Burden of bone disease in chronic pancreatitis: A systematic review and meta-analysis

doi:10.3748/wjg.v29.i8.1374

Advanced Search

BPG is committed to discovery and dissemination of knowledge

Home / Archive / Volume 29, Issue 8

This Article

Academic Content and Language Evaluation of This Article

CrossCheck and Google Search of This Article

Academic Rules and Norms of This Article

Supplementary Materials of This Article

Citation of this article

Corresponding Author of This Article

Research Domain of This Article

Article-Type of This Article

Open-Access Policy of This Article

Times Cited Counts in Google of This Article

Number of Hits and Downloads for This Article

Total Article Views (6163)

All Articles published online

The chart showing PDF series, WORD series, HTML series, Figures (1-3) series, Tables (1-4) series.

Item

Count

PDF

179

WORD

HTML

4231

Figures (1-3)

309

Tables (1-4)

295

Sum=5064

Featured Article

The chart showing Browse series, Download series.

Item

Count

Browse

182

Download

403

Sum=585

Publishing Process of This Article

Item

Count

Browse

155

Download

359

Sum=514

Feb 28, 2023 (publication date) through May 14, 2024

Times Cited of This Article

Times Cited (0)

Journal Information of This Article

Publication Name

World Journal of Gastroenterology

ISSN

1007-9327

Publisher of This Article

Baishideng Publishing Group Inc, 7041 Koll Center Parkway, Suite 160, Pleasanton, CA 94566, USA

Systematic Reviews

World J Gastroenterol. Feb 28, 2023; 29(8): 1374-1394
Published online Feb 28, 2023. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v29.i8.1374

