Derici H, Kara C, Bozdag AD, Nazli O, Tansug T, Akca E. Diagnosis and treatment of gallbladder perforation. World J Gastroenterol 2006; 12(48): 7832-7836 [PMID: 17203529 DOI: 10.3748/wjg.v12.i48.7832]
Corresponding Author of This Article
Dr. Hayrullah Derici, Third Surgical Clinic of Atatürk Training and Research Hospital, 156 sok. No. 5/13 Bornova, Izmir 35360, Turkey. firstname.lastname@example.org
Article-Type of This Article
Open-Access Policy of This Article
This article is an open-access article which was selected by an in-house editor and fully peer-reviewed by external reviewers. It is distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Diagnosis and treatment of gallbladder perforation
Hayrullah Derici, Cemal Kara, Ali Dogan Bozdag, Okay Nazli, Tugrul Tansug, Esra Akca
Hayrullah Derici, Cemal Kara, Ali Dogan Bozdag, Okay Nazli, Tugrul Tansug, Esra Akca, Third Surgical Clinic of Atatürk Training and Research Hospital, Izmir 35360, Turkey
ORCID number: $[AuthorORCIDs]
Correspondence to: Dr. Hayrullah Derici, Third Surgical Clinic of Atatürk Training and Research Hospital, 156 sok. No. 5/13 Bornova, Izmir 35360, Turkey. email@example.com
Telephone: +90-232-3747899 Fax: +90-232-4632786
Received: September 6, 2006 Revised: September 28, 2006 Accepted: November 7, 2006 Published online: December 28, 2006
AIM: To present our clinical experience with gallbladder perforation cases.
METHODS: Records of 332 patients who received medical and/or surgical treatment with the diagnosis of acute cholecystitis in our clinic between 1997 and 2006 were reviewed retrospectively. Sixteen (4.8%) of those patients had gallbladder perforation. The parameters including age, gender, time from the onset of symptoms to the time of surgery, diagnostic procedures, surgical treatment, morbidity, and mortality were evaluated.
RESULTS: Seven patients had typeIgallbladder perforation, 7 type II gallbladder perforation, and 2 type III gallbladder perforation according to Niemeier’s classification. The patients underwent surgery after administration of intravenous electrolyte solutions, and were treated with analgesics and antibiotics within the first 36 h (mean 9 h) after admission. Two patients died of sepsis and multiple organ failure in the early postoperative period. Subhepatic abscess, pelvic abscess, pneumonia, pancreatitis, and acute renal failure were found in 6 patients.
CONCLUSION: Early diagnosis and emergency surgical treatment of gallbladder perforation are of crucial importance. Upper abdominal computerized tomography for acute cholecystitis patients may contribute to the preoperative diagnosis of gallbladder perforation.
Gallbladder perforation (GBP) is a rare but life threatening complication of acute cholecystitis. Sometimes GBP may not be different from uncomplicated acute cholecystitis with high morbidity and mortality rates because of delay in diagnosis[1-3]. Thus GBP still continues to be an important problem for the surgeons. Most cases can only be diagnosed during surgery[1,4]. Male acute cholecystitis cases with high fever, high white blood cell (WBC) count, and associated systemic diseases should be meticulously investigated[1,5,6].
Niemeier in 1934, classified free gallbladder perforation and generalized biliary peritonitis as acute or typeIGBP, pericholecystic abscess and localized peritonitis as subacute or type II GBP, and cholecystoenteric fistula as chronic or type III GBP. This classification is still in use. We aimed to present our clinical experience with GBP in this study.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Records of 332 patients who received medical and/or surgical treatment with the diagnosis acute cholecystitis in our clinic between January 1997 and February 2006 were reviewed retrospectively. Sixteen (4.8%) of those patients were found to have gallbladder perforation. Perforations due to trauma, iatrogenic causes, and gallbladder (GB) carcinoma were excluded.
