Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©2014 Baishideng Publishing Group Inc.
World J Meta-Anal. May 26, 2014; 2(2): 29-35
Published online May 26, 2014. doi: 10.13105/wjma.v2.i2.29
Table 1 Details described on the studies included in meta-analysis
Ref.Study typeLocationTime# of PtsGroupPts/Group
Youn et al[3]RetrospectiveSouth Korea1/07-12/09388Weekend62
4 centersWeekday326
de Groot et al[4]ProspectiveThe Netherlands10/09-9/11571Weekend167
8 centersWeekday404
Byun et al[9]RetrospectiveSouth Korea1/05-2/09294Weekend74
1 centerWeekday220
Jairath et al[11]RetrospectiveUnited Kingdom5/07-6/076749Weekend1499
212 centersWeekday5250
Button et al[22]RetrospectiveWales4/99-3/0724421Weekend5686
22 centersWeekday18285
Dorn et al[18]RetrospectiveUnited States1998-200398975Weekend23339
NIS databaseWeekday75636
Shaheen et al[1]RetrospectiveUnited States1993-2005237412Weekend57270
NIS databaseWeekday180142
Myers et al[10]RetrospectiveUnited States1998-200536734Weekend9237
NIS databaseWeekday27497
Ananthakrishnan et al[2]RetrospectiveUnited States2004419939Weekend97002
NIS databaseWeekday322937
Bell et al[14]RetrospectiveCanada4/88-3/9745167Weekend3602
190 centersWeekday41565
Haas et al[8]RetrospectiveUnited States1/08-10/08174Weekend50
1 centerWeekday124
Table 2 Quality assessment of the studies based upon the effective public health practice project scale
Ref.Selection biasStudy designConfoundersBlindingData collection methodWithdrawals and dropoutsOverall assessment
Youn et al[3]ModerateModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AModerate
de Groot et al[4]StrongSTRONGModerateN/AStrongStrongStrong
Byun et al[9]WeakModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AWeak
Jairath et al[11]StrongModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AModerate
Button et al[22]StrongModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AModerate
Dorn et al[18]StrongModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AModerate
Shaheen et al[1]StrongModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AModerate
Myers et al[10]StrongModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AModerate
Ananthakrishnan et al[2]StrongModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AModerate
Bell et al[14]StrongModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AModerate
Haas et al[8]WeakModerateWeakN/AStrongN/AWeak