Table 1 Description of study design and study population

Ref.	Design	CP patients	CP severity, n (%)	CP etiology, n (%)	Study population	Race	Female patients, n (%)	Age, mean ± SD	BMI, mean ± SD
Morán et al[17], 1997	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological	All severe	Alcohol: 10 (71.4)	CP: 14		CP: 0	CP: 56¹ (-)	CP: 22.64
Morán et al[17], 1997	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological	All severe	Idiopathic 4 (28.6)	Controls: -		Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
Haaber et al[18], 2000	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological		Alcohol: 46 (79)	CP: 58	CP: -	CP: 26 (44.8)	CP: 53 (9)	CP: 23 (5)
Haaber et al[18], 2000	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological		Alcohol: 46 (79)	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
Dujsikova et al[19], 2008	Cross sectional	EUS based criteria	Wiersema classification: Mild: 41 (56.2), moderate: 12 (16.4), severe: 20 (27.4)		CP: 73	CP: -	CP:17 (23.28)	CP: 46.61 (13.23)	CP: -
Dujsikova et al[19], 2008	Cross sectional	EUS based criteria			Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
Tignor et al[20], 2010	Retrospective cohort	ICD-9 code 577.1			CP: 3192	CP: White: 2091 (65.5), black: 419 (13.1), hispanic: 222 (6.9), others: 532 (16.7)	CP: 1636 (51.25)	CP: -	CP: -
Tignor et al[20], 2010	Retrospective cohort	ICD-9 code 577.1			Controls: 1436699	Control: White: 860190 (59.9), black: 115199 (8.0), hispanic: 102000, other: 451110	Controls: 907328 (63.15)	Controls: -	Controls: -
Sudeep et al[22], 2011	Cross sectional	Not defined		Tropical pancreatitis: 20 (65)	CP: 31	CP: -	CP: 0	CP: 35.8 (9)	CP: 18.46 (2.86)
Sudeep et al[22], 2011	Cross sectional	Not defined		Idiopathic: 11 (35)	Controls: 35	Controls: -	Controls: 0	Controls: 38.6 (5.2)	Controls: 22.6 (3.1)
Joshi et al[21], 2011	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological		All patients with tropical calcific pancreatitis	CP: 72	CP: -	CP: 34 (47.2)	CP: 31.1 (10.3)	CP: 19 (3.1)
Joshi et al[21], 2011	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological		All patients with tropical calcific pancreatitis	Controls: 100	Controls: -	Controls: 50 (50)	Controls: 32.6 (9.6)	Controls: 23.6 (3.2)
Duggan et al[23], 2012	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological	Cambridge classification: Mild (37.1), severe (27.4)	Alcohol: 24 (38.7)	CP: 62	CP: -	CP: 17 (27.41)	CP: 47.9 (12.5)	CP: 25.6 (5)
Duggan et al[23], 2012	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological	Cambridge classification: Mild (37.1), severe (27.4)	Idiopathic: 38 (61.3)	Controls: 66	Controls: -	Controls: 18 (27.27)	Controls: 47.74 (11)	Controls: 28.0 (4.1)
Sikkens et al[25], 2013	Prospective cohort	Clinicoradiological		Alcohol: 20 (50)	CP: 40	CP: -	CP: 17 (42.5)	CP: 52 (11)	CP: 24 (5)
				Idiopathic: 17 (43)	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
				Other: 3 (7)
Prabhakaran et al[28], 2014	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological.	Cambridge classification: Mild (13.1), moderate (5.05), marked: (81.8)	Alcohol: 72 (70)	CP: 103	CP: -	CP: 0	CP: 38.6 (20.64)	CP: 19.7
Prabhakaran et al[28], 2014	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological.		Idiopathic: 31 (29.1)	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: 0	Controls: 36.7 (20.70)	Controls: -
Bang et al[26], 2014	Prospective cohort	ICD-10: K86.0 (alcohol induced CP), K86.1 (other CP)			CP: 11972	CP: -	CP: 4011 (33.5)	CP: 54.5 (14)	CP: -
Bang et al[26], 2014	Prospective cohort	ICD-10: K86.0 (alcohol induced CP), K86.1 (other CP)			Controls: 119720	Controls: -	Controls: 40106 (33.49)	Controls: 54.5 (14)	Controls: -
Duggan et al[27], 2015	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological	Cambridge classification (unspecified number in each category)	Alcohol: 18 (62.1)	CP: 29	CP: -	CP: 12 (41.37)	CP: 44.3 (12.3)	CP: 25.2 (5.1)
				Idiopathic: 8 (27.6)	Controls: 29	Controls: -	Controls: 12 (41.37)	Controls: 45.8 (9.8)	Controls: 27.3 (3.7)
				Other: 3 (10.3)
Munigala et al[24], 2016	Cross sectional	ICD-9 code 577.1			CP: 3257	CP: White 2120 (65), black 1012 (31), others 125 (4)	CP: 178 (5.46)	CP: 54.2 (11.1)	CP: -
Munigala et al[24], 2016	Cross sectional	ICD-9 code 577.1			Controls: 450655	Controls: White: 325132 (72), black: 76031 (17), others: 49492 (11)	Controls: 53108 (11.78)	Controls: 53.6 (13.9)	Controls: -
Kumar et al[29], 2017	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological			CP: 102	CP: -	CP: 17 (16.7)	CP: 40.8 (12.6)	CP: 22.5 (3.2)
Kumar et al[29], 2017	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological			Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
Stigliano et al[32], 2018	Cross sectional	M-ANNHEIM criteria	M-ANNHEIM scoring system: Minor: 74 (35), Increased: 99 (47), advanced: 32 (15), marked: 6 (3)	Alcoholic: 91 (43)	CP: 211	CP: -	CP: 69 (32.7)	CP: 60 (-)	CP: 24 (4)
				Idiopathic: 40 (19)	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
				Hereditary: 8 (4)
				Obstructive: 12 (5.7)
Kuhlmann et al[30], 2018	Cross sectional	Score ≥ 4 points based on Lüneburg criteria			CP: 67	CP: -	CP: 27 (40.29)	CP: 60¹ (-)	CP: 22.7 (15-37.9)
Kuhlmann et al[30], 2018	Cross sectional	Score ≥ 4 points based on Lüneburg criteria			Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
Min et al[31], 2018	Prospective cohort	EUS criteria and/or	EUS criteria (unspecified number in each category)	Toxic/metabolic: 54 (59.3)	CP: 91	CP: -	CP: 34 (37.36)	CP: 48.6 (10.4)	CP: 26.1 (7.8)
		secretin stimulation testing		Idiopathic: 17 (18.6)	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
				Hereditary: 13 (14.3)
				Autoimmune: 5 (5.5)
Gupta et al[33], 2019	Prospective cohort	Clinicoradiological and EUS			CP: 38	CP: White 35 (92), black 3 (8)	CP: 19 (50)	CP: 44 (10.7)	CP: 26.7 (5.9)
Gupta et al[33], 2019	Prospective cohort	Clinicoradiological and EUS			Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
Kanakis et al[7], 2020	Retrospective cohort	Clinicoradiological			CP: 239	CP: White 43 (88), minorities: 6 (12)	CP: 37 (15.48)	CP: 56¹ (-)	CP: 23 (8)
Kanakis et al[7], 2020	Retrospective cohort	Clinicoradiological			Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
Hart et al[34], 2021	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological	Cambridge classification (unspecified number in each category)	-	CP: 282	CP: White race (87.2), minorities (12.8)	CP: 145 (51.41)	CP: 56¹ (-)	CP: -
Hart et al[34], 2021	Cross sectional	Clinicoradiological		-	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
Vujasinovic et al[8], 2021	Retrospective cohort	2002 Asia-Pacifc consensus report		Alcohol and smoking: 40 (33.9)	CP: 118	CP: -	CP: 49 (41.52)	CP: 53.1 (16.3)	CP: 23.9 (4.4)
				Smoking only: 12 (11)	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -
				Alcohol only: 7 (5.9)
				Hereditary: 21 (11.8)
				Immunological: 23 (14.4)
				Efferent duct factors: 11 (9.3)
Tang et al[35], 2021	Cross sectional	ICD-9 based codes	M-ANNHEIM clinical stage 0: 6 (5.8), I: 59 (56.7), II: 26 (25.0), III: 8 (7.7), IV: 5 (4.8)		CP: 104	CP: -	CP: 31 (29.8)	CP: 46.08 (14.43)	CP: 21.43 (2.85)
Tang et al[35], 2021	Cross sectional	ICD-9 based codes			Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -	Controls: -

¹Number of subjects who consented to Dual-energy X-ray Absorptiometry scan if detailed in the studies

CP: Chronic pancreatitis; BMI: Body mass index; EUS: Endoscopic ultrasound; ICD: International Classification of Diseases.

Citation: Chhoda A, Hernandez-Woodbine MJ, Addo NAA, Nasir SA, Grimshaw A, Gunderson C, Ahmed A, Freedman SD, Sheth SG. Burden of bone disease in chronic pancreatitis: A systematic review and meta-analysis. World J Gastroenterol 2023; 29(8): 1374-1394
URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/1007-9327/full/v29/i8/1374.htm
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.3748/wjg.v29.i8.1374