The original classification of Niemeier was used to identify the patients. The parameters including age, gender, time from the onset of symptoms to the time of surgery, diagnostic procedures, surgical treatment, postoperative morbidity and mortality were evaluated. Direct abdominal X-ray series, abdominal ultrasound scanning (US), abdominal contrast-enhanced computerized tomography (CT), routine blood cell count, and blood chemistry tests were performed. Peritoneal spaces were lavaged thoroughly with isotonic saline and drains were placed for postoperative drainage in all of the patients.
There were 10 male and 6 female patients. Their mean age was 69 (range, 54-85) years. Their complaints were abdominal pain, poor general condition, high fever, nausea, and vomiting on admission. Cholelithiasis was unknown prior to perforation in 5 patients. The patients had several associated diseases, of which atherosclerotic heart disease (AHD) was the most common. One patient with typeIgallbladder perforation was on long term steroid treatment for systemic lupus erythematosus. White blood cell (WBC) count was high in 14 patients, and 10 patients had high fever. Patients with typeIgallbladder perforation had signs of peritoneal irritation such as extensive abdominal tenderness, guarding and rebound tenderness. Patients with typeIIgallbladder perforation had local tenderness, guarding, positive Murphy’s sign and 4 of them had palpable right subcostal mass while one patient had jaundice with a total bilirubin level of 28 mg/dL. Two patients with type III gallbladder perforation had epigastric tenderness and one of them also had abdominal distension. Four patients had systemic inflammatory response syndrome, of them two patients with typeIgallbladder perforation and two with typeIIand type III gallbladder perforations. The number of patients and their clinical features in each type of gallbladder perforation are shown in Table 1.
1Some patients had more than one sytemic disorder.
Abdominal X-ray series and abdominal US were performed for all of the patients and abdominal CT scanning for 14 patients. Only one patient with type III gallbladder perforation had air-fluid levels on direct abdominal radiograms. Abdominal US showed gall stones in all of the patients with typeIand typeIIgallbladder perforations, extensive intraperitoneal free fluid in 7 patients with typeIgallbladder perforation, and a small amount of pericholecystic free fluid in 6 patients with typeIIgallbladder perforation. Abdominal US did not show GB wall defect in any of the patients. CT revealed GB wall thickening in all of the patients, gall stones in 10 patients, extensive intraperitoneal free fluid in 5 patients, a small amount of pericholecystic free fluid in 7 patients, and GB perforation sites in 5 patients. Abdominal CT and US detected liver abscesses in 2 patients, dilated extra and intrahepatic bile ducts in 1 patient. Abdominal CT showed dilated intestinal loops suggesting mechanical obstruction in one patient with type III gallbladder perforation. Abdominal CT showed dilated stomach suggesting gastric outlet syndrome in another patient. The stomach was dilated with a normal mucosa, but the gall stone could not be seen during upper gastrointestinal endoscopy of this patient.
Enlarged gallbladder, irregularity of the gallbladder walls at the fundic region, air density lateral to the fundus and corpus, and increased density of the mesentery anterior to the fundus suggesting free fluid on CT image of a patient with typeIIgallbladder perforation are shown in Figure 1. The abdominal CT image of a patient with hepatic abscess adjacent to the superior part of GB is shown in Figure 2.
Figure 1 Contrast-enhanced CT image at the level of gallbladder.
Figure 2 Contrast-enhanced CT image of hepatic abscess adjacent to the superior part of gallbladder.
