ± 0.24
t-3.491-2.228-2.46-3.738-0.003-1.301
P-value0.0010.0370.0180.0010.9980.2
Cumulative sufentanil (μg)
Combined group-15.731 ± 2.47230.315 ± 4.01544.339 ± 6.36160.661 ± 3.77388.13 ± 7.49
Control group-15.288 ± 2.07230.085 ± 5.88450.408 ± 6.05670.325 ± 5.42394.01 ± 8.329
t-0.6730.159-3.385-7.166-2.572
P-value-0.5040.8750.001< 0.0010.013
Table 3 Recovery time for enterokinesia, postoperative nausea and vomiting, and hospital stay of the two groups
CharacteristicCombined groupControl grouptP-value
Recovery time for enterokinesia (d)2.944 ± 0.8963.954 ± 0.944-3.804< 0.001
PONA0.33450.8460
No PONA1311
Nausea without vomiting67
Nausea with vomiting56
Hospital stay (d)8.625 ± 2.50511.986 ± 3.908-3.5480.001