Brief Article
Copyright ©2013 Baishideng.
World J Transl Med. Aug 12, 2013; 2(2): 13-21
Published online Aug 12, 2013. doi: 10.5528/wjtm.v2.i2.13
Table 1 Grade scales for the assessment of oral mucositis
World Health Organization GradeGrade 1Grade 2Grade 3Grade 4Grade 5
FunctionPainless ulcers, erythema or mild sorenessPainful erythema, edema, or ulcers but can eat solidsPainful erythema, edema, or ulcers and cannot eat solidsAlimentation is not possible; dependence on IV and feeding-tube
Clinical ExamErythema of the mucosaPatchy ulcerations or pseudomembranesConfluent ulcerations or pseudomembranes; bleeding with minor traumaTissue necrosis; significant spontaneous bleeding; life-threatening consequencesDeath
SymptomsMinimal symptoms, normal diet; minimal respiratory symptoms but not interfering with functionSymptomatic but able to eat and swallow modified diet; respiratory symptoms interfering with function but not with activities of daily livingSymptomatic and unable to adequately aliment or hydrate orally; respiratory symptoms interfering with activities of daily livingSymptoms associated with life-threatening consequencesDeath
Table 2 European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer/Radiation Therapy Oncology Group and the World Health Organization toxicity criteria acute chemoradiation morbidity
Scale for gastrointestinal toxicity
Grade 0Grade 1Grade 2Grade 3Grade 4
Esophagus toxicity gradeNoneMild fibrosis; Slight difficulty in swallowing solids; No pain on swallowingUnable to take solid food normally; Swallowing semi-solid food; Dilation may be indicatedSevere fibrosis; Able to swallow only liquids; May have pain on swallowing; Dilation requiredNecrosis/Perforation Fistula
Small bowel toxicity gradeNoneMild diarrhea; Mild cramping; Bowel movement 5 times dailyModerate diarrhea and colic; Bowel movement > 5 times dailyObstruction or bleeding, requiring surgeryNecrosis/Perforation Fistula
Colorectal toxicity gradeNoneIncreased frequency or change in quality of bowel habits not requiring medication, rectal discomfort not requiring analgesics; Slight rectal discharge or bleedingDiarrhea requiring parasympatholytic drugs, mucous discharge not necessitating sanitary pads, rectal or abdominal pain requiring analgesics; Excessive rectal mucus or intermittent bleedingDiarrhea requiring parenteral support, severe mucous or bloody discharge necessitating sanitary pads/abdominal distension (flat plate radiograph demonstrates distended bowel loops)Acute or subacute obstruction, fistula or perforation; gastrointestinal bleeding requiring transfusion; abdominal pain or tenesmus requiring tube decompression or bowel diversion
World Health Organization colorectalNoneIncrease of 2-3 stools per day over pretreatmentIncrease of 4-6 stools per day, or nocturnal stools, or moderate crampingIncrease of 7-9 stools per day, or incontinence, or severe crampingIncrease of > 10 stools per day or grossly bloody diarrhea, or need for parenteral support
Toxicity grade
Table 3 Modified naranjo probability of intervention-caused response
QuestionsYesNoDon’t knowCase report
1Are there previous conclusive reports on this response?1000 don’t know
2Did the response appear after the intervention was administered?2-10+2 Yes
3Did the response disappear when the intervention was discontinued?+100+1 Yes
4Did the response reappear when the intervention was re-administered?+2-10+2 Yes
5Are there alternative causes that could on their own have caused the reaction?-1+20+2 No
6Did the reaction reappear when a placebo was given?-1+10+1 No
7Was the intervention detected in the blood in concentrations known to be toxic?+1000 No
8Was the response more apparent when the dose was increased, or less apparent when the dose was decreased?+1000 No
9Did the patient have a similar response to the same or similar intervention in any previous exposure?+100+1 Yes
10Was the response confirmed by any objective evidence?+100+1 Yes
Patients total score10