BPG is committed to discovery and dissemination of knowledge
Retrospective Cohort Study
Copyright: ©Author(s) 2026.
World J Gastrointest Oncol. Oct 15, 2026; 18(10): 122464
Published online Oct 15, 2026. doi: 10.4251/wjgo.122464
Table 1 Clinical and image characteristics of patients in different cohorts, n (%)
Item
Training (n = 155)
Internal validation (n = 67)
External validation (n = 74)
P value
Tumor size (cm) 2.91 (1.64)2.68 (0.98)2.70 (1.18)0.408
Age (years)57.9 (11.1)58.8 (12.4)58.6 (12.0)0.853
Sex0.833
Female30 (19.4)13 (19.4)12 (16.2)
Male125 (80.6)54 (80.6)62 (83.8)
HBV0.435
Positive53 (34.2)29 (43.3)27 (36.5)
Negative102 (65.8)38 (56.7)47 (63.5)
Cirrhosis0.261
Positive28 (18.1)17 (25.4)11 (14.9)
Negative127 (81.9)50 (74.6)63 (85.1)
N0.949
< 1.864 (41.3)24 (35.8)28 (37.8)
1.8-6.389 (57.4)42 (62.7)45 (60.8)
> 6.32 (1.29)1 (1.49)1 (1.35)
L0.583
≥ 1.167 (43.2)31 (46.3)28 (37.8)
< 1.188 (56.8)36 (53.7)46 (62.2)
ALT0.085
≤ 50115 (74.2)47 (70.1)63 (85.1)
> 5040 (25.8)20 (29.9)11 (14.9)
AST0.347
> 4068 (43.9)27 (40.3)25 (33.8)
≤ 4087 (56.1)40 (59.7)49 (66.2)
GGT0.805
≤ 6085 (54.8)38 (56.7)38 (51.4)
> 6070 (45.2)29 (43.3)36 (48.6)
GLB0.444
≤ 35122 (78.7)52 (77.6)63 (85.1)
> 3533 (21.3)15 (22.4)11 (14.9)
HbsAg0.757
Positive28 (18.1)13 (19.4)11 (14.9)
Negative127 (81.9)54 (80.6)63 (85.1)
AFP0.167
< 4039 (25.2)20 (29.9)15 (20.3)
40-40092 (59.4)30 (44.8)47 (63.5)
> 40024 (15.5)17 (25.4)12 (16.2)
Np0.933
< 1.831 (20.0)10 (14.9)14 (18.9)
1.8-6.370 (45.2)33 (49.3)34 (45.9)
> 6.354 (34.8)24 (35.8)26 (35.1)
Lp0.968
≥ 1.1101 (65.2)43 (64.2)49 (66.2)
< 1.154 (34.8)24 (35.8)25 (33.8)
ALTp0.504
≤ 5033 (21.3)13 (19.4)20 (27.0)
> 50122 (78.7)54 (80.6)54 (73.0)
ASTp0.483
> 40136 (87.7)62 (92.5)64 (86.5)
≤ 4019 (12.3)5 (7.46)10 (13.5)
GGTp0.965
≤ 6092 (59.4)41 (61.2)44 (59.5)
> 6063 (40.6)26 (38.8)30 (40.5)
GLBp0.972
≤ 35115 (74.2)50 (74.6)54 (73.0)
> 3540 (25.8)17 (25.4)20 (27.0)
Capsule appearance0.136
Positive97 (62.6)39 (58.2)36 (48.6)
Negative58 (37.4)28 (41.8)38 (51.4)
Intratumor vascularity0.811
Positive60 (38.7)28 (41.8)27 (36.5)
Negative95 (61.3)39 (58.2)47 (63.5)
Tumor growth patter0.612
Positive113 (72.9)53 (79.1)56 (75.7)
Negative42 (27.1)14 (20.9)18 (24.3)
Intratumor necrosis0.781
Positive92 (59.4)39 (58.2)47 (63.5)
Negative63 (40.6)28 (41.8)27 (36.5)
PACE0.607
Positive123 (79.4)54 (80.6)55 (74.3)
Negative32 (20.6)13 (19.4)19 (25.7)
Tumor margin0.648
Positive100 (64.5)39 (58.2)45 (60.8)
Negative55 (35.5)28 (41.8)29 (39.2)
Ablation method0398
RFA44 (28.4) 21 (31.3) 16 (21.6)
MWA111 (71.6) 46 (68.7) 58 (7.4)
PFS0.659
Absent93 (60.0) 41 (61.2) 49 (66.2)
Present62 (40.0) 26 (38.8) 25 (33.8)
Table 2 Feature selection results from univariate and multivariate analysis
NameUnivariable
Multivariable
OR
95%CI
P value
OR
95%CI
P value
Np
< 1.8------
1.8-6.30.700.30-1.640.4160.720.29-1.770.476
> 6.30.390.16-0.990.0460.290.10-0.800.017
IV
Positive------
Negative2.281.14-4.540.021.670.78-3.570.19
IN
Positive------
Negative2.131.10-4.120.0242.551.17-5.570.018
Table 3 The DeLong test comparisons among different models in the training, internal validation, and external validation cohorts
ModelTraining
Internal validation
External validation
Z value
P value
Z value
P value
Z value
P value
Cli10 mm-3.916< 0.0001-2.3100.0208-2.2120.0230
CliCombined-4.948< 0.0001-3.4980.0005-3.0350.0024
10 mmCombined-1.0860.2773-1.0630.2878-0.7980.4249


Write to the Help Desk