Observational Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2022.
World J Psychiatry. May 19, 2022; 12(5): 722-738
Published online May 19, 2022. doi: 10.5498/wjp.v12.i5.722
Table 1 Relationship of Patient Health Questionnaire-9 items and depression
PHQ-9 item
Score
Mild (n = 139)
Moderate (n = 49)
Moderately severe (n = 22)
Severe (n = 11)
n
Percent
n
Percent
n
Percent
n
Percent
Item 103223.0224.0800.0000.00
16748.201122.45522.7319.09
23625.902755.101045.45218.18
342.88918.37731.82872.73
Item 206244.60816.3314.5500.00
16244.601428.57418.1800.00
21510.792448.981463.64327.27
300.0036.12313.64872.73
Item 30107.1900.0000.0019.09
14129.501224.4929.0900.00
25237.411938.78940.9119.09
33625.901836.731150.00981.82
Item 401712.2336.1200.0000.00
16647.48918.3714.5500.00
24834.532857.141045.4519.09
385.76918.371150.0011100.00
Item 506949.641020.41313.6400.00
14935.252040.82522.73327.27
21913.671734.69731.8219.09
321.4424.08731.82763.64
Item 6010273.381632.6529.09218.18
13223.022448.98522.7300.00
242.88918.371045.4519.09
310.7200.00522.73872.73
Item 708561.151530.6114.5500.00
14431.651734.6929.0919.09
296.471428.571254.55218.18
310.7236.12731.82872.73
Item 8010575.541734.69627.2700.00
12820.142551.02522.7300.00
253.60612.24940.91327.27
310.7212.0429.09872.73
Item 9013496.404081.631359.09327.27
153.60714.29522.73545.45
200.0024.0829.0919.09
300.0000.0029.09218.18
Table 2 Relationship of Pittsburgh sleep quality index components and depression
PSQI index
Score
Without (n = 190)
With (n = 221)
Mild (n = 139)
Moderate (n = 49)
Moderately severe (n = 22)
Severe (n = 11)
n
Percent
n
Percent
n
Percent
n
Percent
n
Percent
n
Percent
Subjective sleep quality000.0031.3621.4412.0400.0000.00
18745.792712.222215.8348.1614.5500.00
29449.4714666.069467.633367.351150.00872.73
394.744520.362115.111122.451045.45327.27
Sleep latency094.7483.6232.1648.1614.5500.00
15227.373114.032316.55510.20313.6400.00
27740.536931.224532.371326.53836.36327.27
35227.3711351.136848.922755.101045.45872.73
Sleep duration04624.213917.652719.42612.24418.18218.18
16232.636830.774230.221938.78418.18327.27
25931.056027.153928.061326.53836.3600.00
32312.115424.433122.301122.45627.27654.55
Habitual sleep efficiency06433.684821.723424.461020.41313.6419.09
14423.164219.002719.421020.41418.1819.09
24121.584821.722820.141224.49418.18436.36
34121.588337.565035.971734.691150.00545.45
Sleep disturbances031.5820.9010.7212.0400.0000.00
115481.0513561.099971.222551.02836.36327.27
23216.847935.753726.622244.901359.09763.64
310.5352.2621.4412.0414.5519.09
Use of sleeping medications08544.749040.726345.321938.78627.27218.18
12814.74156.7996.4748.1614.5519.09
24322.634018.103223.02816.3300.0000.00
33417.897634.393525.181836.731568.18872.73
Daytime dysfunction016184.749442.537151.081836.73522.7300.00
12714.218438.015338.131836.73940.91436.36
221.053716.741410.071224.49627.27545.45
300.0062.7110.7212.0429.09218.18
Table 3 Comparison of diseases status between without depression and with depression groups, n (%)
Diseases
Status
Without depression
With depression
P value
Diagnosed depressionYes17 (8.95)52 (23.53)< 0.001
No173 (91.05)169 (76.47)
Chronic diseasesYes60 (31.58)68 (30.77)0.86
No130 (68.42)153 (69.23)
High blood pressureYes100 (52.63)114 (51.58)0.83
No90 (47.37)107 (48.42)
DiabetesYes49 (25.79)58 (26.24)0.92
No141 (74.21)163 (73.76)
Coronary heart diseaseYes21 (11.05)42 (19)0.03
No169 (88.95)179 (81)
Cerebrovascular diseaseYes14 (7.37)25 (11.31)0.17
No176 (92.63)196 (88.69)
Enlarged prostateYes9 (4.74)14 (6.33)0.48
No181 (95.26)207 (93.67)
CancerYes6 (3.16)8 (3.62)0.80
No184 (96.84)213 (96.38)
Mental illnessYes1 (0.53)12 (5.43)0.01
No189 (99.47)209 (94.57)
TuberculosisYes0 (0)1 (0.45)0.35
No190 (100)220 (99.55)
Chronic hepatitisYes1 (0.53)3 (1.36)0.39
No189 (99.47)218 (98.64)
CirrhosisYes3 (1.58)2 (0.9)0.53
No187 (98.42)219 (99.1)
Table 4 Comparison of general characteristics between without depression and with depression groups, n (%)
Characteristics
Status
