Published online Aug 14, 2009. doi: 10.3748/wjg.15.3744
Revised: June 29, 2009
Accepted: July 6, 2009
Published online: August 14, 2009
Children with chronic long-term disorders need to move to the adult practice at some point in their life. Establishing a smooth and efficient transition process is a complicated task. Transition of medical care to adult practice is defined as the purposeful planned movement of adolescents and young adults with chronic physical and medical conditions from child-centered to adult-oriented health care systems. This step is of the utmost importance for several reasons. There is an obvious deficiency of research in this area especially when it comes to pediatric inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). There is a considerable difference in individual practice among different centers. Also, age of transition varies among different countries and sometimes, even within the same country, transition age may vary among different provinces and districts! Interestingly, local politics and many factors other than children’s welfare often play a role in deciding the age that older children move to adult practice at. This review discusses transition of children with IBD in view of the available evidence.
- Citation: El-Matary W. Transition of children with inflammatory bowel disease: Big task, little evidence. World J Gastroenterol 2009; 15(30): 3744-3747
- URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/1007-9327/full/v15/i30/3744.htm
- DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.3748/wjg.15.3744
The relapsing and remitting nature of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) with its high morbidity makes transition of children with IBD into adult care a mandatory step in their care. As young people move to maturity, their medical and psychological needs change and it is crucial for them to receive age-appropriate medical care. This highlights the importance of what is called health-care transition. Preparing older children and young adults for this process is very important as they need to develop a sense of independence and maturity.
There have been several definitions of the process of transition of medical care but the most quoted one is that by Blum et al “the purposeful planned movement of adolescents and young adults with chronic physical and medical conditions from child-centered to adult-oriented health care systems”.
The aim of the transition program is to achieve for each chronically ill patient a continuum of care that includes normalization of social and emotional development and acquisition of independent living skills.
Several hurdles may interfere with this process. As the patients and their families are used to dealing with certain faces, they may be reluctant to move to an adult health care system. A strong sense of bonding usually develops over years of care under pediatric service. On the other hand, pediatric caregivers may also find it difficult to give up their patients after years of care and strong ties. They may feel that the adult caregivers are unable to provide the same quality of, not only medical, but also psychological care during this critical period.
In addition, the adult caregivers may feel that patients and their families with pediatric-onset disease may be too demanding. The adult caregivers may assume that patients should take a large part of responsibility for the details of their care. Adult care normally lacks the multidisciplinary team approach that pediatric service usually offers.
Most of the available pediatric IBD transition literature is in the form of some guidelines based on personal experience. The North American Society of Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition (NASPGHAN) indicates its recommendations for this process as: (1) The pediatric gastroenterologist should start seeing adolescent patients without their parents in order to build some sort of relationship that promotes independence, so the patient will have this well-established before going to adult practice. Nevertheless, it is not clear at what age pediatric gastroenterologists should start implementing this recommendation. (2) Introduction of the patients subject to transition, and their families, to a gastroenterologist who is trained in internal medicine. Emphasis placed on benefits of transition to the patients and their families, including exposure to a physician experienced in aspects that pediatricians are not exposed to such as pregnancy, fertility and cancer surveillance. (3) Selection of an adult gastroenterologist who cares for young adults and identifies what this sector of patients may need that differs from newly diagnosed young adults. (4) The transition process should include a detailed letter from the pediatric to the adult gastroenterologist with a copy to the family. (5) The timing of the transition should be flexible according to patients’ individual needs, e.g. the pediatric gastroenterologist should continue to follow those patients with delayed puberty who still have some potential to grow.
In a recent report, Hait et al recommended some tasks and knowledge that pediatric patients at different age groups should be able to accomplish and be familiar with through the help of the medical team (Table 1). This work has not been validated.