The patients underwent surgery after administration of intravenous crystalloid solutions, and were treated with analgesics and antibiotic (third generation cephalosporins) within the first 36 h (mean 9 h) after admission. The patients who had associated diseases such as diabetes, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and AHD underwent surgery after specific medical treatment was started. Antibiotic treatment was changed when required, according to the results of microbiological assessment of the infected bile specimens obtained from the gall bladder. The most common preoperative diagnoses were perforated cholecystitis in patients with typeIgallbladder perforations, and acute cholecystitis in patients with typeIIgallbladder perforations. Laparoscopic cholecystectomy was performed in 6 patients, two of them had typeIgallbladder perforation, and four typeIIgallbladder perforation. Conversion was required in 2 of them due to unclear anatomy. Laparotomy was performed in the remaining 10 patients. Perforations were recognized intraoperatively in 11 patients. The perforated site of the GB was the fundus in 9 patients, the corpus in 3 patients, the infundibulum in 3 patients, and the cystic duct in 1 patient. Two patients with typeIIgallbladder perforation also had hepatic abscesses, which were covered by the omentum. Hepatic abscesses were also drained in these patients. All of the patients received a cholecystectomy. Common bile duct exploration was performed, gall stones were extracted, and a T-tube was placed into the common bile duct in addition to cholecystectomy in 1 patient with obstructive jaundice. One of the 2 patients had a cholecystoduodenal fistula (type III gallbladder perforations) underwent surgery for gastrointestinal tract obstruction due to bile stones in the jejunum, which were removed through an enterotomy. Gall stones were also found in the duodenum of the other patient with type III gallbladder perforation and removed through a duodenotomy.
The median hospital stay was 15 d (4-26 d). Two patients (12.5%) died of sepsis and multiple organ failure in the early postoperative period. One was a female patient at the age of 79 with type III gallbladder perforation and COPD. The other was a 84 year-old male patient with delayed typeIIgallbladder perforation and pericholecystic abscess associated with AHD and diabetes. Subhepatic abscess, pelvic abscess, pneumonia, pancreatitis and acute renal failure were found in 6 patients (Table 2). Subhepatic and pelvic abscesses were drained percutaneously under ultrasound guidance. The other diseases were treated conservatively.
Table 2 Surgical procedures and morbidities of the patients n (%).
Inflammation may progress and cause ischemia and necrosis, thus resulting GBP in 2% to 11% of acute cholecystitis patients[6,8,9]. GBP also develops following acalculous cholecystitis, although rare[10,11]. GB fundus, the most distal part with regard to blood supply, is the most common site of perforation[8,12]. The incidence of GBP was 4.5% and the most frequent site of perforation was the fundus (60%) in our study. Six of the 7 typeIgallbladder perforations and 3 of 7 typeIIgallbladder perforations were at the fundus. When GB is perforated at the fundus, it is less possibly covered by the omentum, thus the bile drains into the peritoneal space. If the perforation site is not at the fundus, it is easily sealed by the omentum or the intestines and the condition remains limited in the right upper quadrant with formation of a plastrone and pericholecystic fluid. This observation suggests that if the perforation site is at the fundus, it is more likely to end up with a typeIperforation. The relation between the site and the type of GBP has not been defined. Although statistical analysis was not possible because of the insufficient number of patients in this series, this observation may be supported by larger series.
Acute uncomplicated cholecystitis is more common among females with a female to male ratio of 2:1. However, GBP is more frequent in male gender[1,6]. In our study, male patients made up of 60% and the two patients with type III gallbladder perforation were females. GBP is usually seen over 60 years of age[4,14]. Roslyn et al reported that typeIandIIGBP tend to occur in younger patients, especially more or less at the age of 50 years, whereas type III gallbladder perforations are more common in the elderly. The patients with typeIgallbladder perforation were relatively younger than those with typeIIand III gallbladder perforations in our study.
