Review
Copyright ©2014 Baishideng Publishing Group Co.
World J Hepatol. Jan 27, 2014; 6(1): 17-32
Published online Jan 27, 2014. doi: 10.4254/wjh.v6.i1.17
Table 8 Compilation of causality assessment methods used in suspected herb induced liver injury cases
Herbs/Herbal productsAd hoc (n)WHO (n)CIOMS (n)Naranjo (n)DILIN (n)KL (n)Ref.
Kava20BfArM[58]
Kava30Denham et al[59]
Kava20Teschke et al[60]
Kava36Stickel et al[61]
Kava80Schmidt et al[62]
Greater Celandine23BfArM[63]
Black cohosh31EMA[54]
Herbalife products12Elinav et al[64]
Herbalife products12Schoepfer et al[65]
Kava26Teschke et al[12]
Black cohosh30Mahady et al[42]
Green tea34Sarma et al[43]
Black cohosh4Teschke et al[47]
Black cohosh9Teschke et al[48]
Kava31Teschke[34]
Hydroxycut17Fong et al[66]
Black cohosh22Teschke et al[36]
Greater Celandine22Teschke et al[37]
Herbalife products20Manso et al[67]
Various herbs45Chau et al[57]
Greater Celandine21Teschke et al[32]
Pelargonium sidoides15Teschke et al[38]
Pelargonium sidoides13Teschke et al[39]
Sum (n)63134275641720
Sum (percent)11.00%23.40%48.00%11.20%3.00%3.40%