Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2021.
World J Meta-Anal. Aug 28, 2021; 9(4): 342-352
Published online Aug 28, 2021. doi: 10.13105/wjma.v9.i4.342
Table 1 The baseline details of studies included in our meta-analysis considering the groups with raised and normal values of troponin I
Ref.
Country
Population
Mean age
Male/female
Cutoff for TnI raising
Arcari et al[17]Italy Normal TnI: 3966 ± 1728/1114 pg/mL
Raised TnI: 6479 ± 1319/45
Fan et al[18]China Normal TnI: 6758 ± 1538/290.01 μg/L
Raised TnI: 2271 ± 1211/11
Guo et al[19]China Normal TnI: 13553 ± 1357/7899th percentile
Raised TnI: 5271 ± 934/18
Lala et al[20]United StatesNormal TnI: 220666 ± 131312/894318/2120.09 ng/mL
Raised TnI: 53068 ± 15
Lombardi et al[21]ItalyNormal TnI: 33664 ± 13234/102201/7799th percentile
Raised TnI: 27871 ± 12
Lorente-Ros et al[22]Spain Normal TnI: 56063 ± 12367/19314 ng/L
Raised TnI: 14778 ± 1477/70
Raad et al[23]United StatesNormal TnI: 63059 ± 11280/35018 ng/L
Raised TnI: 39070 ± 13229/161
Karbalai Saleh et al[24]Iran Normal TnI: 27157 ± 15167/10499th percentile
Raised TnI: 11565 ± 1569/46
Shah et al[25]United StatesRaised TnI: 11659 ± 1470/1230.05 ng/ml
Normal TnI: 19368 ± 1462/54
Singh et al[26]United StatesNormal TnI: 12953 ± 1154/7517 ng/L
Raised TnI: 13271 ± 1270/62
Table 2 The outcome of coronavirus disease 2019 considering the groups with raised and normal values of troponin
Ref.
Raised TnI rate
Death rate
ARDS
Kidney injury
ICU admission
Arcari et al[17]39/103Raised TnI: 12---------
Normal TnI: 7
Fan et al[18]22/89---Raised TnI: 20Raised TnI: 9---
Normal TnI: 12Normal TnI: 10
Guo et al[19]52/187Raised TnI:3 1Raised TnI: 30Raised TnI: 14Raised TnI: 31
Normal TnI: 12Normal TnI: 16Normal TnI: 4Normal TnI: 14
Lala et al[20]530/2736Raised TnI: 223---------
Normal TnI: 102
Lombardi et al[21]278/614Raised TnI: 102---Raised TnI: 41---
Normal TnI: 43Normal TnI: 13
Lorente-Ros et al[22]147/707Raised TnI: 60; Normal TnI: 130------Raised TnI: 7Normal TnI: 5
Raad et al[23]390/1020Raised TnI: 128Raised TnI: 93Raised TnI: 224Raised TnI: 105
Normal TnI: 52Normal TnI: 64Normal TnI:178Normal TnI:93
Karbalai Saleh et al[24]115/386Raised TnI: 47Raised TnI: 46Raised TnI: 35Raised TnI: 41
Normal TnI: 30Normal TnI: 30Normal TnI: 25Normal TnI: 38
Shah et al[25]116/309Raised TnI: 44---Raised TnI: 13Raised TnI: 58
Normal TnI: 22Normal TnI: 5Normal TnI: 52
Singh et al[26]132/276Raised TnI: 20Raised TnI: 29---Raised TnI: 63
Normal TnI: 5Normal TnI: 10Normal TnI: 25
Table 3 The baseline details of studies included in our meta-analysis considering the survived and non-survived groups
Ref.
Country
Population
Mean age
Male/female
Mean TnI
Aladağ and Atabey[27]Turkey Survived: 3568 ± 1422/13Survived: 0.001 ng/mL
Non-survived: 1568 ± 156/9Non-survived: 0.010 ng/mL
Deng et al[28]China Survived: 21262 ± 1197/115Survived: 0.006 ng/mL
Non-survived: 5274 ± 1533/19Non-survived: 0.051 ng/mL
Liberati et al[15]Italy Survived: 42561 ± 13287/138Survived: 0.006 ng/mL
Non-survived: 9876 ± 1068/30Non-survived: 0.036 ng/mL
Nie et al[29]China Survived: 20060 ± 11180/20Survived: 0.002 ng/mL
Non-survived: 11172 ± 1288/23Non-survived: 0.032 ng/mL
Rath et al[30]GermanySurvived: 10767 ± 1565/42Survived: 0.014 ng/mL
Non-survived: 1673 ± 1612/4Non-survived: 0.024 ng/mL
Shi et al[31]ChinaSurvived: 60961 ± 13287/322Survived: 0.006 ng/mL
Non-survived: 6274 ± 1535/27Non-survived: 0.023 ng/mL
Yang et al[32]ChinaSurvived: 14557 ± 1377/68Survived: 0.004 ng/mL
Non-survived: 5867 ± 1538/20Non-survived: 0.020 ng/mL