|11-13||Able to articulate his or her GI condition||Introduces idea of future independent visits|
|Able to name medications, doses, side effects||Asks parents to remain in waiting room for a portion of the visit|
|Knows strategies to take his or her medications||Anticipatory guidance about fitness, sexuality, and substance abuse|
|Able to use and read a thermometer|
|Articulates impact of IBD on school and daily life|
|14-16||Able to identify medical team||Directs all questions and explanations to patient|
|Knows names and purposes of procedures and tests done on him or her||Patient ask for input first|
|Knows his or her medical history||Explores family’s apprehensions about patient taking in primary role|
|Knows names of IBD social support groups and community organizations||Clarifies to patient what must legally be disclosed to parents|
|Understands the medical risk of no adherence||Determines when the patients wants his or her parents in and out of the room|
|Understands the impact of drugs and alcohol on the illness||Initiates discussion about eventual transfer of care|
|Determines post-high school plans (social, employment, education)|
|Instructs patient to keep names of medications, dosages, and medical team contact in wallet/purse/backpack|
|Instructs patient on how to get prescriptions filled and how to call and schedule appointments|
|17-19||Knows how to gather information about IBD||Initiates conversation about potential barriers to transition|
|Demonstrates consistent ability to book own appointments, fill prescriptions, contact medical team||Identifies potential adult GI providers|
|Able to name his or her insurance coverage and plans for next 2 years of coverage||Encourages patient to meet and interview providers|
|Carries insurance information in wallet/purse/backpack||Reminds patient and family that at age 18 the patient has the right to make his or her own heath choices|
|20-23||Has had a telephone conversation with potential adult GI providers||Providers patient with medical summary and checklist (see Table 2)|
|Initial visit with adult GI is scheduled while IBD stable||Transfers medical records to adult provider|
|Early (10 to 12 years of age)||Middle (13 to 15 years of age)||Late (16 to 18 years of age)|
|Self-advocacy||Describe GI condition||Name and describe the role of those involved in care||Review successful changes achieved in life|
|Learn about transition process||Learn about rights and responsibilities||Review GI conditions and ways to stay informed|
|Independent behaviors||Name medications and doses||Describe tests and reasons for them||Demonstrate knowledge in dealing with own care needs (e.g. booking appointments, refilling prescriptions)|
|Choose method to remember to take medication||Plan and prepare for appointments|
|Discuss differences in pediatric and adult care|
|Sexual health||Discuss puberty and changes related to GI condition and medication side effects||Discuss safer relationships and dating||Aware of sexual capability and ability to have children|
|Name places for reliable sexual health information||Understands sexual behaviors and its risks|
|Social supports||Describe role of family in transition process||Discuss family medical history||Enrolls in GI support associations|
|Discuss ways to benefit from peer support||Identifies contacts in case of need of emotional support|
|Educational/ vocational planning||Discuss school attendance, goals and strengths||Review restrictions for education or work||Aware of work opportunities|
|Discuss volunteering opportunities at school or community||Discuss further plans for insurance coverage|
|Health and lifestyles||Review healthy active living||Review ways of coping with stress||Describes exercise/activity routines|
|Tobacco use or other substances||Learn of risks associated with driving and GI condition||Discuss importance of planning ahead for trips and being away from home|
Dabadie et al have recently conducted a survey on a small sample of young adults with IBD. Their mean age of transition was 17.9 ± 0.9 years. Eighty five percent of patients and 74% of their parents felt they were ready to move to adult practice. The transition model they were using involved having one joint pediatric-adult care visit before moving completely to adult care. The majority of patients felt comfortable with this model.
Many other centers are using the same model. In fact some hospitals may have more than one visit per patient to the joint clinics before transitioning children to adult practice. Most of these clinics take place in hospitals where both adult and pediatric gastroenterology departments exist. The problem with this system is the diversity of patients’ location especially in large countries. As the number of adult gastroenterology centers exceeds that of pediatric centers, some patients may choose to move to an adult gastroenterologist near where they live, in which case they would not see the same gastroenterologist from the transition clinic. Available health resources may interfere with arranging transition clinics where patients reside.
Another survey by Hait et al was done among 1132 adult gastroenterologists in the Netherlands. The response rate was only 34% but the majority of these gastroenterologists reported a lack of medical knowledge among young adults with IBD. They also reported receiving inadequate medical history from their pediatric colleagues.
We recently started conducting a survey looking at the level of disease-related knowledge among older children and young adults with IBD. We asked patients and their parents to complete the same questionnaire forms independently. The preliminary results showed a significant lack of knowledge among those children and a significant knowledge deficit between children and their parents. This was the case despite the presence of a meticulous program for educating newly diagnosed children with IBD. The problem is that patients in this age group are often highly dependant on their parents on selecting and filtering all the information they need. Consequently we started seeing older patients with IBD on their own without their parents early before transitioning them to our adult colleagues. We are also evaluating a new strategy for patients’ education to see if the outcome can be improved.
