Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2016.
World J Transplant. Dec 24, 2016; 6(4): 790-797
Published online Dec 24, 2016. doi: 10.5500/wjt.v6.i4.790
Table 1 Main characteristics of the studies included in this meta-analysis
Ref.CountryYearTotal numberNo. of patients with kidney stoneTime of diagnosisSex of patients with stoneAge of patients with stoneDonorsStone locationStone compositionMean follow-up time
Cho et al[12]United States19885449Mean 14.7 mo, Median 7 mo (range 3-42 mo)6 male, 3 femaleMean 30 yr (range 8-65 yr)6 living, 3 cadaveric4 bladder, 3 kidney, 2 unknown4 calcium oxalate/calcium phosphate, 2 ammonium magnesium phosphate and carbonate appetite, 1 uric acid, 2 not studied5 (range 1.5-15.5) yr
Hayes et al[13]United States198989210Mean 13 mo (range 4-49 mo)7 male, 3 femaleMean 29 yr (range 17-53 yr)3 living, 7 cadavericNRNRNR
Harper et al[38]United Kingdom19941786NR4 male, 1 femaleNR4 living, 1 cadavericNR1 uric acid, 2 calcium phosphate, 1 calcium oxalate, 1 Magnesium ammonium phosphateNR
Shoskes et al[14]United Kingdom19958122Mean 3.5 yr (range 2-5 yr)NRMean 40 yrNR2 ureterNRAt least 1 yr
Benoit et al[36]France1996150012NR7 male, 5 femaleMean 36 yr2 living, 10 cadaveric5 calyces, 6 ureter, 1 pyeloureteral junction4 calcium oxalate and phosphate, 2 struviteNR
Del Pizzo et al[15]United States1998540 (445 renal transplant, 95 pancreas/renal transplant)4NRNRNRNRNRNR
Rhee et al[16]United States19991813 (1730 renal transplant, 83 pancreas/renal transplant)8NR4 male, 4 femaleMean 51 yr (range 34-60 yr)2 living, 1 cadaveric, 5 pancreas/renal3 kidney, 1 ureter, 4 bladder1 uric acid, 1 calcium oxalate, 1 calcium oxalate/calcium phosphate, 1 calcium phosphate, 1 struvite stone, 3 unknownMean 68.6 mo (range 27-98 mo)
El-Mekresh et al[17]Egypt2001120011NRNRNRNR3 kidney, 4 ureter, 4 bladderNRNR
Kim et al[18]United States200184915Mean 17.8 mo (range 3-109 mo)10 male, 5 femaleMean 41.5 yr (range 28-67 yr)8 living, 7 cadaveric11 bladder, 3 kidney, 1 multiple sites5 mixed form of calcium oxalate and calcium phosphate, 1 calcium oxalate, 3 predominant calcium phosphate, 2 struvite, 2 mixed form of struvite and calcium phosphate, 2 not studiedMean 58 mo (range 11-149 mo)
Klinger et al[19]Austria2002102719 (4 diagnosis during transplant, 5 perioperative, 10 de novo)For de novo: Mean 27.7 mo (range 13 to 48 mo)8 male, 11 femaleMean 48.1 yr (range 26-72 yr)1 living, 18 cadaveric14 kidney, 3 infundibulum, 1 distal ureter, 1 staghorn11 calcium oxalate, 2 uric acid, 1 calcium phosphate, 5 not studiedMean 29 mo (range 14-48 mo)
Doehn et al[20]Germany2002150011NR5 male, 6 femaleMedian 50 yr11 cadavericNR3 uric acid, 3 calcium oxalate, 2 magnesium ammonium stone, 3 not studiedMedian 4 yr
Streeter et al[21]United Kingdom2002153512For renal calculi: Median 150 d (range 56-1280 d); For bladder calculi: Range 8 mo - 4 yrNRNRNR9 ureter, 3 bladderNRNR
Abbott et al[22]United States20034290652NRNRNR35 kidney, 17 ureterNR1.89 ± 1.15 yr
Lipke et al[23]United States200450079 mo (range 1.5-26 mo)7 femaleMean 50 yr (range 8-73 yr)4 living, 3 cadaveric7 bladder7 mixed between calcium oxalate and calcium phosphateNR
Yigit et al[24]Turkey20041255 (2 preoperative, 1 early posttransplant, 2 de novo)For de novo: Mean 6.5 mo (range 6-7 mo)3 male, 2 femaleMean 35.2 yrNRNR2 calcium oxalate, 1 uric acid, 2 infectiousMean 32.4 mo
Challacombe et al[25]United Kingdom20052085213.7 (0.17-18) yr8 male, 13 femaleMean 41 yr (range 15-64 yr)3 living, 18 cadeveric13 kidney, 7 ureter, 1 bladderNRNR
Ferreira Cassini et al[26]Brazil2012131312 de novoRange 6 mo to 13 yr8 males, 9 femalesMean 45.6 yr (range 32-63 yr)2 living, 15 cadaveric6 calyces, 3 renal pelvis, 3 ureterNRNR
Stravodimos et al[27]Greece201215257Mean 3.2 (2-7) yrNRNRNR5 kidney, 2 ureterNRMean 8 yr
Cicerello et al[40]Italy201495310NR4 male, 6 femaleMean 43 yrNR7 kidney, 3 ureterNRNR
Mamarelis et al[28]Greece201420459Mean 3.1 yr (range 1-7 yr)NRNRNR6 kidney, 3 ureterNR6.6 yr (range 1-15 yr)
Rezaee-Zavereh et al[29]Iran201557425NRNRNRNRNRNR55 ± 53 mo