Theco-thecal bypass technique elucidating a novel procedure and perspective on treatment of post-arachnoiditis syringomyelia: A case report

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Post-arachnoiditis syringomyelia is a condition in which there is an intraspinal cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) blockade due to arachnoidal adhesions and bands. Although many of the techniques currently in use, namely, the theco-peritoneal, syringo-pleural, syringo-peritoneal, and syringo-subarachnoid shunts, are effective, the results are often variable.

CASE SUMMARY

A 36-year-old man with a past history of pulmonary tuberculosis, presented with progressive paraesthesia in the feet and progressive paraparesis along with constipation, difficulty in micturition, and decreased libido. He was bedridden a month before presentation. Magnetic resonance imaging revealed a dorsal multiloculated syrinx from D3-D10 vertebral levels. He underwent a D1-2 to D11 theco-thecal shunt bilaterally to abolish the CSF gradient across the level of the syrinx. There was no direct surgical handling of the spinal cord involved. At the 15-mo follow up, the patient had significant improvement in his symptoms and function.

CONCLUSION

We present a novel technique aimed at correcting the primary cause of a post-arachnoiditis syrinx, the subarachnoid cerebrospinal flow obstruction or block, which we believe is simple and effective, involves minimal handling of the normal neural structures, and attempts to restore the physiology of CSF flow across the obstruction, with favorable clinical results.

Key Words: Syringomyelia, Tubercular, Arachnoiditis, Adhesiolysis, Minimally invasive, Cerebrospinal fluid, Case report

Core Tip: Theco-thecal bypass technique was envisaged to achieve a long lasting zero net pressure difference via free flow of cerebrospinal fluid above and below the level of spinal subarachnoid adhesions with minimal handling of the spinal cord and avoidance of extensive adhesiolysis that is associated with a high rate of re-adhesions and failure. This surgical technique involves a valve-less shunt conduit connecting the subarachnoid space above and below the level of adhesions and thereby abolishing the trans-mural pressure gradient causing the syringomyelia, leading to a drastic clinical improvement, as elaborated in this case report.

INTRODUCTION

A syrinx is a fluid-filled cavity that anatomically lies within the spinal cord parenchyma. Syringomyelia, at its core, is a disorder of abnormal cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) circulation[1]. This entity is most frequently associated with Chiari-I malformations (C-I-M)[2]. Other less frequent pathologies include spinal cord tumors and post-traumatic or infectious adhesive arachnoiditis[3,4].

Despite the several proposed etiopathogenetic mechanisms and therefore a number of different treatment strategies[5], the management of post-arachnoiditis syringomyelia remains a challenge. The presence of multiple loculations and arachnoid adhesions is the likely cause of treatment failures and poor prognosis in these patients[6]. The principle of the surgery in post-inflammatory arachnoid scarring is directed toward reconstituting the spinal subarachnoid CSF flow[7]. Microsurgical lysis of arachnoid adhesions and local decompression of the subarachnoid space via laminectomy and duraplasty were found to significantly benefit surgical outcomes[4]. Gottschalk et al[8] emphasized the importance of minimally invasive treatments and highlighted the risks involved in spinal adhesiolysis, namely, postoperative scarring within the subarachnoid space and a consequent worsening of symptoms leading to a high failure rate[9]. Syrinx shunting procedures carry an inherent risk involved during myelotomy[10].

We present the case of a patient with post-arachnoiditis syringomyelia who was treated surgically by reconstituting CSF flow without passing through the adhesion zone, using a theco-thecal bypass. This new technique, its theoretical safety, and clinical efficacy are described in detail.

CASE PRESENTATION

Chief complaints

A 36-year-old Indian man presented with progressive paraesthesia and dysesthesia in the plantar aspect of both feet for 3 years, along with progressive paraparesis and low backache.

History of present illness

The patient was bedridden a month before presentation and was brought in on a wheelchair. He also complained of constipation, difficulty and straining while micturating, and decreased libido.

History of past illness

The patient was diagnosed with pulmonary tuberculosis 20 years ago, had received anti-tubercular treatment for 6 mo as per national protocols, and was declared cured. Treatment was sought after 3 years of onset symptoms in view of recent aggravation.

Personal and family history

The family history was unremarkable.