Taking in consideration the huge advances in patient care and management, children with chronic disease are expected to live longer. Consequently, the area of transition has been explored in most other pediatric subspecialties.
In a recent multicentre audit from the UK, Robertson et al reported some improvements in their transition program after highlighting the aspects of care provisions in transition through a national UK service framework of children. Improvements took place in the documentation of transition issues and in some educational needs of patients and their parents that were related to their disease. The concept of independent clinic visits was introduced at an earlier age (mean of 15.8 years vs 16.8 years before provision).
A service model for adults with congenital heart disease was recently published stressing the importance of close communication between local district general hospitals, tertiary specialist centers and primary care clinics. The authors suggested that transition clinics should start at the age of 12 years.
McDonagh and Kelly summarized determinants of the timing of transition as follows: (1) Chronologic age; (2) Maturity; (3) Current medical status; (4) Adherence to therapy; (5) Independence in health care; (6) Self-advocacy skills; (7) Preparation; (8) Readiness of the young person and (9) Availability of an appropriate adult specialist.
Clearly it is not an easy task for pediatric gastroenterologists to determine the exact maturity status for each child with IBD. Moreover, even when we feel that some children are not mature enough to move to adult service at the age of 16-17 years; it is not easy to convince health authorities to keep seeing these children in pediatric services. In fact, the differences between transition services in different health care systems were proven to inhibit a smooth and successful transition process in a recent study by Reiss et al.
There have been some attempts to create a self-efficacy/independence scale to facilitate assessing older children with chronic disease for maturity. Schlosser and Havermans created and validated a self-efficacy scale for children with bronchial asthma between 10-18 years of age. The scale consisted of 38 items partly taken from a self-efficacy scale by Grossman et al for diabetics. Older children scored higher on the total scale. One major flaw in this study was the lack of adjustment for obvious confounders like social class or IQ. These points were partially taken into consideration in another independence-scale that was designed for children with cystic fibrosis (SCIS). The scale consisted of 44 items. An initial interview was done to screen for children with an average or high cognitive function. The study was conducted among CF patients aged from 14-17 years. Based on age, two different intellectual screening tools were used. There was a positive correlation between SCIS scores, patient’s age and the number of years since diagnosis. A similar study with a larger sample size was conducted among patients with diabetes not only for children but also for parents assessing independence of their children. Approximately 25% of parents of children 6 years-old, 50% of parents of children 8 years-old and 75% of parents of 14 year-old children reported that their children had mastered their disease-related skills.
Another tool was developed by the Boston Children’s Hospital, USA to allow older children to evaluate their readiness for transition. This tool consisted of 15 questions. Validation of this tool remains questionable.
Two case studies were recently published demonstrating the concept of “a medical home”. This concept was highlighted in a statement by the American Academy of Pediatrics. It was stated that all children and youth with special health care needs should have a medical home where health care services are accessible, family centered, continuous, comprehensive, coordinated and compassionate. The authors tried to set a model for transitioning older children with chronic, disabling medical problems using the above concept.
Currently there is a residency program in the United States (combined Medicine-Pediatrics Residency Program) that helps in qualifying physicians to look after children with chronic disorders during this critical period. Training includes pediatric and adult subspecialty experience. Spreading this program to other countries may help in smoothing the transition process.
Transitioning adolescents with IBD to adult gastroenterologists requires an understanding of the specific issues and challenges involved in the management of pediatric IBD. Currently there is no consistency in transition practice among different centers.
