Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2016.
World J Hepatol. Feb 8, 2016; 8(4): 231-262
Published online Feb 8, 2016. doi: 10.4254/wjh.v8.i4.231
Table 10 Differences in gastrointestinal bleeding from portal hypertensive gastropathy vs esophageal varices
ParameterPortal hypertensive gastropathyEsophageal varices
EtiologyPortal hypertension: Cirrhotic or non-cirrhoticPortal hypertension: Cirrhotic or non-cirrhotic
ConcurrenceFrequently occur simultaneously with esophageal varices because the two diseases share common risk factorsFrequently occurs simultaneously with PHG because the two diseases have common risk factors
LocationStomach: Predominantly fundus and bodyDistal esophagus: Also can have gastric varices or ectopic varices in other gastrointestinal regions, particularly duodenum
DiagnosisEsophagogastroduodenoscopyEsophagogastroduodenoscopy
Endoscopic appearanceErythematous small polygonal areas of mucosa surrounded by a fine, whitish, reticular or mosaic/snakeskin mucosa with red or brown spotsSerpiginous mucosal greyish luminal projections in distal esophagus
Clinical presentationMild acute or chronic bleedingAcute gastrointestinal bleeding-typically massive
Severity of bleedingTypically mild and not life-threateningTypically severe and life-threatening
HistologyNot biopsied at endoscopy
Endoscopic therapyLimited roleVariceal ligation recommended as initial therapy. Sclerotherapy an alternative therapy
Medical therapyOctreotideOctreotide
PropranololPropranolol
Vasopressin or vasopressin analogues-infrequently recommended any moreVasopressin or vasopressin analogues-infrequently recommended any more
Blakemore tubeNot recommendedSometimes used for refractory bleeding especially as a temporizing measure before performing more definitive therapy
Angiographic therapyTIPS used as a last resortTIPS recommended if endoscopic therapy fails
Transfusion of packed erythrocytesTransfuse only to hematocrit of about 28. Over-transfusion may increase portal pressure and induce greater bleedingTransfuse only to hematocrit of about 28. Over-transfusion may increase portal pressure and induce greater bleeding
Liver transplantationImproves or resolves with liver transplantationImproves or resolves with liver transplantation
PrognosisRarely fatalFrequently fatal