Without depression
With depression
P value
GenderMale51 (26.84)55 (24.89)0.65
Female139 (73.16)166 (75.11)
Age (yr)59.36 ± 7.4659.66 ± 8.360.71
EducationElementary school and below2 (1.05)4 (1.81)0.04
Junior high school25 (13.16)52 (23.53)
Secondary school or high school73 (38.42)66 (29.86)
University and above90 (47.37)99 (44.8)
Marital statusUnmarried6 (3.16)10 (4.52)0.05
Married170 (89.47)178 (80.54)
Divorced5 (2.63)18 (8.14)
Widowed9 (4.74)15 (6.79)
Living situationLiving alone11 (5.79)36 (16.29)0.002
Live with husband or wife113 (59.47)112 (50.68)
Live with children61 (32.11)60 (27.15)
Other5 (2.63)13 (5.88)
OccupationalOn-the-job55 (28.95)49 (22.17)0.29
Retire130 (68.42)166 (75.11)
Unemployed5 (2.63)6 (2.71)
Income (yuan)0-20004 (2.11)9 (4.07)0.09
2000-4000 53 (27.89)81 (36.65)
4000-600071 (37.37)78 (35.29)
≥ 6000 62 (32.63)53 (23.98)
Exercise Yes150 (78.95)138 (62.44)< 0.001
No40 (21.05)83 (37.56)
Table 5 Comparison of insomnia related characteristics between without depression and with depression groups, n (%)
Indicator
Status
Without depression
With depression
P value
Years of insomnia5.21 ± 6.067.35 ± 7.48< 0.001
Western medicine treatmentYes102 (53.68)143 (64.71)0.02
No88 (46.32)78 (35.29)
Chinese medicine treatmentYes82 (43.16)143 (64.71)< 0.001
No108 (56.84)78 (35.29)
PsychotherapyYes6 (3.16)25 (11.31)0.002
No184 (96.84)196 (88.69)
Kinds of insomniaDifficult to fall asleep89 (46.84)140 (63.35)< 0.001
Difficult to deep sleep20 (10.53)16 (7.24)
Easy to wake up53 (27.89)36 (16.29)
Wake up early28 (14.74)29 (13.12)
Events related to insomniaWork pressure42 (22.11)40 (18.1)0.10
Family life58 (30.53)66 (29.86)
Disease related49 (25.79)82 (37.1)
Sleep environment37 (19.47)31 (14.03)
Interpersonal communication4 (2.11)2 (0.9)
Treatment expected to treat insomniaWestern medicine53 (27.89)36 (16.29)< 0.001
Traditional Chinese Medicine97 (51.05)133 (60.18)
Psychotherapy14 (7.37)36 (16.29)
Other26 (13.68)16 (7.24)
Traditional Chinese medicine foot bathYes50 (26.32)49 (22.17)0.33
No140 (73.68)172 (77.83)
AcupressureYes51 (26.84)50 (22.62)0.32
No139 (73.16)171 (77.38)
Psychological counselingYes1 (0.53)19 (8.6)< 0.001
No189 (99.47)202 (91.4)
Medicated dietYes16 (8.42)28 (12.67)0.17
No174 (91.58)193 (87.33)
Tai ChiYes11 (5.79)5 (2.26)0.07
No179 (94.21)216 (97.74)
Traditional Chinese medicineYes93 (48.95)120 (54.3)0.28
No97 (51.05)101 (45.7)
Other traditional Chinese medicineYes17 (8.95)16 (7.24)0.53
No173 (91.05)205 (92.76)
Habit of 1 hour before bedElectronic products79 (41.58)125 (56.56)< 0.001
Reading news or papers31 (16.32)22 (9.95)
Chat7 (3.68)10 (4.52)
Fitness0 (0)1 (0.45)
None12 (6.32)26 (11.76)
Watch TV61 (32.11)37 (16.74)
Habit of drinking teaYes57 (30)81 (36.65)0.16
No133 (70)140 (63.35)
Habit of drinking coffeeYes38 (20)35 (15.84)0.27
No152 (80)186 (84.16)
Habit of drinking spiritsYes3 (1.58)10 (4.52)0.09
No187 (98.42)211 (95.48)
Habit of smokingYes24 (12.63)19 (8.6)0.18
No166 (87.37)202 (91.4)
Habit of lunch breakYes52 (27.37)82 (37.1)< 0.001
No138 (72.63)139 (62.9)
Table 6 Logistic analysis of depression and the significant characteristics
Characteristics
Univariate analysis
Multivariate analysis
Wals
P value
OR
95% CI of OR
Wals
P value
OR
95% CI of OR
Lower
Upper
Lower
Upper
Education5.580.020.710.540.946.080.010.710.550.93
Living situation0.380.540.910.671.23
Exercise 5.630.021.811.112.959.89< 0.0012.091.323.31
Years of insomnia3.400.071.031.001.07
Western medicine treatment1.050.310.790.501.24
Chinese medicine treatment0.700.401.200.781.82
Psychotherapy1.300.250.530.181.57
Kinds of insomnia5.950.010.790.650.958.79< 0.0010.760.630.91
Treatment expected to treat insomnia0.740.391.120.871.44
Psychological counseling2.960.090.150.021.30
Habit of 1 hour before bed3.970.040.900.811.005.480.020.890.810.98
Habit of lunch break0.120.731.080.681.71
Diagnosed depression4.640.030.480.240.9412.94< 0.0010.320.170.60
Coronary heart disease 5.910.020.460.250.867.430.010.430.230.79
Mental illness2.870.090.160.021.34