Efficacy of telemedicine on glycaemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes: A meta-analysis

doi:10.4239/wjd.v12.i2.170

Advanced Search

BPG is committed to discovery and dissemination of knowledge

Home / Archive / Volume 12, Issue 2

This Article

Academic Content and Language Evaluation of This Article

CrossCheck and Google Search of This Article

Academic Rules and Norms of This Article

Supplementary Materials of This Article

Citation of this article

Corresponding Author of This Article

Research Domain of This Article

Article-Type of This Article

Open-Access Policy of This Article

Times Cited Counts in Google of This Article

Number of Hits and Downloads for This Article

Total Article Views (16318)

All Articles published online

The chart showing PDF series, WORD series, HTML series, Figures (1-3) series, Tables (1-3) series.

Item

Count

PDF

772

WORD

205

HTML

12421

Figures (1-3)

260

Tables (1-3)

324

Sum=13982

Featured Article

The chart showing Browse series, Download series.

Item

Count

Browse

400

Download

665

Sum=1065

Publishing Process of This Article

Item

Count

Browse

547

Download

722

Sum=1269

Feb 15, 2021 (publication date) through Apr 27, 2024

Times Cited of This Article

Times Cited (38)

Journal Information of This Article

Publication Name

World Journal of Diabetes

ISSN

1948-9358

Publisher of This Article

Baishideng Publishing Group Inc, 7041 Koll Center Parkway, Suite 160, Pleasanton, CA 94566, USA

Meta-Analysis

World J Diabetes. Feb 15, 2021; 12(2): 170-197
Published online Feb 15, 2021. doi: 10.4239/wjd.v12.i2.170

