Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Surg Proced. Mar 28, 2015; 5(1): 147-154
Published online Mar 28, 2015. doi: 10.5412/wjsp.v5.i1.147
Table 5 Patient characteristics
Ref.Age (yr)
Laparoscopic Group
Open Group
BMI
Distance from Anal Verge (cm)
Laparoscopic Group
Open Group
LapOpenMenWomenMenWomenLapOpenLapOpenARAPRARAPR
1Kang et al[9]57.8 (11.1)59.1 (9.9)64.7%35.3%64.7%35.3%24.1 (3.2)24.1 (3.2)5.6 (2.3)5.3 (2.5)151 (88.8%)19 (11.2%)146 (85.9%)24 (14.1%)
Kusano et al[11]58 (32-82)55 (39-73)15 (78.9%)4 (21.1%)8 (57.1%)6 (42.9%) ≤ 25 = 14 (73.7%) > 25 = 5 (26.3%) ≤ 25 = 9 (64.3%) >25 = 5 (35.7%)2 (0-50)3.7 (0-10)11 (57.9%)8 (42.1%)4 (28.6%)10 (71.4%)
Hu et al[14]55 (35-78)55 (29-82)34 (66.7%)17 (33.3%)56 (65.1%)30 (34.9%)23.4 (16-31.2)24.2 (16.3-36.2) ≤ 5 = 33 (64.7%) > 5 = 18 (35.3%) ≤ 5 = 54 (62.8%) > 5 = 32 (37.2%)32 (62.7%)18 (35.3%)36 (41.9%)44 (51.2%)
Seshadri et al[12]48 (22-73)48 (19-71)47 (65%)25 (35%)45 (62%)27 (38%)21 (15-33)22 (14-38)3 (0-8)3 (0-10)8 (11%)64 (89%)8 (11%)64 (89%)
1Denoya et al[15]56.357.119 (59.4%)13 (40.6%)18 (56.3%)14 (43.7%)2526.44.14.624 (75%)8 (25%)24 (75%)8 (25%)
Denost et al[10]65 (20-85)NA179 (61.3%)113 (38.7%)NANA25 (16-39)NA< 5 = 175 (59.9%) > 5 = 117 (40.1%)NANRNRNANA
Motson et al[7]63 (39-81)NA21 (80.8%)5 (19.2%)NANANRNA< 5 = 11 (42.3%) > 5 = 15 (57.7%)NA16 (61.5%)10 (38.5%)NANA