Kheirvari M, Goudarzi H, Hemmatizadeh M, Anbara T. Bariatric surgery outcomes following organ transplantation: A review study. World J Exp Med 2022; 12(5): 92-99 [PMID: 36196436 DOI: 10.5493/wjem.v12.i5.92]
Corresponding Author of This Article
Taha Anbara, FRCS, Academic Fellow, Department of Surgery, Erfan Niayesh Hospital, No. 17 Bahar Intersection, Imam Hossein St., Tehran 14758-94433, Iran. email@example.com
Checklist of Responsibilities for the Scientific Editor of This Article
This article is an open-access article which was selected by an in-house editor and fully peer-reviewed by external reviewers. It is distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Author contributions: Kheirvari M contributed to conception and design; Anbara T provided administrative support; Goudarzi H was responsible for collection and assembly of the data; Goudarzi H and Hemmatizadeh M analyzed the data and polished the manuscript; all authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Conflict-of-interest statement: There are no conflicts of interest to disclose.
Open-Access: This article is an open-access article that was selected by an in-house editor and fully peer-reviewed by external reviewers. It is distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution NonCommercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: https://creativecommons.org/Licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Corresponding author: Taha Anbara, FRCS, Academic Fellow, Department of Surgery, Erfan Niayesh Hospital, No. 17 Bahar Intersection, Imam Hossein St., Tehran 14758-94433, Iran. firstname.lastname@example.org
Received: May 26, 2022 Peer-review started: May 26, 2022 First decision: June 27, 2022 Revised: June 29, 2022 Accepted: August 12, 2022 Article in press: August 12, 2022 Published online: September 20, 2022
Weight gain is a frequent postoperative complication following a solid organ transplant which can be solved by bariatric surgery. The outcomes of bariatric surgery among patients with an organ transplant history are always a challengeable subject for surgeons and surgery candidates. In this review article, we aim to investigate the existence literature about the rates of morbidity and mortality, frequent complications in terms of graft function, remission in diabetes, hypertension, pulmonary and cardiovascular disorders, hepatic and renal functions, and immunosuppressive stability, as well as the safety of bariatric surgery among patients.
Core Tip: In this minireview article, we try to provide a broad introduction to the impacts of bariatric surgery on organ transplantation outcomes rather than as an exhaustive review. Moreover, this review will focus on major transplantations and type of bariatric surgery among morbidly obese patients. Within the broad categories of organ transplantation, we then conclude with remarks about the outcomes of bariatric surgery among patients with combined organ transplantation. Where possible, the readers are suggested to refer to the numerous comprehensive clinical studies reporting the predictors of adverse outcomes of organ transplantation following bariatric surgery.
Citation: Kheirvari M, Goudarzi H, Hemmatizadeh M, Anbara T. Bariatric surgery outcomes following organ transplantation: A review study. World J Exp Med 2022; 12(5): 92-99
Obesity is a frequent complication among patients who underwent solid organ transplantation, and may consequently affect the transplant population at multiple levels[1,2]. Graft function depends not only on the management of immune processes but also on the optimal control of chronic diseases, especially obesity and metabolic syndrome, which may lead to a number of disorders exerting adverse effects, including to the transplanted organ. Obesity in transplantation patients may also negatively impact preoperative and long-term outcomes after bariatric surgery[4,5]. Based on previous reports, obesity was linked to a higher odds of biopsy-proven acute rejection, mortality, allograft loss, and the development of diabetes. Therefore, this study aims to compare the clinical outcomes of bariatric surgery among patients with prior organ transplantation. In this mini-review article, we tried to provide a broad introduction to the impacts of bariatric surgery on organ transplantation outcomes rather than as an exhaustive review. Moreover, this review will focus on major transplantations and type of bariatric surgery among morbidly obese patients including kidney transplantation, liver transplantation, heart transplantation, and sleeve gastrectomy (SG); pancreas transplantation and gastric banding surgery; lung transplantation and robotic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB). Within the broad categories of organ transplantation, we then conclude with remarks about the outcomes of bariatric surgery among patients with combined organ transplantation. Where possible, the readers are suggested to refer to the numerous comprehensive clinical studies reporting the predictors of adverse outcomes of organ transplantation following bariatric surgery.