Table 3 HbA1c subgroup analysis for included studies

Subgroups	Studies (n)	Participant (n)	Mean difference			Effect size
	Studies (n)	Participant (n)	Q test	Mean difference (95%CI)	I² (%)	Q test	Effect size (95%CI)	I² (%)
Mode of intervention
Text message	5	469	55.331	-0.591 (-0.892, -0.290)^c	92.771^c	133.957	-1.377 (-2.503, -0.252)^a	97.014^c
Mobile app	12	1154	321.220	-0.359 (-0.502, -0.215)^c	96.576^c	281.110	-1.308 (-2.009, -0.607)^c	96.087^c
Interactive telephone	2	170	9.069	-0.782 (-1.172, -0.391)^c	88.974b	2.226	-2.600 (-3.243, -1.957)^c	55.074
Internet server/computer network	7	1288	353.994	-0.431 (-0.558, -0.304)^c	98.305^c	332.245	-1.751 (-2.819, -0.684)^c	98.194^c
Website	14	1875	843.158	-0.539 (-0.706, -0.371)^c	98.458^c	696.131	-1.747 (-2.587, -0.907)^c	98.133^c
Video conference	2	164	1.687	-0.845 (-1.144, -0.546)^c	40.719	25.261	-1.450 (-3.323, 0.424)	96.041^c
Device or tablet	5	1812	332.123	-0.278 (-0.747, 0.191)^c	98.796^c	162.677	-0.905 (-1.725, -0.085)^a	97.541^c
Duration of intervention, months
≤ 6	6	1158	222.519	-0.363 (-0.567, -0.159)^c	97.753^c	239.478	-1.290 (-2.186, -0.394)^b	97.912^c
6	20	2234	1260.455	-0.626 (-0.766, -0.486)^c	98.493^c	740.442	-2.054 (-2.712, -1.396)^c	97.434^c
> 6	21	2565	1173.100	-0.380 (-0.507, -0.252)^c	98.295^c	674.872	-1.080 (-1.583, -0.578)^c	97.036^c
Focus of intervention
Biomedical parameters	16	2633	1830.624	-0.687 (-0.821, -0.553)^c	99.181^c	844.645	-2.406 (-3.174, -1.639)^c	98.224^c
Self-management behaviors	7	334	64.189	-0.360 (-0.805, 0.086)	90.653^c	139.861	-0.740 (-1.753, 0.274)	95.710^c
Biomedical and self-management	24	3965	687.693	-0.348 (-0.442, -0.253)^c	96.655^c	645.659	-1.171 (-1.583, -0.759)^c	96.438^c
Telemedicine method
Telemonitoring	19	3076	1872.902	-0.553 (-0.662, -0.445)^c	99.039c	1107.777	-2.263 (-2.991, -1.534)^c	98.375^c
Tele-education	12	994	125.448	-0.495 (-0.683, -0.307)^c	91.231c	289.370	-1.068 (-1.767, -0.368)^b	96.199^c
Telemonitoring and tele-education	16	2862	501.993	-0.391 (-0.542, -0.240)^c	97.012c	287.276	-1.002 (-1.415, -0.588)^c	94.779^c
Model of intervention
Behavior change	28	2773	629.401	-0.452 (-0.575, -0.329)^c	95.710^c	596.338	-1.041 (-1.426, -0.656)^c	95.472^c
Treatment	13	2248	1518.194	-0.589 (-0.725, -0.453)^c	99.210^c	710.693	-2.386 (-3.249, -1.522)^c	98.312^c
Behavior change and treatment	6	1911	448.804	-0.401 (-0.612, -0.189)^c	98.886^c	332.288	-1.934 (-3.070, -0.799)^c	98.495^c
Intervention lead
Doctor	11	987	522.974	-0.288 (-0.512, -0.064)^a	98.088^c	391.153	-0.922 (-1.795, -0.048)^a	97.443^c
Nurse	15	2747	868.940	-0.491 (-0.655, -0.327)^c	98.389^c	474.130	-1.606 (-2.205, -1.006)^c	97.047^c
Multi-disciplinary	17	2941	1237.843	-0.534 (-0.643, -0.425)^c	98.707^c	852.270	-2.038 (-2.702, -1.375)^c	98.123^c
Allied health	4	257	8.094	-0.939 (-1.651, -0.227)^b	62.935^a	11.197	-0.600 (-1.137, -0.062)^a	73.208^b
Dropout rate
0%-9.9%	20	2659	779.280	-0.458 (-0.584, -0.333)^c	97.562^c	571.285	-1.138 (-1.62, -0.657)^c	96.674^c
10%-19.9%	16	2795	709.022	-0.645 (-0.786, -0.504)^c	97.884^c	740.889	-2.329 (-3.107, -1.552)^c	97.975^c
20% +	10	994	365.413	-0.297 (-0.472, -0.121)^c	97.537^c	267.256	-0.902 (-1.632, -0.171)^a	96.632^c
Frequency of intervention
Daily	19	2176	996.897	-0.439 (-0.577, -0.302)^c	98.194^c	593.016	-1.408 (-1.959, -0.857)^c	96.965^c
< daily to > weekly	10	2005	627.889	-0.307 (-0.462, -0.152)^c	98.567^c	602.249	-1.452 (-2.300, -0.605)^c	98.506^c
Weekly	7	1095	448.790	-0.791 (-1.167, -0.416)^c	98.663^c	353.155	-2.340 (-3.576, -1.105)^c	98.301^c
< weekly	5	1162	30.212	-0.835 (-1.068, -0.602)^c	86.760^c	131.622	-2.423 (-3.943, -0.902)^b	96.961^c
Not mentioned	6	494	33.795	-0.227 (-0.690, 0.237)	85.205^c	42.744	-0.360 (-1.010, 0.290)	88.302^c
Rate of use/engagement
≤ 70%	5	808	406.483	-0.212 (-0.526, 0.102)	99.016^c	254.620	-1.060 (-2.422, 0.303)	98.429^c
> 70%	8	1287	150.709	-0.576 (-0.696, -0.455)^c	95.355^c	204.974	-2.492 (-3.514, -1.469)^c	96.585^c