TypeIgallbladder perforations are usually seen in patients with AHD, diabetes, malignancy, cirrhosis, and immunosupressive diseases, or during immunosupressive treatment, without a history of chronic cholecystitis. On the other hand, type III gallbladder perforations most often occur in patients with a previous long time history of gall stones[1,9,12]. Severe AHD has been reported in 21% of patients with typeIandIIgallbladder perforations, and diabetes, in 25% of patients with typeIgallbladder perforation[8,14]. Such high rates are related to vascular disorders caused by these systemic diseases. It has been reported that typeIIGBP occurs more frequently[1,3,9,12]. The incidence of typeIandIIgallbladder perforations was equal and the most frequent associated systemic disease was AHD in the present study. Type III gallbladder perforations usually occur in chronic cholecystitis patients with obstructive gastrointestinal symptoms[9,12,15]. Since the symptoms of typeI-IIGBP and uncomplicated cholecystitis are similar, differential diagnosis may be difficult based on physical examination, laboratory tests, and radiological methods and the diagnosis may not be established preoperatively[6,12]. Delay in diagnosis is the major cause of its high morbidity and mortality[1,4,9,16]. Tanaka et al reported that only one patient had a concrete diagnosis preoperatively in their series of 9 patients. The majority of GBP patients include those who undergo early surgery with the diagnosis of acute cholecystitis. The main complaint of the patients is abdominal pain accompanied with nausea and vomiting during the last 7 d[12,18]. The duration of symptoms was shorter in patients with typeIgallbladder perforation than in patients with typeIIand III gallbladder perforation in our study. High fever and elevated WBC count are not the diagnostic indications for gallbladder perforation. Parker et al reported that high fever and high WBC count could be observed in 56% and 59% of patients with acute cholecystitis, respectively. The majority of typeIandIIgallbladder perforation cases had fever whereas type III gallbladder perforation cases did not in our study. The patients with typeIandIIgallbladder perforation had elevated WBC count, but those with type III gallbladder perforation had only a mild increase in WBC count.
US findings in acute cholecystitis, such as the GB wall thickening, GB distension, pericholecystic free fluid, and positive sonographic Murphy sign, may also be present in gallbladder perforation cases[2,9,20]. Sood et al noted that the sonographic hole sign, in which the defect in GB wall is visualized, is the only reliable sign of gallbladder perforation. They reported that GB wall defect could be shown with a high resolution ultrasound scanner device in 70% of patients. However, Kim et al reported that the site of defect could not be visualized on US in any patients, which is similar to our study. On the other hand, CT can show more accurate signs of free intraperitoneal fluid, pericholecystic fluid, and abscess[1,2,22]. CT can also show GB wall thickness and the defect on the wall due to perforation[2,20]. In our study, all of the 5 patients who had the diagnosis of gallbladder perforation preoperatively were diagnosed by CT. Since the patients were admitted for acute abdominal pain, standard pelvic CT rather than upper abdominal CT was applied. Kim et al reported that the defect could not be visualized on CT in 54% of patients. Doppler ultrasound, magnetic resonance imaging and radionuclide methods have been used in the diagnosis of gallbladder perforation[23-25]. The majority of our patients with typeII gallbladder perforation were initially treated conservatively and then underwent surgery as no improvement was observed during the first 3 d.
Cholecystectomy, drainage of abscess if present, and abdominal lavage are usually sufficient to treat gallbladder perforation[1,4]. Cholecystectomy may be difficult in type III gallbladder perforations. If a cholesystectomy is performed, additional surgical procedures such as repair of the fistula may be required[15,16]. Cholecystectomy can be performed after the infection is relived by US guided percutaneus drainage in typeIIgallbladder perforations. Laparoscopic cholecystectomy can be performed for acute, gangrenous, and/or perforated cholecystitis as well as uncomplicated cholecystitis, but a conversion may be necessary in case of difficulties like an unclear anatomy[9,16]. In our study, laparoscopic procedure was initiated in 6 patients but conversion was required in two.
Since the difficulties in diagnosis cause delay in treatment, higher morbidity and mortality rates are often encountered[1,2,9]. Glenn and Moore have reported that the mortality rate of gallbladder perforation patients is 42%, while other studies reported that the mortality rates are decreased to 12%-16% owing to the developments in anesthesiology and intensive care conditions[1,3]. The morbidity and mortality rates were 37.5% and 12.5%, respectively in the present study.
In conclusion, early diagnosis of gallbladder perforation and immediate surgical intervention are of crucial importance. Although standard abdominal CT has an important role in diagnosing gallbladder perforation, upper abdominal CT for acute cholecystitis in which pericholecystic fluid is found by US may increase the rate of preoperative diagnosis of gallbladder perforation.
S- Editor Wang GP L- Editor Wang XL E- Editor Bai SH
Roslyn JJ, Thompson JE, Darvin H, DenBesten L. Risk factors for gallbladder perforation.Am J Gastroenterol. 1987;82:636-640.