KIDNEY TRANSPLANTATION AND BARIATRIC SURGERY
The problem of obesity in renal transplant recipients has been well documented. Based on previously published reports, kidney recipients with obesity demonstrated enhanced rate of comorbidities such as respiratory and cardiovascular diseases, diabetes mellitus or posttransplant diabetes mellitus, dyslipidemia, and even wound complications[7-9]. Elli et al evaluated the outcomes of SG in six patients who had a kidney transplant. There were no significant differences in excess weight loss (EWL) or percent of weight loss (WL) between the renal recipient group and patients without a history of kidney transplant. In addition, no preoperative and serious postoperative complications were observed in the transplant group. In another study, four kidney transplant patients diagnosed with hypertension (all subjects) and type 2 diabetes (T2D) underwent SG and 45% of EWL was observed 12 to 24 mo after surgery. The authors reported a significant reduction in antihypertensive medications and complete remission of T2D one year after SG. Significant weight loss, improvement of obesity-related conditions, preservation of graft function, and the estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) were enhanced significantly in the subjects. Furthermore, five renal recipient patients underwent bariatric surgery RYGB and one SG and experienced 50% of EWL at 2 years after procedure. Preoperative evaluation revealed five subjects with hypertension, two with T2D, and one with chronic heart failure among the patients. After surgery, no postoperative complications and no alteration to the dosage of the immunosuppressant drugs were recorded. However, in another study among ten patients with a history of kidney transplants, just two cases needed higher doses of tacrolimus and one decreased based on serum level. Gheith et al in 2017 reported a study to shed light on the effects of bariatric surgery on the outcomes of renal transplant recipients among 22 bariatric patients with a history of kidney transplant and 44 nonbariatric control subjects with a kidney transplant history. The overweight nonbariatric control group received a more potent induction immunosuppression compared to bariatric patients. In addition, no differences in graft functions or new onset of T2D were recorded in 22 bariatric patients with a history of kidney transplant compared to the control group. In a well-designed study, the outcomes of bariatric surgery were evaluated among 26 patients with a history of kidney transplant. However, the patients experienced more than 50% of EWL improvement in comorbidities without serious graft rejection, and declined tacrolimus blood levels (but remained within the therapeutic range), but the surgical risk was higher than the regular bariatric surgery population. Table 1 demonstrates more studies on the outcomes of bariatric surgery in patients with a history of organ transplantation. In the most recent study, among 38 patients with solid organ transplantation, eight had a kidney transplant. Comorbidity-related medications such as tacrolimus were declined in most patients, while two subjects experienced transplant organ rejection after bariatric surgery.
Table 1 Outcomes of bariatric surgery in patients with a history of organ transplants.
There is a positive correlation between body mass index (BMI) and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD), and individuals with obesity undergoing liver transplantation may be at enhanced risk for NAFLD recurrence[15,16]. Whereas some experts prefer to do the liver transplantation first, some others have suggested gastric bypass before liver transplant. In a study on seven patients with a history of orthotopic liver transplantation who underwent RYGB, two deaths in subjects with hepatitis C were reported 6 and 9 mo following bariatric surgery. Gastric bypass may have contributed to the death of one case owing to multiple organ dysfunction syndrome. The other patients experienced improved gylcemic control, therapeutic weight loss, and balanced high-density lipoprotein levels with continued dyslipidemia in a long-time follow-up. In another report, among five liver-recipient patients undergoing SG, five and four in preoperative assessment were diagnosed with hypertension and T2D, respectively. In postoperative screening, the patients illustrated a significant reduction in antihypertensive medications including mycophenolate 720 mg and tacrolimus 2 mg, and completed remission of T2D, and graft function remained preserved in subjects one year after SG. Lin et al reported the outcomes of SG in nine patients with prior liver transplant. In the first month after SG, three subjects were diagnosed with postoperative complications including dysphagia that required reoperation, bile leak from the liver surface requiring laparoscopic drainage, and mesh dehiscence after synchronous incisional hernia repair. Hepatic and renal functions remained stable and no graft rejection was reported after surgery. In a case report study on a 51-year-old male liver recipient, he was diagnosed with steatohepatitis of the graft, gained 30 kg after organ transplant, and was on an oral hypoglycemic agent with HbA1c of 8%. After laparoscopic SG, completed remission in diabetes, reduction in BMI from 42 to 34, and stable graft functions were reported. In one of the most recent studies on 19 cases with prior liver transplant undergoing SG or robotic RYGB, one patient was readmitted for abdominal pain owing to gastric ulcer and related comorbidities were decreased in most of patients[10,14]. There were no organ rejections in this study at the 12-mo follow-up. The tacrolimus blood levels declined to 4-6 ng/mL 6 mo after operation.
HEART TRANSPLANTATION AND SLEEVE GASTRECTOMY
In a previously mentioned study by Khoraki et al, one patient with a history of heart transplant was diagnosed with hypertension. The preferred surgery was SG and after the procedure, the subject experienced 45% of EWL and reduction in antihypertensive medications. Moreover, the left ventricular ejection fraction enhanced by 10% in the patient was reported after surgery. Significant weight loss, improvement of obesity-related conditions, and preservation of graft function were observed after SG. In another study on six cases with heart transplant, three subjects underwent SG and three patients underwent robotic RYGB. One patient died 20 mo after robotic RYGB owing to the adverse effects of the tricuspid valve replacement, not directly related to bariatric surgery. One subject required early readmission due to abdominal pain and shortness of breath. No leaks were documented in either group. The comorbidity-related medications were decreased in other cases[1,19].