Not mentioned	34	4837	1782.085	-0.496 (-0.589, -0.403)^c	98.148^c	1231.652	-1.361 (-1.771, -0.951)^c	97.321^c
Self-care: Medication adherence
No significant differences	4	557	57.285	-0.268 (-0.459, -0.077)^b	94.763^c	39.413	-0.650 (-1.254, -0.047)^a	92.388^c
Intervention significantly better	3	541	22.004	-0.265 (-0.677, 0.147)	90.911^c	60.687	-0.783 (-1.810, 0.245)	96.704^c
Not mentioned	40	5834	2414.200	-0.522 (-0.605, -0.44)^c	98.385^c	1538.553	-1.664 (-2.09, -1.237)^c	97.465^c
Self -care: Disease knowledge
No significant differences	7	685	33.269	-0.025 (-0.169, 0.118)	81.965^c	39.012	-0.142 (-0.535, 0.252)	84.620^c
Intervention significantly better	2	197	5.253	-0.590 (-1.401, 0.222)	80.963^a	42.653	-1.220 (-3.543, 1.102)	97.655^c
Not mentioned	38	6050	2399.254	-0.530 (-0.611, -0.449)^c	98.458^c	1584.253	-1.802 (-2.234, -1.37)^c	97.655^c
Self-care: Behavior change
No significant differences	3	379	0.374	-0.100 (-0.134, -0.065)^c	0.000	10.944	-0.318 (-0.769, 0.132)	81.726^c
Intervention significantly better	4	328	94.795	-0.532 (-1.153, 0.090)	96.835^c	70.276	-1.145 (-2.347, 0.057)	95.731^c
Not mentioned	40	6225	2477.596	-0.508 (-0.59, -0.427)^c	98.426^c	1678.368	-1.656 (-2.079, -1.234)^c	97.676^c
Self-care: Glucose monitoring
No significant differences	1	299	0.000	-0.100 (-0.136, -0.064)^c	0.000	0.000	-0.634 (-0.866, -0.401)^c	0.000
Intervention significantly better	3	434	103.754	-0.505 (-0.923, -0.087)^a	98.072^c	31.471	-1.795 (-2.897, -0.693)^c	93.645^c
Not mentioned	43	6199	2441.038	-0.498 (-0.580, -0.416)^c	98.279^c	1807.229	-1.527 (-1.942, -1.113)^c	97.676^c
Self-care: Hospital visits needed
No significant differences	2	339	29.741	-0.440 (-0.744, -0.137)^b	96.638^c	0.510	-2.467 (-2.750, -2.184)^c	0.000
Intervention significantly better	1	246	0.000	0.010 (-0.023, 0.043)	0.000	0.000	0.082 (-0.187, 0.351)	0.000
Not mentioned	44	6347	2341.454	-0.505 (-0.586, -0.424)^c	98.164^c	1692.930	-1.519 (-1.906, -1.133)^c	97.460^c
Self-care: self-efficacy
No significant differences	6	1071	90.786	-0.232 (-0.360, -0.105)^c	94.493^c	71.592	-0.636 (-1.093, -0.178)^b	93.016^c
Intervention significantly better	1	47	0.000	-0.810 (-1.013, -0.607)^c	0.000	0.000	-2.290 (-3.029, -1.552)^c	0.000
Not mentioned	40	5814	2311.342	-0.514 (-0.597, -0.430)^c	98.313^c	1633.909	-1.638 (-2.077, -1.199)^c	97.613^c
Self-care: nutrition
No significant differences	4	380	42.368	-0.642 (-0.845, -0.440)^c	92.919^c	7.474	-2.190 (-2.608, -1.772)^c	59.861
Not mentioned	43	6552	2567.224	-0.466 (-0.546, -0.387)^c	98.364^c	1785.184	-1.457 (-1.853, -1.061)^c	97.647^c
Self-care: Exercise
No significant differences	2	132	7.605	-0.641 (-0.943, -0.338)^c	86.850^b	0.209	-2.427 (-2.877, -1.976)^c	0.000
Not mentioned	45	6800	2636.871	-0.477 (-0.554, -0.400)^c	98.331c	1824.510	-1.485 (-1.866, -1.104)^c	97.588^c
Racial
Hispanic	2	148	2.118	-0.867 (-1.052, -0.682)^c	52.782	0.502	-2.791 (-3.245, -2.337)^c	0.000
Not mentioned	45	6784	2560.239	-0.464 (-0.540, -0.388)^c	98.281^c	1804.224	-1.471 (-1.85, -1.092)^c	97.561^c
Comorbid disease
Overweight/obese	4	318	50.425	-1.270 (-1.971, -0.568)^c	94.051^c	50.979	-2.034 (-3.280, -0.788)^c	94.115^c
Hypertension	1	299	0.000	-0.100 (-0.136, -0.064)^c	0.000	0.000	-0.634 (-0.866, -0.401)^c	0.000
Not mentioned	42	6315	2376.371	-0.439 (-0.516, -0.361)^c	98.275^c	1787.062	-1.499 (-1.910, -1.087)^c	97.706^c

Allied health, diabetes educator, dietician, councillor.

^aP < 0.05.

^bP < 0.01.

^cP < 0.001. CI: Confidence interval.

Citation: De Groot J, Wu D, Flynn D, Robertson D, Grant G, Sun J. Efficacy of telemedicine on glycaemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes: A meta-analysis. World J Diabetes 2021; 12(2): 170-197
URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/1948-9358/full/v12/i2/170.htm
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.4239/wjd.v12.i2.170