Case Control Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2023.
World J Crit Care Med. Jun 9, 2023; 12(3): 165-175
Published online Jun 9, 2023. doi: 10.5492/wjccm.v12.i3.165
Table 1 The clinical pulmonary infection score
Assessed parameter
Result
Score
Temperature (°Celsius) 36.5–38.4 °C0
38.5–38.9 °C1
≤ 36 or ≥ 39 °C2
Leukocytes in blood (cells/mm3)4000–11000/mm30
< 4000 or > 11000/mm31
≥ 500 band cells2
Tracheal secretions (subjective visual scale)None0
Mild/non-purulent1
Purulent2
Radiographic findings (on chest radiography, excluding CHF and ARDS)No infiltrate 0
Diff use/patchy infiltrate1
Localized infiltrate2
Culture results (endotracheal aspirate)No or mild growth 0
Moderate or florid growth1
Moderate or florid growth and pathogen consistent with gram stain2
Oxygenation status > 240 or ARDS 1
≤ 240 and absence of ARDS 2
Table 2 Comparison between ventilator-associated pneumonia and non-ventilator-associated pneumonia groups for risk factors and complications, n (%)
Risk factors and complications
VAP group, n = 46
Non-VAP group, n = 109
P value
Age, mean ± SD52.74 ± 20.4261.45 ± 65.05> 0.5
Sex, males%32 (69.57)73 (66.97)> 0.5
Number of hospital days before intubation, mean ± SD5.39 ± 8.113.38 ± 6.37> 0.5
Number of ICU days before intubation, mean ± SD0.52 ± 1.940.47 ± 2.78> 0.5
Presence of comorbidities Diabetes mellitus19 (41.30)54 (49.54)> 0.5
Hypertension 19 (41.30)67 (61.47)> 0.5
Chronic kidney disease7 (15.22)28 (25.69)> 0.5
Ischemic heart disease6 (13.04)25 (22.94)> 0.5
Neurological disorder5 (10.87)9 (8.26)> 0.5
Malignancy4 (8.70)3 (2.75)> 0.5
Liver disease3 (6.52)8 (7.34)> 0.5
Sickle cell disease3 (6.52)3 (2.75)> 0.5
Hospital courseLength of ICU stay, mean ± SD21.41 ± 11.8911.01 ± 10.38< 0.001a
Duration of mechanical ventilation, mean ± SD16.67 ± 8.7012.03 ± 10.530.009a
Extubation 18 (39.13)79 (72.48)< 0.001a
Need of re-intubation 12 (26.09)11 (10.09)0.014a
Tracheostomy 14 (30.43)9 (8.26)< 0.001a
Potential complicationSeptic shock28 (60.87)31 (28.44)< 0.001a
ARDS15 (32.61)12 (11.01)0.002a
Acute kidney injury24 (52.17)36 (33.03)0.031a
Pneumothorax1 (2.17)2 (1.83)> 0.5
Mortality, deaths14 (30.43)21 (19.27)> 0.5
Table 3 Most common organisms isolated among patients with ventilator-associated pneumonia, n (%)
OrganismTotalEarly-onset VAP (Number 9)
Late-onset VAP (Number 37)
Number (of total)
MDR
Number (of total)
MDR
Total gram negative38 (82.6)8 (21)6 (75)30 (79)21 (70)
Acinetobacter baumannii19 (50)4 (21)4 (100)15 (79)14 (93)
Klebsiella pneumoniae8 (21.1)3 (37.5)2 (66.6)5 (62.5)5 (100)
Pseudomonas aeruginosa3 (9)003 (100)1 (33.3)
Stenotrophomonas maltophilia5 (13.1)005 (100)0
Enterobacter asburiae1 (2.6)1 (100)000
E coli1 (2.6)0011 ESBL (100)
Hemophilus influenzae1 (2.6)001 (100)0
Total gram positive5 (11)005 (100)
Staph aureus4 (80)004 (100)0
MRSA1 (20)001 (100)0
00000
00000
Fungal infection
Candida species3 (100)1 (33.3)02 (66.6)0
Total microorganisms46 (100)9 (19.6)6 (13)37 (80.4)
Table 4 Antibiotics sensitivity percentage of the common gram-positive causative organisms for patients with ventilator-associated pneumonia in our study, n (%)
Antimicrobial agent
MSSA, n = 4
MRSA, n = 1
Penicillin0/4 = 0 (0)0/1 = 0 (0)
Oxacillin4 (100)0/1 = 0 (0)
Erythromycin4 (100)1 (100)
Clindamycin4 (100)1 (100)
Tetracycline4 (100)1 (100)
Vancomycin4 (100)1 (100)
Table 5 Antibiotics sensitivity percentage of the common gram-negative causative organisms for ventilator-associated pneumonia in our study, n (%)
Antimicrobial agent
Acinetobacter baumannii
Klebsiella pneumoniae
Stenotrophomonas maltophilia
Pseudomonas aeruginosa
Number of organisms19 (50)8 (42)5 (26)3 (16)
Ceftazidime1 (5.2)01 (20)3 (100)
Trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole7 (37)4 (50)5 (100)-
Levofloxacin01 (12.5)5 (100)-
Minocycline--5 (100)-
Piperacillin-tazobactam1 (5.2)0-3 (100)
Cefepime1 (5.2)1 (12.5)-3 (100)
Meropenem1 (5.2)1 (12.5)-2 (66.6)
Imipenem1 (5.2)1 (12.5)-2 (66.6)
Ertapenem1 (5.2)1 (12.5)-2 (66.6)
Colistin19 (100)5 (62.5)-3 (100)
Gentamicin7 (37)3 (37.5)-3 (100)
Amikacin7 (37)3 (37.5)-3 (100)
Ciprofloxacin1 (5.2)1 (12.5)-3 (100)
Tigecycline4 (21)7 (87.5)--
Ampicillin ----
Amoxiclav -1 (12.5)--
Cefuroxime -1 (12.5)--
Ceftriaxone -1 (12.5)--