Brief Article
Copyright ©2012 Baishideng Publishing Group Co.
World J Gastroenterol. Sep 7, 2012; 18(33): 4563-4569
Published online Sep 7, 2012. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v18.i33.4563
Table 1 Baseline characteristics and symptom scores (mean ± SD)
Test group (n = 58)Control group (n = 59)P value
Age (yr)37.43 ± 10.2734.24 ± 8.670.720
Male:female n (%)17 (29.3):41 (70.7)18 (30.5):41 (69.5)0.887
BMI (kg/m2)21.96 ± 3.0121.28 ± 2.500.184
Subtype of IBS n (%)0.919
Constipation19 (32.8)22 (37.3)
Diarrhea19 (32.8)16 (27.1)
Mixed5 (8.6)5 (8.5)
Unsubtyped15 (25.9)16 (27.1)
Abdominal symptoms
Abdominal pain or discomfort (VAS)34.05 ± 18.5533.05 ± 19.940.779
Frequency of abdominal pain or discomfort/d1.73 ± 2.031.21 ± 1.170.089
Abdominal distension or bloating (VAS)44.40 ± 21.9939.83 ± 20.820.281
Flatulence/d5.19 ± 4.014.98 ± 2.880.749
Bowel habit
Defecation frequency/wk6.38 ± 5.985.69 ± 3.870.458
Defecation duration (min)8.68 ± 6.358.85 ± 5.590.881
Urgency n (%)23 (39.7)22 (37.3)0.792
Straining n (%)39 (67.2)37 (62.7)0.608
Feeling of incomplete defecation n (%)39 (67.2)44 (74.6)0.382
Stool consistency (BSS)3.95 ± 1.643.54 ± 1.590.159
Bowel habit satisfaction (VAS)32.33 ± 17.5331.95 ± 18.220.909
Discomfort related to daily life (VAS)36.21 ± 22.5430.93 ± 17.580.160
Table 2 Study parameters at week 8 and changes from baseline in all patients (mean ± SD)
Test group (n = 58)Control group (n = 59)P value1
Baselinewk 8Δ wk 8P valueBaselinewk 8Δ wk 8P value
Abdominal symptoms
Abdominal pain or discomfort (VAS)34.05 ± 18.5512.93 ± 14.99-21.12033.05 ± 19.9416.5 ± 17.7-16.53< 0.0010.26
Frequency of abdominal pain or discomfort/d1.73 ± 2.030.84 ± 0.83-0.890.0041.21 ± 1.170.7 ± 0.8-0.48 0.0010.214
Abdominal distension or bloating (VAS)44.40 ± 21.9925.86 ± 18.1-18.53039.83 ± 20.8228.8 ± 21.2-11.02< 0.0010.096
Flatulence/d5.19 ± 4.015.69 ± 5.08 0.50.3914.98 ± 2.885.5 ± 4.0 0.51 0.2660.991
Bowel habits
Defecation frequency/wk6.38 ± 5.987.23 ± 4.28 0.850.2895.69 ± 3.876.7 ± 4.2 1.04 0.0520.843
Defecation duration (min)8.68 ± 6.357.47 ± 4.95-1.220.078.85 ± 5.596.7 ± 3.9-2.12< 0.0010.301
Urgency23 (39.7%)16 (27.6%)-70.11822 (37.3%)22 (37.3%) 0 10.146
Straining39 (67.2%)22 (37.9%)-17037 (62.7%)20 (33.9%)-17 0.0020.959
Feeling of incomplete evacuation39 (67.2%)19 (32.8%)-20044 (74.6%)23 (39.0%)-21< 0.0010.815
Stool consistency (BSS)3.95 ± 1.643.72 ± 1.02-0.220.2743.53 ± 1.593.88 ± 1.15 0.36 0.0470.118
Bowel habit satisfaction (VAS)32.33 ± 17.5359.48 ± 19.21 27.16031.95 ± 18.2247.5 ± 20.1 15.51< 0.0010.01
Discomfort related to daily life (VAS)36.21 ± 22.5421.98 ± 19.91-14.22030.93 ± 17.5822.9 ± 17.5-8.05 0.0070.199
Improvement in overall IBS symptoms (VAS)64.2 ± 17.050.4 ± 20.5 < 0.001
Table 3 Study parameters at week 8 and changes from baseline in constipation-predominant irritable bowel syndrome patients (mean ± SD)
