Brief Article
Copyright ©2011 Baishideng Publishing Group Co.
World J Gastroenterol. Oct 14, 2011; 17(38): 4321-4333
Published online Oct 14, 2011. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v17.i38.4321
Table 1 General information of included randomized controlled trials
First author, year[Ref.]Group (n)Interventions on mothersMaternal HBV DNA level1Newborns within 24 hInfants within 6-12 moAdverse events
Before interventionBefore deliveryHBsAg(+)HBeAg(+)HBV DNA (+)HBsAg(+)HBeAg(+)HBV DNA (+)MothersInfants
Zhang, 2010[21]Arm 1:503TC 100 mg od from week 286.83 ± 0.903.65 ± 0.546/50-5/501/50-1/5000
Arm 2:50No treatment6.87 ± 1.676.88 ± 1.0817/50-18/508/50-8/50--
Han, 2010[22]Arm 1:523TC 100 mg od from week 20--5/52-1/520/42-0/4200
Arm 2:61200 IU HBIG every 2 wk from week 28--26/61-7/619/55-9/5500
Han, 2009[23]Arm 1:573TC 100 mg od from week 207.5 ± 0.50-6/57-1/570/46-0/4600
Arm 2:66200 IU HBIG every 2 wk from week 287.5 ± 0.72-27/66-8/6610/59-10/5901/66
Su, 2009[24]Arm 1:1283TC 100 mg od from week 32, 200 IU HBIG at week 28, 32, 36-----6/128--00
Arm 2:120200 IU HBIG at week 28, 32, 36-----17/120---
Xu, 2009[25]Arm 1:633TC 100 mg od from week 329.35 ± 0.217.71 ± 1.4917/5-7/5610/56-11/567/8910/56
Arm 2:62Placebo9.43 ± 0.219.34 ± 0.2214/59-24/5923/59-27/596/6112/59
Shi, 2009[26]Arm 1:493TC 100 mg od from week 287.24 ± 1.904.49 ± 3.253/49-1/49---2/51-
Arm 2:116100 IU HBIG at week 28, 32, 366.31 ± 2.135.86 ± 2.628/116-4/116---3/146-
Arm 3:43Placebo6.40 ± 2.126.19 ± 2.5710/43-5/43---2/84-
Yang, 2008[27]Arm 1:453TC 100 mg od from week 246.99 ± 0.845.10 ± 0.80---1/45---0
Arm 2:42100 IU HBIG at week 28, 32, 366.87 ± 0.926.87 ± 0.92---6/42---0
Guo, 2008[28]Arm 1:703TC 100 mg od from week 28--6/70-8/704/70-6/70--
Arm 1:40No treatment--10/40-13/4012/40-18/40--
Xiang, 2007[29]Arm 1:213TC 100 mg od from week 288.02 ± 1.154.58 ± 1.221/213/21------
Arm 2:25200 IU HBIG every month from month 47.63 ± 1.235.12 ± 1.072/252/25------
Arm 3:18No treatment7.16 ± 0.796.88 ± 1.365/183/18------
Feng, 2007[30]Arm 1:483TC 100 mg od from week 288.34 ± 1.234.85 ± 1.278/489/487/48-7/4800
Arm 1:42No treatment8.26 ± 1.878.56 ± 1.0817/4219/4216/42-16/4200
Li, 2006[31]Arm 1:363TC 100 mg od from week 246.89 ± 0.825.08 ± 0.76---1/36--00
Arm 2:44No treatment> 5.00> 5.00---7/44--00
Li, 2006[32]Arm 1:403TC 100 mg od from week 28 and 200 IU HBIG at week 28, 32, 36-----1/351/351/3500
Arm 2:37200 IU HBIG at week 28, 32, 36-----7/326/326/3200
Han, 2005[33]Arm 1:433TC 100 mg od from week 287.15 ± 0.915.43 ± 0.85---0/43-0/4300
Arm 1:35No treatment> 5.60> 5.60---5/35--00
Shi, 2005[34]Arm 1:213TC 100 mg od from week 288.72 ± 0.696.59 ± 1.061/213/212/21---1/210
Arm 1:18No treatment8.93 ± 1.129.05 ± 0.261/182/188/18---00
Li, 2003[35]Arm 1:56200 IU HBIG every 4 wk from week 287.38 ± 1.175.28 ± 2.773/567/56----00
Arm 2:433TC 100 mg od from week 287.49 ± 0.545.33 ± 1.341/437/43----00
Arm 3:52No treatment7.05 ± 1.296.23 ± 3.668/5211/52----00
Table 2 Methodological quality of included randomized clinical trials
First author, year[Ref.]Generation of allocation sequenceAllocation concealmentBlindingMethodologicalquality
Han, 2010[22]UnclearUnclearUnclearLow
Zhang, 2010[21]UnclearUnclearUnclearLow
Han, 2009[23]UnclearUnclearUnclearLow
Su, 2009[24]UnclearUnclearUnclearLow
Xu, 2009[25]UnclearAdequateAdequateHigh
Shi, 2009[26]AdequateAdequateAdequateHigh
Yang, 2008[27]AdequateUnclearUnclearLow
Guo, 2008[28]AdequateUnclearUnclearLow
Xiang, 2007[29]AdequateUnclearUnclearLow
Feng, 2007[30]Not doneNot doneNot doneLow
Li, 2006[31]Not doneNot doneNot doneLow
Li, 2006[32]Not doneNot doneNot doneLow
Han, 2005[33]Not doneNot doneNot doneLow
Shi, 2005[34]AdequateUnclearUnclearLow
Li, 2003[35]AdequateUnclearUnclearLow