Reporting of dental status from full-arch radiographs: Descriptive analysis and methodological aspects

doi:10.12998/wjcc.v2.i10.552

Advanced Search

BPG is committed to discovery and dissemination of knowledge

Home / Archive / Volume 2, Issue 10

This Article

Academic Content and Language Evaluation of This Article

Citation of this article

Corresponding Author of This Article

Research Domain of This Article

Article-Type of This Article

Open-Access Policy of This Article

Times Cited Counts in Google of This Article

Number of Hits and Downloads for This Article

Total Article Views (8794)

All Articles published online

The chart showing PDF series, WORD series, HTML series, Figures (1-3) series, Tables (1-2) series.

Item

Count

PDF

377

WORD

359

HTML

3946

Figures (1-3)

187

Tables (1-2)

234

Sum=5103

Featured Article

The chart showing Browse series, Download series.

Item

Count

Browse

593

Download

897

Sum=1490

Publishing Process of This Article

Item

Count

Browse

1059

Download

1142

Sum=2201

Oct 16, 2014 (publication date) through May 17, 2024

Times Cited of This Article

Times Cited (4)

Journal Information of This Article

Publication Name

World Journal of Clinical Cases

ISSN

2307-8960

Publisher of This Article

Baishideng Publishing Group Inc, 7041 Koll Center Parkway, Suite 160, Pleasanton, CA 94566, USA

Systematic Reviews

World J Clin Cases. Oct 16, 2014; 2(10): 552-564
Published online Oct 16, 2014. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v2.i10.552

Table 2 Evaluated articles and encountered mode of report: All full-text reviewed articles are sorted by the year of publication