Physical examination

A neurological examination revealed normal upper extremity power, reflexes, and sensations bilaterally. There was mild dissociated sensory loss below the D4 dermatome along with spastic paraparesis with a modified Medical Research Council (mMRC) grade 2 power in the right and grade 3 in the left lower limb muscle groups. Grade 4 spasticity as per the modified Ashworth Spasticity Score (mASS) was noted in bilateral lower limbs along with exaggerated deep tendon reflexes and extensor plantar responses.

Laboratory examinations

The routine hematological workup, including complete blood counts, and renal and hepatic function tests were normal.

Imaging examinations

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the dorsal spine was performed with whole spine screening, which revealed a multiloculated syrinx from D3-D10 vertebral levels with a CSF loculation anterior to the lower cervical and upper dorsal cord (Figure 1).

Figure 1 T2 sagittal magnetic resonance imaging sequence showing a multiloculated syrinx from D3-D11. Arrow points to a subtle loculation of cerebrospinal fluid anterior to the lower cervical and upper dorsal cord.

There were features of extensive subarachnoid adhesions in the form of greatly varying peri-myelic CSF along with areas of absent CSF intensity. To minimize cord handling and avoid extensive adhesiolysis with its associated risks, a first-in-human theco-thecal bypass procedure (TTBP) was performed after obtaining informed consent from the patient and due permission from the local institutional body. The patient's consent for publication was also obtained at this stage.

FINAL DIAGNOSIS

A final diagnosis of post-arachnoiditis syringomyelia was made.

TREATMENT

To minimize cord handling and avoid extensive adhesiolysis with its associated risks, a first-in-human TTBP was performed after obtaining informed consent from the patient and due permission from the local institutional body. The patient's consent for publication was also obtained at this stage.

The surgery was performed by a senior neurosurgeon and a spine surgeon at a tertiary care community center. The laminectomy level above and below the extent of syringomyelia was marked on the previous day under CT guidance for precision and to reduce operative time. The entry points both above at D1-2, and below at D11-12 were selected based on sagittal MRI films, away from areas of possible adhesions in order to ensure a free passage of the shunt tube within the subarachnoid space. The patient was positioned prone on bolsters in a standard fashion as for a dorsal laminectomy. Preoperative preparation, prepping, and draping were performed. In addition to laminectomy instruments, a regular adult ventriculoperitoneal shunt ‘tunneller’ and basic micro-neurosurgical and spinal instruments were kept ready. Silicone tubes of the distal catheters of a shunt system with valves subtracted were obtained from two ventriculoperitoneal shunt sets (Chhabra, Hydrocephalus Shunt System, Surgiwear, India). Each conduit was fashioned on the table considering three principal measurements: (1) Length inside the theca above and below of arbitrarily 4-5 cm on each side; (2) Distance from the durotomy to subcutaneous tissue at the proximal and distal end; and (3) Intermediate-length from one laminectomy incision site to another. A connector and further tubing were used until the desired length was obtained.

Five 1-mm fenestrations were made with fine micro-scissors over a length of 3-5 cm from either end of the conduit in an equidistant helical fashion. No two fenestrations were in close approximation or in one horizontal or vertical plane. Such an arrangement ensured the structural stability of the tube and minimized the risk of tube collapse or kinks (Figure 2).

Figure 2  Shunt conduits are prepared and ends fenestrated in a helical fashion to ensure adequate flow of cerebrospinal fluid and minimize the risk of obstruction while also maintaining structural stability.

The goal of surgery was to achieve a long-lasting zero net pressure difference via a free flow of CSF above and below the level of spinal subarachnoid adhesions, mimicking a physiological subarachnoid environment and reversing pathological forces leading to syringomyelia. Therefore, it is imperative that no valve be used while designing the conduit.

Surgical procedure

Using two midline incisions approximately 4 cm in length, the D1, superior aspect of D2, and the D11 laminae were exposed subperiosteally. Depending on the laterality and ease of access, bony work may range from a limited unilateral fenestration to a complete laminectomy (Figure 3).

Figure 3 Various approaches to the thecal sac. A unilateral fenestration (A) may suffice for unilateral theco-thecal shunts whereas a bilateral fenestration (B) or complete laminectomy (C) may be employed in bilaterally placed conduits.

Limited midline D1, partial D2, and D11 vertebral laminectomies were performed until adequate thecal tube was visualized at both levels. Connecting passages were created by subcutaneous tunneling with the help of an adult ventriculoperitoneal shunt tunneller to emerge at either side of the incision and positioned at the mouth of each incision (Figure 4).

