Primary clarithromycin resistance to Helicobacter pylori: Is this the main reason for triple therapy failure?

Abstract

Conventional triple therapies for Helicobacter pylori (H. pylori) eradication have recently shown a disappointing reduction in effectiveness in many countries. The main reason for failure was found to be bacterial resistance to one of the most commonly used antibiotics, clarithromycin. An additional problem for conventional triple therapy is the high rate of resistance to metronidazole found in Europe, America and Asia. In Italy, in the last 15 years a 2-fold increase in resistance has occurred. A recent study of the whole of Italy included about 20 patients from each region at the first endoscopic diagnosis of H. pylori infection. The most surprising result was the patchy distribution of resistance, which was almost absent in two regions (one northern and one southern), although the highest prevalence was found in some regions of the South. In the paediatric population we found a 25% prevalence of resistance in a sample of H. pylori positive children observed between 2002 and 2007, mirroring data obtained in southern European countries. Clarithromycin resistance assessment is currently based on phenotypic detection performed after culture the agar dilution method or E-test, and genotypic methods based on polymerase chain reaction (PCR). In a recent comparative study we found a 71.2% agreement between the two methods. Culture-free techniques are highly accurate in finding even minimal traces of genotypically resistant strains. Moreover, PCR-based tools are accurate in detecting a heteroresistant status, defined as the co-existence of some strains that are susceptible and some resistant to the same antibiotic in an individual patient. Three point mutations, namely A2143G, A2142G and A2142C, are responsible for 90% of cases of primary clarithromycin resistance in H. pylori strains isolated in Western countries, although we previously demonstrated that the presence of the A2143G mutation, but not A2142G or A2142C, significantly lowered the H. pylori eradication rate. Treatment failure has considerable cost/benefit implications because of “waste” of National Health System and patient resources, in terms of drugs, further diagnostic tests and medical examination expenses. Therefore, in future it would be very useful to be able to test for clarithromycin resistance before starting conventional triple therapy. Hopefully, fast, effective non-invasive tests may soon be devised to determine this condition.

Keywords: Helicobacter pylori, Clarithromycin, Genotypic resistance, Phenotypic resistance, Therapy failure cost, Resistance epidemiology

Core tip: Clarithromycin resistance is the main reason for the failure of conventional therapies for Helicobacter pylori. We evaluate the scope of the problem, as reported in literature and especially on the basis of personal data in adult and paediatric populations. Another issue is the detection of resistance using phenotypic and genotypic methods; comparison is made of the limits and advantages of these approaches. Cost/benefit analysis of unsuccessful eradication therapy is performed. Based on these considerations, the best solution in future seems likely to be the detection of resistant strains before starting treatment.