Sood BP, Kalra N, Gupta S, Sidhu R, Gulati M, Khandelwal N, Suri S. Role of sonography in the diagnosis of gallbladder perforation.J Clin Ultrasound. 2002;30:270-274.
Lennon F, Green WE. Perforation of the gallbladder. A review of 32 cases.J R Coll Surg Edinb. 1983;28:169-173.
Ong CL, Wong TH, Rauff A. Acute gall bladder perforation--a dilemma in early diagnosis.Gut. 1991;32:956-958.
Lein HH, Huang CS. Male gender: risk factor for severe symptomatic cholelithiasis.World J Surg. 2002;26:598-601.
Bedirli A, Sakrak O, Sözüer EM, Kerek M, Güler I. Factors effecting the complications in the natural history of acute cholecystitis.Hepatogastroenterology. 2001;48:1275-1278.
Niemeier OW. Acute Free Perforation of the Gall-Bladder.Ann Surg. 1934;99:922-924.
Abu-Dalu J, Urca I. Acute cholecystitis with perforation into the peritoneal cavity.Arch Surg. 1971;102:108-110.
Menakuru SR, Kaman L, Behera A, Singh R, Katariya RN. Current management of gall bladder perforations.ANZ J Surg. 2004;74:843-846.
Wang AJ, Wang TE, Lin CC, Lin SC, Shih SC. Clinical predictors of severe gallbladder complications in acute acalculous cholecystitis.World J Gastroenterol. 2003;9:2821-2823.
Isch JH, Finneran JC, Nahrwold DL. Perforation of the gallbladder.Am J Gastroenterol. 1971;55:451-458.
Glenn F. Acute cholecystitis.Surg Gynecol Obstet. 1976;143:56-60.
Williams NF, Scobie TK. Perforation of the gallbladder: analysis of 19 cases.Can Med Assoc J. 1976;115:1223-1225.
Doko M, Zovak M, Kopljar M, Glavan E, Ljubicic N, Hochstädter H. Comparison of surgical treatments of gallstone ileus: preliminary report.World J Surg. 2003;27:400-404.
Doherty GM, Way LW. Biliary Tract.Current Surgical Diagnosis & Treatment. 11st ed. New York: McGraw-Hill 2003; 595-624.
Tanaka M, Takahashi H, Yajima Y, Okamura K, Kosaka A, Mizumoto R. Idiopathic perforation of the gallbladder: report of a case and a review of the Japanese literature.Surg Today. 1997;27:360-363.
Felice PR, Trowbridge PE, Ferrara JJ. Evolving changes in the pathogenesis and treatment of the perforated gallbladder. A combined hospital study.Am J Surg. 1985;149:466-473.
Parker LJ, Vukov LF, Wollan PC. Emergency department evaluation of geriatric patients with acute cholecystitis.Acad Emerg Med. 1997;4:51-55.
Forsberg L, Andersson R, Hederström E, Tranberg KG. Ultrasonography and gallbladder perforation in acute cholecystitis.Acta Radiol. 1988;29:203-205.
Kim PN, Lee KS, Kim IY, Bae WK, Lee BH. Gallbladder perforation: comparison of US findings with CT.Abdom Imaging. 1994;19:239-242.
van Sonnenberg E, D'Agostino H, Casola G. Interventional gallbladder procedures.Radiol Clin North Am. 1990;28:1185-1190.
Sood B, Jain M, Khandelwal N, Singh P, Suri S. MRI of perforated gall bladder.Australas Radiol. 2002;46:438-440.
Konno K, Ishida H, Sato M, Naganuma H, Obara K, Andoh H, Watanabe S. Gallbladder perforation: color Doppler findings.Abdom Imaging. 2002;27:47-50.
Stadalnik RC, Matolo NM. Radionuclide imaging of the biliary tree.Surg Clin North Am. 1981;61:827-842.
Glenn F, Moore SW. Gangrene and perforation of the wall of the gallbladder. A sequele of acute cholecystitis.Arch Surg. 1942;44:677-686.