BPG is committed to discovery and dissemination of knowledge
Meta-Analysis
Copyright: ©Author(s) 2026.
World J Meta-Anal. Mar 18, 2026; 14(1): 112793
Published online Mar 18, 2026. doi: 10.13105/wjma.v14.i1.112793
Table 2 Baseline patient characteristics, mean ± SD/ mean (95%CI)
Ref.Age (year)
Weight (kg)
Body mass index (kg/m²)
Duration of bronchoscopy
Heart rate (bpm)
Mean systolic blood pressure (mmHg)
Mean diastolic blood pressure (mmHg)
Mean oxygen saturation, saturation of oxygen in blood
Intervention
Control
Intervention
Control
Intervention
Control
Intervention
Control
Intervention
Control
Intervention
Control
Intervention
Control
Intervention
Control
Magazine et al[27], 202447.65 ± 13.4150.23 ± 11.9752.94 ± 12.3657.16 ± 10.9520.90 ± 4.8621.83 ± 3.1915.35 ± 11.9312.84 ± 8.1189.87 ± 11.3585.94 ± 16.86133.77 ± 22.38124.68 ± 14.1683.29 ± 8.7776.61 ± 9.3199.45 ± 1.5099.23 ± 1.28
Magazine et al[28], 202148.50 ± 13.13844.42 ± 12.04750.55 ± 10.2050.07 ± 7.8120.25 ± 2.8020.05 ± 3.3613.42 ± 6.80110.54 ± 3.70681.92 ± 18.53384.83 ± 15.670127.42 ± 20.930126.58 ± 20.90574.08 ± 11.08878.92 ± 9.52899.92 ± 0.408100.00 ± 0.000
Kim et al[29], 202163.7 ± 11.363.9 ± 11.0--23.4 ± 2.923.7 ± 2.6----------
Zhang et al[31], 202158.03 ± 14.0460.23 ± 11.5663.40 ± 11.6061.76 ± 9.72--24.40 ± 12.3720.29 ± 10.96--------
Magazine et al[30], 202047.07 ± 13.4045.00 ± 14.2653.23 ± 8.6950.37 ± 9.8420.61 ± 3.2719.98 ± 3.51--87.85 ± 16.1987.41 ± 16.31131.63 ± 22.56126.67 ± 18.9277.85 ± 9.5377.19 ± 11.49100.00 ± 099.85 ± 0.53
Goneppanavar et al[32], 201549.70 ± 13.8552.52 ± 15.0553.26 ± 10.1056.07 ± 10.8420.77 ± 3.4020.42 ± 3.468.93 ± 2.968.19 ± 2.53--------
Liao et al[33], 201258.5 ± 9.160.1 ± 8.457.0 ± 8.458.2 ± 11.3--12.8 ± 2.613.1 ± 2.6--------
Kumari et al[34], 202144 ± 1449 ± 1463 ± 1365 ± 13------------
Zhou et al[21], 202461 (55-65)60 (52-66)60 (53-68)61 (54-70)22.24 ± 2.78722.60 ± 2.74213 (10-18.5)13 (10-19)--------
Riachy et al[22], 201863----16--------
Yuan et al[23], 201659.76 ± 7.6160.46 ± 69.3--22.20 ± 3.0621.69 ± 3.1620.64 ± 2.0821.14 ± 1.87--------
Shoukry et al[24], 201650.3 ± 14.947.9 ± 15.377.9 ± 14.280.3 ± 14.0--21.8 ± 3.921.5 ± 3.6--------
Mani et al[26], 2015--164.961.3 ± 6.15----------
Ryu et al[25], 201252.9 (27-67)52.9 (23-69)62.1 ± 13.860.6 ± 13.8--12.1 ± 2.812.0 ± 3.4--------


Write to the Help Desk