PANCREAS TRANSPLANTATION AND GASTRIC BANDING SURGERY
Regarding pancreas recipients, there are no technical modifications to be considered. RYGB is not performed in these patients because of bowel drainage. In a report, two patients with pancreas transplant maintained normal glycemic serum levels with HbA1c levels of 5.8% and 5.3%, respectively, at the one-year follow-up. Weight gain in these patients may induce insulin resistance and return to insulin therapy despite proper graft function. Furthermore, calcineurin inhibitors for maintenance immune suppression can cause insulin resistance, and they are also responsible for weight gain post-transplantation. However, laparoscopic gastric banding surgery to treat insulin resistance in a pancreas transplant recipient yielded good short-term outcomes.
LUNG TRANSPLANTATION AND ROBOTIC RYGB
For patients with lung transplant, robotic RYGB seems a preferable method compared to other types of weight loss surgery due the high reported rate of postoperative reflux[21,22]. In a study on two patients with lung transplant, no organ rejection was reported and comorbidity conditions declined significantly after surgery.
OUTCOMES OF BARIATRIC SURGERY AMONG PATIENTS WITH COMBINED ORGAN TRANSPLANTATION
The outcomes of bariatric surgery in patients with combined transplantation are one of the principal studies that have been performed by some researchers, but more studies with a long-term follow-up period are required to conclude the efficiency of weight loss surgery in this population. For instance, combined kidney-pancreas transplantation is a treatment option for end-stage diabetic nephropathy. Post-transplant weight gain enhances the risk for posttransplant comorbidities and death caused by pulmonary and cardiovascular disorders. Gastric banding is an established treatment for moderate morbid obesity for this population. Based on reports on kidney pancreas recipients, although no organ rejection, declined HbA1c levels and significant weight loss were reported[14,20,23], but no reduction in medication doses was reported postoperatively. In another study on a 65-year-old patient with combined kidney-liver transplant, 30 kg weight gain with the risk of graft impairment was reported 4 years after transplant. It has been reported that, after weight loss surgery, although the surgical risk was higher than the regular bariatric patients, BMI declined significantly with stable graft functions and no development of diabetes[14,19] in patients with a history of kidney-liver transplantation. Immunosuppressive stability was enhanced from 39% to 47% after bariatric surgery in this population. Table 2 presents more details of studies related to the immunosuppressant changes following bariatric surgery in patients with a history of organ transplants.
Table 2 Dose adjustment of immunosuppressive drugs following bariatric surgery in patients with a history of organ transplants.
Type of bariatric surgery
Immunosuppressant adjustment compared to patients without organ transplants
PREDICTORS OF ADVERSE OUTCOMES OF ORGAN TRANSPLANTATION FOLLOWING BARIATRIC SURGERY
Ethnicity and its impact on the outcomes of bariatric surgery among patients with a transplant history, are a remarkable issue that has been addressed by Edwards et al in a recent report. In this survey on 335 patients from white and black races, preoperatively, black subjects were more likely to have hypertension and dialysis dependent chronic disease and be on chronic steroids. Nonetheless, mortality and morbidity rates were similar in both groups. Postoperatively, the black population were prone to have higher rates of renal failure, pulmonary disorders, and emergency readmissions, higher overall bariatric-related morbidity, and higher rates of pneumonia and progressive renal insufficiency compared to the white group. Nevertheless, race was not found to be an independent predictor of adverse outcomes following SG or RYGB in subjects with prior solid organ transplantation. The same results can be seen in another cohort study with 610 patients with organ transplant and 320000 cases without organ transplant. While previous transplant subjects experienced a higher incidence of readmissions, surgical complications, and medical issues than the other group, but no difference in the incidence of death was observed. On the other side, among patients with prior organ transplant, longer operative time and increased rates of morbidity, surgical site infection, acute and progressive renal failure, myocardial infarction, bleeding, and venous thromboembolism are undeniable after bariatric surgery. Considering the potential for poorer outcomes in overweight people with prior solid organ transplant, there is significant interest in identifying optimal modalities to achieve significant and durable weight loss, including metabolic and bariatric surgery.
Cumulatively, reports suggested that bariatric surgery, regardless of the type of procedure (sleeve vs gastric bypass) and surgical approach (robotic assisted vs conventional laparoscopic), ensures significant weight loss and improvement of related conditions, together with good immunosuppressive maintenance, along with the absence of serious graft rejection or dysfunction and with a trivial mortality rate in this high surgical risk population. Due to the lack of a large size survey, we are unable to expand our analyses by bariatric procedure type and surgical approach. These are potential confounders that may have influenced results. Further studies to assess bariatric surgery outcomes by organ transplant subtype and risks of organ rejection are necessary to advance our knowledge on this issue. Obesity medicine experts may choose to use this review article to educate patients with organ transplant about bariatric surgery and the options for them to promote weight loss postoperatively.
I would like to appreciate all who helped us to perform this study.
Provenance and peer review: Unsolicited article; Externally peer reviewed.