Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2024.
World J Clin Pediatr. Mar 9, 2024; 13(1): 89086
Published online Mar 9, 2024. doi: 10.5409/wjcp.v13.i1.89086
Table 1 Main characteristics of the included studies
Ref.
Location
Study design
Type of Sampling
Sample size LWB
Control group
Measurements
Analysis
Lizarazo et al[2], 2023ColombiaObservationalConvenience25NoInvestigator-designed survey. Medical recordsDescriptive analysis
Ortelan et al[18], 2020BrazilObservationalProbabilistic2370NoQuestionnaire on sociodemographic characteristics of mothers and breast milk consumption. BF prevalence surveyPoisson regression
Agudelo et al[23], 2021ColombiaClinical trialProbabilistic297YesInfant BF assessment toolCox proportional hazards analysis. Cox regression models
Montoya et al[24], 2020ColombiaObservationalConvenience52YesInvestigator-designed survey. Medical recordsDescriptive analysis
Charpak and Montealegre-Pomar[25], 2023ColombiaObservationalConvenience57.154YesGriffiths test. INFANIB testBivariate analysis
Sequeiros et al[26], 2023PeruObservationalConvenience489NoDemographic and family health survey. Household questionnaire. Individual woman questionnaire. Health questionnaireBivariate and multivariate analysis
Ortiz Romaní and Loayza Alarico[20], 2023PeruObservationalConvenience531NoNational databaseBinary logistic regression
Wormald et al[19], 2021ChileObservationalConvenience118NoState trait anxiety inventory. Beck depression inventory; BDI-I. BF self-efficacy scale for mothers with hospitalized preterm infantsMultinomial logistic regression
Javela Rugeles et al[21], 2019ColombiaObservationalConvenience90NoMedical recordsDescriptive analysis
Mangialavori et al[22], 2022ArgentinaObservationalProbabilistic1044NoInvestigator-designed survey. Medical recordsDescriptive analysis
Ortelan et al[17], 2019BrazilObservationalProbabilistic2112YesMedical recordsMultilevel Poisson regression models
Table 2 Sociodemographic characteristics and proximal determinants associated with breastfeeding outcomes in low-birth-weight term infants in Latin America
Ref.
BF results
Mother's socio-demographic characteristics
Associated proximate determinants
Age
Education
Social stratum
Lizarazo et al[2], 2023Information on prenatal BF: 67%. No information on BF: 32.3%. 1-4 prenatal checkups: 43.5%. More than 4 controls: 13.7%. Time to initiation of BF at birth: < 1 h: 33.9%. 1-12 h: 33.1%. > 12 h: 33%. Previous history of BF. BF up to 6 months: 58.5%. BF between 3 and 6 months: 18.5%. No previous BF: 7.1%Average 28 ± 7.3 yearsHigh School: 38.7%. Technical education: 19.4%. Professional: 31.5%Low stratum: 31.5%. Very low stratum: 40.3%Work-related causes: 10.5%. Study: 0.8%. Partially absent mother: 0.8%
Ortelan et al[18], 2020BF prevalence: 54.5%Age in years (%). < 20: 18.1%. 20-35: 66.9%. > 35: 15%High School: 47.1%. Professional: 12.5%No reportWorking outside the home (PR = 1.28; 95%CI 1.11-1.48). Residence in municipalities with a prevalence of child undernutrition below 10% (PR = 1.66; 95%CI 1.23-2.24). Mothers with 12 years of schooling or more (PR = 1.35; 95%CI 1.16-1.58)
Agudelo et al[23], 2021Average duration of exclusive BF: 5 months. BF up to 3 months: 78%. No BF up to 3 months: 19.5%. BF up to 6 months: 25%. No BF up to 6 months: 71%Median age (IQR). Intervention group: 23 years (21-29). Control group: 24 years (20-25)Elementary education: 11%. High school: 60%. Technical education: 13%. Professional: 16%Low stratum: 64.3%. Very low stratum:33.6%Working outside the home
Sequeiros et al[26], 2023Interruption of exclusive BF: 26%. Initiation of BF at birth: Immediately: 70.1%. > 1 h: 29.8%Age in years of mothers who discontinued BF. < 18: 31.7%. 18-25: 27.7%. 26-35: 25.7%. 36-45: 25.0%Elementary education: 20.5%. High school: 26.7%. Professional: 31.2%Low stratum: 22%. Middle stratum: 33%. High stratum: 36%Higher educational level (PRa: 1.55; 95%CI: 1.06-2.27). Rich vs poor family wealth index (RPa: 1.13; 95%CI: 1.03-1.25). Residing in the jungle (RPa: 0.77; 95%CI: 0.71-0.84). Native indigenous language (PRa: 0.82; 95%CI: 0.75-0.91). BF training (PRa: 0.88; 95%CI: 0.82-0.94). Infant with health insurance (PRa: 0.91; 95%CI: 0.84-0.97)
