Observational Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Transplant. Dec 24, 2015; 5(4): 338-347
Published online Dec 24, 2015. doi: 10.5500/wjt.v5.i4.338
Table 1 Characteristics of kidney donors and recipients
Everolimus (n = 59)Azathioprine/MMF (n = 114)P value
Donor
Age (yr)38.4 ± 13.744.1 ± 13.0< 0.01
Male gender30 (51%)65 (57%)0.44
Living15 (25%)14 (12%)0.03
Non-living44 (75%)100 (88%)0.03
Extended criteria donor5 (9%)20 (18%)0.11
Stroke as donor's cause of death10 (23%)28 (28%)0.51
Hypertension3 (5%)22 (19%)0.01
Type 2 diabetes0 (0%)4 (4%)0.15
Serum creatinine (mg/dL)0.83 ± 0.260.90 ± 0.360.19
Cold ischemia time (h)18.9 ± 5.420.1 ± 7.10.33
Warm ischemia time (min)37.3 ± 9.2541.3 ± 11.20.02
Recipient
Age (yr)43.1 ± 12.545.0 ± 12.10.35
Male gender32 (54%)79 (69%)0.05
List waiting time (mo)27.9 ± 22.730.4 ± 28.30.57
Previous kidney transplant0 (0%)0 (0%)
Total time in dialysis (mo)49.0 ± 26.558.4 ± 33.60.57
PRA (%)3.0 ± 4.33.8 ± 5.20.35
HLA-mismatch2.9 ± 1.42.8 ± 1.20.68
Double kidney transplant1 (2%)5 (4%)0.36
Hypertension42 (71%)79 (69%)0.80
Type 2 diabetes0 (0%)7 (6%)0.10
Coronary artery disease1 (2%)1 (1%)0.63
IgG CMV (+)56 (97%)98 (88%)0.06
Immunosuppressive treatment
Induction0 (0%)1 (1%)0.47
Cyclosporine59 (100%)114 (100%)
Azathioprine59 (100%)111 (97%)0.21
Mycophenolate mofetyl0 (0%)3 (3%)0.21
Delayed graft function3 (5%)65 (57%)< 0.01
Table 2 Follow up clinical findings and complications n (%)
Everolimus (n = 59)Azathioprine/MMF (n = 114)P value
Surgical complication11 (19)25 (22)0.61
Vascular complication2 (3)10 (9)0.22
First year acute rejection episode6 (10)25 (22)0.06
Acute rejection episode during entire follow up period12 (20)41 (36)0.04
Cyclosporine toxicity8 (14)22 (19)0.35
New onset diabetes after transplant3 (5)8 (7)0.75
CMV disease0 (0)6 (5.3)0.10
BK virus nephropathy1 (2)5 (4)0.67
New onset neoplasia2 (3)6 (5)0.72
Post-transplant Lymphoproliferative disease1 (2)2 (2)0.98
Hospitalizations/yr0.50 ± 0.720.62 ± 0.780.32
Leucopenia12 (20)58 (51)< 0.01
Thrombocytopenia29 (49)73 (64)0.06
Pneumonia6 (10)25 (22)0.06
Urinary tract infection27 (46)46 (40)0.49
Table 3 Graft survival uncensored by recipient death with a functioning graft at different periods after kidney transplant
TimeEverolimus (n = 59)Azathioprine/MMF (n = 114)
Year 198%97%
Year 298%94%
Year 396%93%
Year 494%88%
Year 594%86%
Year 691%83%
Table 4 Graft survival censored by recipient death with a functioning graft at different periods after kidney transplant
TimeEverolimus (n = 59)Azathioprine/MMF (n = 114)
Year 1100%97%
Year 2100%94%
Year 398%93%
Year 496%88%
Year 596%88%
Year 693%83%