Figure 4 Connecting passages created by subcutaneous tunneling with the help of an adult ventriculoperitoneal shunt tunneller. A: One after another, both conduits were positioned in the subcutaneous plane on either side of the midline, using an adult ventriculoperitoneal shunt tunneller. The right conduit is seen in place (white arrow) and the tunneller is in use to position the left shunt (yellow arrow); B: Both conduits were placed in the subcutaneous plane and emerged on either side of the incision with fat pads (arrowheads) placed a few centimeters from the tip to help seal the dural entry.

Fat cuffs harvested from the surrounding subcutaneous tissues were placed to rest a few centimeters proximal to the catheter ends. The conduits were pre-flushed with sterile Amikacin-saline and kept fluid-filled to eliminate any air pockets. Two 2-3 mm nicks were made in the dura on either side of the midline at the upper dorsal and lower dorsal exposed levels. The incisions were just adequate to permit free entry and further passage of the catheter tubes to the predetermined extent. Care was taken to ensure that the catheter fenestrations were well within the theca to preclude CSF egress into the surgical wound cavity. The four ends of tubing were inserted through four small durotomies which were sealed with the help of Tisseel fibrin glue (Baxter, Illinois, United States) and fat grafts (Figure 5).

Figure 5 The tubes have been inserted into the theca on both sides of the midline approximately 7-10 mm apart (orange arrowhead). An adequate intradural length is ensured (orange arrow) and fat grafts are lowered (black arrowhead) over a fibrin seal to augment the sealing (Inset Image).

The tubes were secured with silicone collars to the fascia. Incisions were closed after ensuring hemostasis and antibiotic-saline lavages in a routine layered fashion.

OUTCOME AND FOLLOW-UP

The patient was discharged on the second postoperative day and had an uneventful surgical recovery. Plain radiographs confirmed the levels and structural continuity of the conduits (Figure 6).

Figure 6  Postoperative plain spine radiographs (AP and lateral) confirming the intraspinal position above at D1-D2 level and below at D11 level (white arrows) along with the continuous subcutaneous track of the conduits and intrathecal portion visible.

At the 4-mo follow-up, the patient had a 50% reduction in the burning and tingling sensations in his feet, improved sensations of temperature and pain, and a subjective reduction in stiffness by 30%-40% in his legs. Objectively, spasticity had decreased to an mASS grade 3 in the right lower limb and to grade 2 in the left lower limb. Power had improved to mMRC grade 3 in the right lower limb and grade 4 in the left lower limb muscle groups and he could stand with support. There was a significant improvement in the bowel-bladder functions and improved libido. Deep tendon reflexes remained exaggerated and bilateral plantars showed extensor responses.

An MRI scan obtained at this stage showed subtle changes in the morphology of loculated CSF anterior to the lower cervical and upper dorsal cord with no significant change in the size or shape of the syrinx (Figure 7).

Figure 7 Magnetic resonance imaging images. T2 weighted sagittal (A and B) and axial magnetic resonance imaging sequences (C and D) at a 4-mo interval showed the upper entry of conduit into the thecal space above and below the level of the syrinx (yellow arrows). No interval change was noted in the size of the syrinx, although a significant clinical and functional improvement was noted.

The patient has since returned to his remote village and on telephonic follow-up at 15 mo, the time of writing this article, the patient had a near-total reduction in the sensory discomfort in his feet, significantly improved temperature and pain sensations in lower limbs, and reduced stiffness in lower limbs by 70%-80%. Bowel and bladder functions, as well as libido, had returned to normal. He was ambulant with minimal support and had near-complete recovery of his lower limb power with a drastic functional improvement. There was no evidence of conduit infection, malfunction, or any other procedure-related complication.

DISCUSSION

Current treatment modalities and challenges

The challenges involved in treating syringomyelia due to tubercular arachnoiditis are well known and several procedures are currently employed to address themwith no conclusively efficacious treatment[7,9,11]. Current shunting techniques including syringo-pleural, syringo-peritoneal, and syringo-subarachnoid shunts decompress the syrinx by draining it into an ‘external’ non-neurological space like the pleura or peritoneum or into an ‘internal’ neurological adjoining subarachnoid compartment. The theco-peritoneal or lumbo-peritoneal shunt is an external diversion of CSF from spinal subarachnoid space to the peritoneum. It provides an alternative path of low resistance to CSF flow and thus, in theory, decreases the spinal cord trans-mural pressure and halts syrinx progression.

