Minireviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2019.
World J Clin Oncol. Jan 10, 2019; 10(1): 14-27
Published online Jan 10, 2019. doi: 10.5306/wjco.v10.i1.14
Table 1 Study characteristics and tumor control results
StudyNo.F/u (median)Age (median)LocStageDose/fxOSLCRCDC
Miyakawa et al[20], 2017714477C + PT1-2N0M048-52 Gy/ 4 fx5-yr 65%5-yr 85%NANA
Sun et al[80], 2017658671C + PT1-2N0M050 Gy/4 fx7-yr 48%7-yr 92%7-yr 86%7-yr 86%
Singh et al[22], 2017, I-1244079827NAPT1-2N0M030 Gy/1 fx and 60 Gy/3fx2-yr 71% (30 Gy)NANANA
2-yr 61% (60 Gy)
Bezjak et al[24], 2016, RTOG 08137133 (57.5 Gy)NACT1-2N0M057.5-60 Gy/5 fx2-yr 70% (57.5 Gy)2-yr 90% (57.5 Gy)2-yr 95% (57.5 Gy)2-yr 84% (57.5 Gy)
30 (60 Gy)2-yr 88% (60 Gy)2-yr 88% (60 Gy)2-yr 88% (60 Gy)2-yr 85% (60 Gy)
Navarro-Martin et al[11], 2016384274PT1-3N0M054 Gy/3 fx3-yr 66%3-yr 94%3-yr 79%3-yr 87%
Nyman et al[14], 2016, SPACE1023774 (mean)PT1-2N0M066 Gy/3 fx3-yr 54%3-yr 86%3-yr 93%3-yr 76%
Chang et al[15], 2015, STARS and ROSEL314067C + PT1-2N0M054 Gy/3 fx, 50 Gy/4 fx, 60 Gy/5 fx3-yr 95%3-yr 96%3-yr 90%3-yr 97%
Lindberg et al[19], 2015574275 (mean)PT1-2N0M045 Gy/3 fx5-yr 30%5-yr 79%3-yr 81% for regional/distant controlNA
Nagata et al[12], 2015, JCOG 040316947 (inop)78NAT1N0M048 Gy/4 fx3-yr 60%3-yr 87% (inop)3-yr 92% (inop)3-yr 78% (inop)
67 (op)5-yr 43% (inop)3-yr 85% (op)3-yr 75% (op)3-yr 67% (op)
3-yr 77%
5-yr 54% (op)
Shibamoto et al[6], 20151805377C + PT1-2N0M044-52 Gy /4 fx5-yr 52%5-y 83%5-yr 84%5-yr 76%
Videtic et al[13], 2015, RTOG 0915943075PT1-2N0M034 Gy/1 fx and 48 Gy/4 fx3-yr 56%3-yr 98%NANA
Timmerman et al[18], 2014, RTOG 0236554872PT1-2N0M054 Gy/3 fx5-yr 40%5-yr 80%5-yr 62% (local-regional control)5-yr 79%
Taremi et al[26], 20121081973 (mean)C + PT1-2N0M048 Gy/4 fx or 54-60 Gy/3 fx (P)4-yr 30%4-yr 89%4-yr 87%4-yr 83%
50-60 Gy /8-10 fx (C)
Bral et al[46], 2011401673 (mean)C + PT1-3N0M060 Gy/3-4 fx2-yr 52%2-yr 84%2 nodal recurrences6 distant recurrences
Ricardi et al[16], 2010622874PStage I45 Gy/3 fx3-yr 57%3-yr 88%3-yr 94%3-yr 76%
Fakiris et al[17], 2009705070C + PT1-2N0M060-66 Gy/ 3 fx3-yr 43%3-yr 88%3-yr 91%3-yr 87%
Koto et al[10], 2007313277C + PT1-2N0M045 Gy/3 fx or 60 Gy/8 fx3-yr 72%3-yr 78% (T1)3-yr 94%3-yr 81%
3-yr 40% (T2)
McGarry et al[7], 20054727 (Stage IA)71 (Stage IA)C + PT1-2N0M024-72 Gy/ 3 fxNA2-yr 81%2-yr 81%2-yr 79%
19 (Stage IB)74 (Stage IB)
Nagata et al[8], 20054530 (Stage IA)77 (Stage IA)C + PT1-2N0M048 Gy/4 fx2-yr 90% (Stage IA)1-yr 100%2-yr 91%2-yr 88% (Stage IA)
22 (Stage IB)73 (Stage IB)2-yr 72% (Stage IB)2-yr 77% (Stage IB)