The best strategy for health education or patients’ transition is yet to be determined. Assessing children with IBD for maturity could be a challenge in view of the lack of validated scales. Current guidelines and suggestions are based on personal opinions. More research addressing best strategy for education, transition and building bridges with adult gastroenterologists are needed.
|1.||Bousvaros A, Sylvester F, Kugathasan S, Szigethy E, Fiocchi C, Colletti R, Otley A, Amre D, Ferry G, Czinn SJ. Challenges in pediatric inflammatory bowel disease. Inflamm Bowel Dis. 2006;12:885-913.|
|2.||A consensus statement on health care transitions for young adults with special health care needs. Pediatrics. 2002;110:1304-1306.|
|3.||Blum RW, Garell D, Hodgman CH, Jorissen TW, Okinow NA, Orr DP, Slap GB. Transition from child-centered to adult health-care systems for adolescents with chronic conditions. A position paper of the Society for Adolescent Medicine. J Adolesc Health. 1993;14:570-576.|
|4.||Kalwinsky DK. Health care issues as the child with chronic illness transitions to adulthood. South Med J. 2002;95:966-967.|
|5.||Wallis C. Transition of care in children with chronic disease. BMJ. 2007;334:1231-1232.|
|6.||Baldassano R, Ferry G, Griffiths A, Mack D, Markowitz J, Winter H. Transition of the patient with inflammatory bowel disease from pediatric to adult care: recommendations of the North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2002;34:245-248.|
|7.||Pinzon JL, Jacobson K, Reiss J. Say goodbye and say hello: the transition from pediatric to adult gastroenterology. Can J Gastroenterol. 2004;18:735-742.|
|8.||Hait E, Arnold JH, Fishman LN. Educate, communicate, anticipate-practical recommendations for transitioning adolescents with IBD to adult health care. Inflamm Bowel Dis. 2006;12:70-73.|
|9.||Dabadie A, Troadec F, Heresbach D, Siproudhis L, Pagenault M, Bretagne JF. Transition of patients with inflammatory bowel disease from pediatric to adult care. Gastroenterol Clin Biol. 2008;32:451-459.|
|10.||Hait EJ, Barendse RM, Arnold JH, Valim C, Sands BE, Korzenik JR, Fishman LN. Transition of adolescents with inflammatory bowel disease from pediatric to adult care: a survey of adult gastroenterologists. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2009;48:61-65.|
|11.||Robertson LP, McDonagh JE, Southwood TR, Shaw KL. Growing up and moving on. A multicentre UK audit of the transfer of adolescents with juvenile idiopathic arthritis from paediatric to adult centred care. Ann Rheum Dis. 2006;65:74-80.|
|12.||Hudsmith LE, Thorne SA. Transition of care from paediatric to adult services in cardiology. Arch Dis Child. 2007;92:927-930.|
|13.||McDonagh JE, Kelly DA. Transitioning care of the pediatric recipient to adult caregivers. Pediatr Clin North Am. 2003;50:1561-1583, xi-xii.|
|14.||Reiss JG, Gibson RW, Walker LR. Health care transition: youth, family, and provider perspectives. Pediatrics. 2005;115:112-120.|
|15.||Schlosser M, Havermans G. A self-efficacy scale for children and adolescents with asthma: construction and validation. J Asthma. 1992;29:99-108.|
|16.||Grossman HY, Brink S, Hauser ST. Self-efficacy in adolescent girls and boys with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Diabetes Care. 1987;10:324-329.|
|17.||Patton SR, Graham JL, Varlotta L, Holsclaw D Jr. Measuring self-care independence in children with cystic fibrosis: the Self-Care Independence Scale (SCIS). Pediatr Pulmonol. 2003;36:123-130.|
|18.||Wysocki T, Meinhold PM, Taylor A, Hough BS, Barnard MU, Clarke WL, Bellando BJ, Bourgeois MJ. Psychometric properties and normative data for the parent version of the diabetes independence survey. Diabetes Educ. 1996;22:587-591.|
|19.||Callahan ST, Winitzer RF, Keenan P. Transition from pediatric to adult-oriented health care: a challenge for patients with chronic disease. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2001;13:310-316.|
|20.||Kelly AM, Kratz B, Bielski M, Rinehart PM. Implementing transitions for youth with complex chronic conditions using the medical home model. Pediatrics. 2002;110:1322-1327.|
|21.||American Academy of Pediatrics Ad Hoc Task Force on Definition of the Medical Home: The medical home. Pediatrics. 1992;90:774.|
|22.||Melgar T, Brands C, Sharma N. Health care transition. Pediatrics. 2005;115:1449-1450; author reply 1450.|
|23.||Desir B, Seidman EG. Transitioning the paediatric IBD patient to adult care. Best Pract Res Clin Gastroenterol. 2003;17:197-212.|