In patients with post-inflammatory arachnoid scarring and post-traumatic syringomyelia, the operative procedure is directed toward reconstituting spinal subarachnoid CSF flow by arachnoid scar membrane resection, microsurgical lysis of arachnoid adhesions, and dural reconstruction[12,13]. As extensive spinal adhesiolysis can lead to postoperative scarring within the subarachnoid space, any surgery for this condition should be as minimally invasive as possible[8].

TTBP

The TTBP described herewith addresses the question of this intraspinal CSF block in a simple minimally invasive fashion. The procedure was developed on the principle that the pathological mechanism directly causing the syrinx is CSF flow obstruction and pressure imbalance within the subarachnoid compartment. Treatments aimed at adhesiolysis carry a high rate of re-scarring and failure. This method reconstitutes the CSF flow from the normal-above to the normal-below subarachnoid space, bypassing the pathological area of obstruction, and proposes to normalize CSF pressure hydrodynamics across the area of the blockade. Exposure or handling of the syrinx affected and compromised spinal cord is entirely avoided. The procedure is simple, effective, and in theory, less hazardous than physical manipulation involved in a microsurgical procedure, of an already disturbed spinal cord region. It employs existing low-cost silicone implants that are in common use and combines techniques of laminectomy, shunt tunneling, etc., familiar to most neurosurgeons worldwide.

The use of two conduits in our case was to maintain the functionality and physiology of uninterrupted CSF flow in the scenario of one conduit being inadvertently blocked. As in foramen magnum decompression procedures for symptomatic C-I-M with syringomyelia[14], collapse of the syrinx and visible resolution on imaging are expected to be delayed and might not always occur, as the pathological cavity is not directly deroofed or decompressed.

Pathophysiology of the procedure

The clinical benefit in our patient is possibly the result of lowered pressure in the syrinx cavity and an arrest of its progression leading to the gradual restoration of spinal cord function. Altered CSF dynamics is known to be a causative factor in syringomyelia[15] and it is speculated that the rostrocaudal CSF pulse wave is misdirected into the spinal cord parenchyma. The resulting high trans-mural pressure and decreased compliance of the subarachnoid space favor the flow of fluid into the spinal cord, possibly through perivascular spaces, resulting in a destructive cavitation process and eventually the formation of a syrinx cavity[16-19]. We posit that the insertion of a fluid diverting shunt in our surgical procedure could attenuate and possibly redirect this misdirected rostrocaudal CSF pulse wave and consequently have a bearing on pressure hydrodynamics in the syrinx cavity. In surgical procedures directed towards optimization of CSF dynamics and no direct drainage of the syrinx cavity, patients may experience significant improvement in clinical symptoms in the absence of complete syrinx resolution on imaging[20]. Hence, with regard to different surgical procedures for syringomyelia, clinical outcome, rather than radiological improvement, is the more appropriate indicator of the surgical result[10,21,22].

Future scope and improvisation

We acknowledge the need for larger randomized control studies with a longer follow-up period before TTBP can be established as a regular treatment for post-arachnoiditis syringomyelia. With refinements and further controlled trials, one conduit may possibly suffice for the optimization of CSF flow. Evolutions in the method by utilizing minimally invasive techniques in spine surgery, using preformed factory generated perforated tube endings and innovative percutaneous manipulations in the lumbar region for intrathecal tube insertion, are promising.

CONCLUSION

The TTBP is a novel simple technique that may be used to treat certain cases of syringomyelia secondary to arachnoiditis. The procedure aims at reversing the direct pathology of altered CSF dynamics and increased transmural pressure leading to a syrinx. In selected patients, advantages over currently employed methods include minimal handling of the spinal cord, avoidance of extensive adhesiolysis and its associated complications, and a small incision minimally invasive approach with a shorter operative time.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

We acknowledge assistance from Dr. Amit Jain, MS (Ortho) during the procedure and help from Dr. Priyam B, MD and Dr. Salila MB, MBBS for their guidance and assistance in the preparation of this manuscript. We also acknowledge the contribution of the late Dr. US Vengsarkar, our teacher and one of the first neurosurgeons in the world to pioneer the use of the theco-peritoneal shunt for syringomyelia.