Evidence Review
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2020.
World J Meta-Anal. Oct 28, 2020; 8(5): 348-374
Published online Oct 28, 2020. doi: 10.13105/wjma.v8.i5.348
Table 5 Prevalence of hepatic abnormalities reported in different studies, n (%)
Ref.LocationNumber of patientsAST elevationALT elevationT. Bili elevation
Huang et al[42]Wuhan, China4115 (37)NANA
Chen et al[1]Wuhan, China9935 (35)28 (28)18 (18)
Zhou et al[84]Wuhan, China191NA59 (31)NA
Chen et al[86]Wuhan, China27484 (31)60 (27)NA
Xu et al[91]Wuhan, China355102 (28.7)91 (25.6)66 (18.6)
Huang et al[94]Wuhan, China3618 (58)4 (13.3)4 (12.9)
Shu et al[97]Wuhan, China54535 (10.1)41 (7.5)189 (34.7)
Cai et al[146]Shenzhen City, Guangdong, China29825 (8.4)39 (13.1)24 (8.1)
Ai et al[98]Xiangyang, China10226 (25.5)20 (19.6)NA
Zhao et al[102]Hefei, Anhui, China7514 (18.7)15 (20)12 (16)
Zhao et al[100]Beijing, China7720 (26)26 (33.8)NA
Qi et al[105]Chongqing, China26719 (7.1)20 (7.5)6 (2.2)
Lin et al[107]Zhuhai, Guangdong, China954 (4.2)5 (5.3)22 (23.2)
Xu et al[109]Multiple locations in China (All outside Hubei province)45NANANA
Yan et al[110]Hainan Province, China16818 (17.3)9 (8)7 (6.4)
Wang et al[111]Zhengzhou, Henan, China18Abnormal LFTs 4 (25)NA
Chen et al[112]Changsha and Loudi, Hunan, China29144 (15.1)30 (10.3)27(9.3)
Yao et al[115]Xi’an, Shaanxi, China4016 (40)21 (52.5)10 (25)
Tian et al[116]Liaocheng, Shandong, China374 (10.8)2 (5.4)13 (35.1)
Fu et al[120]Kunming, Yunnan, China364 (11.1)4 (11.1)11 (30.56)
Xu et al[121]Zhejiang, China6210 (16.1)NANA
Qian et al[122]Multiple sites, Zhejiang, China919 (9.9)7 (7.7)NA
Chen et al[123]Multiple sites, Wenzhou, Zhejiang, China17519 (11)23 (13)NA
Guan et al[48]Multiple sites across China1099168 (22.2)158 (21.3)76 (10.5)
Ferm et al[77]New York, United States892Borderline elevation (1-2 × ULN) 40%Borderline elevation (1-2 × ULN) 26.5%4.3%
mild elevation (2-5 × ULN) 13.8%mild elevation (2-5 × ULN) 11.5%
moderate to severe elevation (> 5 × ULN) 2.8%moderate to severe (> 5 × ULN) 1.9%
Tabata et al[131]Diamond Princess Cruise, Japan10418 (17.3)17 (16.3)NA