Test group (n = 19)Control group (n = 22)P value1
Baselinewk 8Δ wk 8P valueBaselinewk 8Δ wk 8P value
Abdominal symptoms
Abdominal pain or discomfort (VAS)28.95 ± 20.909.21 ± 12.39-19.740.00137.50 ± 25.3015.91 ± 18.17-21.590.0010.8
Frequency of abdominal pain of discomfort/d1.50 ± 1.170.89 ± 0.88-0.610.0321.27 ± 1.560.68 ± 0.78-0.60.0290.979
Abdominal distension or bloating (VAS)44.74 ± 21.3825.00 ± 16.67-19.740.00738.64 ± 22.7926.14 ± 16.33-12.50.0310.393
Flatulence/wk6.05 ± 5.036.13 ± 4.35 0.080.9525.52 ± 3.346.02 ± 4.95 0.50.5770.785
Bowel habit
Defecation frequency/wk3.82 ± 2.085.61 ± 3.54 1.790.0023.43 ± 1.555.39 ± 3.97 1.960.0320.872
Defecation duration (min)12.26 ± 7.339.66 ± 5.28-2.610.10610.84 ± 6.496.59 ± 4.07-4.25 < 0.0010.358
Urgency4 (21.1%)4 (21.1%)  013 (13.6%)6 (27.3%) 30.3750.336
Straining18 (94.7%)11 (57.9%)-70.01618 (81.8%)12 (54.5%)-60.1460.321
Feeling of incomplete evacuation15 (78.9%)7 (36.8%)-80.02116 (72.7%)9 (40.9%)-70.0160.776
Stool consistency (BSS)2.26 ± 0.453.05 ± 0.85 0.78902.18 ± 0.663.27 ± 1.08 1.090.0010.386
Bowel habit satisfaction30.26 ± 19.6856.58 ± 20.14 26.32027.27 ± 18.7644.32 ± 21.73 17.050.0040.21
Discomfort related to daily life (VAS)34.21 ± 22.3818.42 ± 16.33-15.790.01436.36 ± 21.4527.73 ± 15.25-13.640.0150.782
Improvement in overall IBS symptoms (VAS)72.4 ± 18.450.0 ± 21.8 < 0.001
Table 4 Study parameters at week 8 and changes from baseline in diarrhea-predominant irritable bowel syndrome patients (mean ± SD)
Test group (n = 19)Control group (n = 16)P value1
Baselinewk 8Δ wk 8P valueBaselinewk 8Δ wk 8P value
Abdominal symptoms
Abdominal pain or discomfort (VAS)32.89 ± 14.569.21 ± 14.93-23.68029.69 ± 10.0820.3 ± 18.8-9.380.0830.05
Frequency of abdominal pain or discomfort/d2.45 ± 3.180.63 ± 0.83-1.820.0361.25 ± 0.710.91 ± 0.94-0.340.2450.117
Abdominal distension or bloating (VAS)43.42 ± 23.3425.00 ± 20.41-18.420.01235.94 ± 15.7329.69 ± 20.85-6.250.1640.146
Flatulence/wk4.63 ± 2.364.08 ± 2.67-0.550.5034.66 ± 2.155.50 ± 3.38 0.840.2550.212
Bowel habit
Defecation frequency/wk10.55 ± 8.188.79 ± 4.46-1.760.3819.09 ± 4.199.09 ± 4.12 010.451
Defecation duration (min)6.66 ± 5.576.58 ± 4.98-0.080.9388.00 ± 4.757.03 ± 3.81-0.970.30.52
Urgency10 (52.6%)8 (42.1%)-20.62512 (75.0%)11 (68.8%)-110.867
Straining8 (42.1%)3 (15.8%)-50.0637 (43.8%)2 (12.5%)-50.0630.707
Feeling of incomplete evacuation13 (68.4%)6 (31.6%)-70.03912 (75.0%)5 (31.3%)-70.0160.826
Stool consistency (BSS)5.42 ± 1.174.16 ± 0.38-1.260.0015.50 ± 1.104.88 ± 1.09-0.630.0360.738
Bowel habit satisfaction31.58 ± 18.3464.47 ± 19.21 32.9040.63 ± 15.4848.44 ± 17.00 7.810.1730.006
Discomfort related to daily life (VAS)36.84 ± 24.1123.68 ± 25.65-13.160.16329.69 ± 13.6028.13 ± 17.97-1.560.7510.292
Improvement in overall IBS symptoms (VAS)61.8 ± 17.451.6 ± 14.30.07