Ortiz Romaní and Loayza Alarico[20], 2023Prevalence of early initiation of BF: 49.6%.Age in years (%). 12-14: 0.09%. 15-19: 6.11%. 20-49: 93.80%High School: 47.2%Low stratum: 47%. Middle stratum: 21.3%. High stratum: 31.5%Factors interfering with early initiation of BF: Living in rural area (ORa: 2.37) and jungle (ORa: 1.72). High wealth index. Access to health services and prenatal care
Javela Rugeles et al[21], 2019Children with BF for one year maintain anthropometric measurements below -2 SD.Age in years (%). < 20: 17%. > 35: 18%High school: 64%. Elementary education: 18%. Technical education: 18%Very low stratum: 57%. Low stratum: 36%. High stratum: 8%Low social stratum
Mangialavori et al[22], 2022Prevalence of BF: 34.7% (95%CI: 31.6-37.9). BF before the first hour of birth: 40.1% (95%CI: 36.9-43.4)No reportElementary education: 9.3%. High school: 91.3%No reportMother's educational level
Ortelan et al[17], 2019Prevalence of BF: 43.9%Age in years (%). < 20: 21.3%. 20-35: 65.3%. > 35: 13.4%High School: 47.6%No reportFactors favoring BF practices: Age between 20-35 years (PR = 1.35; 95%CI: 1.09-1.69). Work at home. Birth in BF-friendly hospital services. Increased availability of human milk banks per 10000 inhabitants
Table 3 Individual characteristics related to self-efficacy for breastfeeding maintenance and adherence in low-birth-weight term infants in Latin America
Ref.
Reason for BF desertion/difficulties
Barriers
Enablers
Lizarazo et al[2], 2023Perception of low milk production. Newborn's feeling of not satiety. Newborn rejection. Maternal decisionMother's mood as an influence on BF practice. Work commitmentsFamily support for housework
Ortelan et al[18], 2020Age, education, multiparityInadequate supplementary feedingHigh educational level
Agudelo et al[23], 2021Supported to stimulate BF in the first hour of lifeInterference with newborn routines; availability of time for skin-to-skin contact at birth; obesity; smokingEducational support. Immediate skin-to-skin contact in the maternity ward
Montoya et al[24], 2020Newborn hospitalization for low birth weight. Maternal hospitalization. BF technique. No previous experience in BFFeeding with milk substitutes suggested by health personnelMother's willingness to breastfeed. Support from family and health personnel. Mother's previous BF experience
Charpak and Montealegre-Pomar[25], 2023Respiratory pathology of the newbornPathologies of the newbornMonitoring and follow-up of the health of low-birth-weight newborns and maternal care in mother Kangaroo programs.
Sequeiros et al[26], 2023Lack of knowledge of BF during pregnancyMothers with higher education. Infant only child. Age < 18 years. Birth by caesarean sectionEarly BF training during pregnancy. Early initiation of BF
Ortiz Romaní and Loayza Alarico[20], 2023Cesarean delivery. First gestation. Pre-milk feeding of the newbornLack of BF skills. Limitations for skin-to-skin contact in the first hour of lifeDevelop skills and abilities in relation to the promotion of BF. Management of the mother's own symptoms that are contemplated in the different prenatal services and delivery room
Wormald et al[19], 2021Manifestation of emotional symptomsExposure to triggers for depression or anxietySelf-efficacy
Javela Rugeles et al[21], 2019Newborn comorbiditiesExtreme ages. No support during the first month of the newborn's lifeFamily support
Mangialavori et al[22], 2022Cesarean deliveryLimitations to BF in the first hour of life. Separation of mother-infant dyad > 4 hEducational level