Ref.	Number of X- rays evaluated	Ia: Number of teeth	IIa: Fillings	IIb: Caries	IIc: Restorations	IIIa: RCF	IIIb: apF	IV: ABL
Helenius-Hietala et al[17] 2011^b	212	N[r-teeth](mean,SD)[pat]	ND	N[pat] (mean)/G[spec]	ND	ND	NR	mm(mean,SD)/pat; meanABL[pat]/G[spec]; N[teeth+G[ABL]] (mean,SD)/G[spec]
Yoshihara et al[40] 2011^a	177	N[r-teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec,gender]	ND	ND	ND	ND	ND	ND
Andersen et al[28] 2011^b	52	N[r-teeth](mean,SD, median,Q)[pat]/G(age)	ND	ND	ND	Combined: N[teeth](mean,SD,median,Q)[pat]/G[age]; N[teeth](F,%)[toothtype]/G[age]		ND
Seppänen et al[18] 2011^b	84	N[r-teeth](median,rg) [pat]	ND	N[pat](F,%)[all pat], G[spec]	ND	ND	ND	N[pat](F)[ND]/G[spec]
Willershausen et al[9] 2011^d	2374?	N[r-teeth](mean?)/ G[age,spec], N[m-teeth](mean)/G[age]	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec], N[pat](%)/G[age]	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec], N[pat](%)/G[age]	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec]; N[pat](%)/G[age]	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec], N[pat](%)/G[age]	ND	ND
Kirkevang et al[22] 2009^b	470	N[r-teeth](median,rg)[pat]/G[age]	N[teeth+1,2,3 surfaces](median,range)[pat]/G[age,toothtype]	N[teeth](median,rg)[pat]/G[age,tooth-type]	ND	ND	ND	ND
Saeves et al[10] 2009^d	93	N[m-teeth](mean)[pat]/G[age,spec]	N[teeth](mean)[pat]/G[age,spec]	ND	“Some”	N[teeth](%)[all teeth]; N[pat](F)[spec]	ND	ND
Tarkkila et al[13] 2008^b	161	N[r-teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec]	Combined with clinical examination: N[DMFT,DT,FT](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec]		ND	NR	NR	ND
Buhlin et al[49] 2007^b	51	N[r-teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec,all]	N[DMFS](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec,all]; N[DMFT](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec,all]		ND	ND	N[lesions](F,%)[pat]/G[spec]	N[pat](F,%)/G[grade]
Nalçaci et al[26] 2007^d	190	N[r-,m-teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,tooth-type]	N[teeth](median,SD)[pat]/G[gender,all]	N[teeth](median,SD) [pat]/G[gender,all]	N[FPD](F,%)/G[gender,jaw] N[teeth](SD,median)[pat]	N[teeth](median,SD) [pat]/G[gender,all]	N[teeth](median,SD)[pat]/G[gender,all]	N[pat](median, SD)[ND ABL]/G[gender]
Huumonen et al[3] 2007^b	95	N[m-teeth](F)/G[spec]	ND	N[teeth](F)/G[spec]; N[findings?](F)/G[spec]	ND	N[teeth](F)/G[spec]	N[teeth](F)/G[spec];	N[pat](F)/G[spec]
Jansson et al[36] 2006^c	191?	N[r-teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/ G[spec]	ND	ND	ND	ND	ND	N[pat](F)/G[spec]
Tabrizi et al[11] 2006^c	20	N[r-teeth] (F,mean,SD)[pat]	N[DMFS,DMFT](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec]		Included to DMFT?	ND	ND	ABL(mean)[pat]
Skudutyte-Rysstad et al[30] 2006^d	146	ND	ND	ND	ND	N[pat+tooth](F,%)[all]; N[pat]/N[teeth](F); N[teeth](F,%)/G[spec]	N[pat+tooth](F,%)[all]; N[teeth](F)[grade]; N[pat]/N[teeth](F); N[teeth](F,%)[all]/G[spec]	ND
Peltola et al[31] 2006^a	307	NR via DMFT	NR via DMFT N[pat](F)[DMFT = 0]/G[spec]	N[lesions](mean,SD) [pat]/G[spec]	ND	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec]	N[lesions](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec]	NR
Ma et al[2] 2005^a	1232	N[pat+m-teeth](%)/G[tooth-type]; N[m-teeth](%)[tooth-type]	ND	ND	ND	ND	ND	ND
Olze et al[14] 2005^d	275	NR	NR	NR	ND	ND	ND	ND
Cabrera et al[4] 2005c	1417	N[pat](F)/G[m-teeth,spec]	ND	ND	ND	ND	ND	ND
Rosenquist et al[5] 2005^b	452	N[pat](F)[G[m-teeth]/G[spec]	N[pat](F)[G[m-teeth]/G(spec)			ND	N[pat](F)[teeth]/G[spec]	N[pat](F)[grade]/G(spec)
Montebugnoli et al[44] 2004^c	113	NR via pantomography index	ND	NR via Pantomography index	ND	ND	NR	NR
Abou-Raya et al[46] 2002^a	50	N[pat+m-teeth](%)/G[spec]	ND	NR via Pantomography index	ND	ND	NR via pantomography index	NR via pantomography index
Enberg et al[21] 2001^a	137?	N[r-teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,age,spec]	ND	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,age,spec]	ND	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,age,spec]	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,age,spec]	N[teeth](F,%)[pat]/G[gender,age-group,spec]
Närhi et al[6] 2000^a	396	N[pat+r-teeth]; N[r-teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,jaw,spec]	ND	N[teeth]; N[teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,spec]	ND	absN[teeth], N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,spec]	N[teeth], N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[gender,jaw,spec]	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat,grade]/G[gender, spec]
Aartman et al[43] 1999^a	211	N[r-teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/ G[spec]	ND	N[teeth](mean,SD) [pat]/G[spec]	ND	N[teeth](mean,SD)[pat]/G[spec]	ND	ND
Taylor et al[38] 1998^b	362	N[r-teeth?](median)/G[spec]	ND	ND	ND	ND	ND	N[pat](F,%)[grades]/G[spec, age-group];
Grau et al[48] 1997^c	126	NR via pantomography index	ND	NR via pantomography index	ND	NR via pantomography index	NR via pantomography index	NR via pantomography index
Peltola et al[19] 1993^c	990?	N[pat](%)[DMFT = 0]	N[DMF](mean,SD)[pat]/G[age]	N[teeth](mean,SD,rg)[pat]	ND	N[pat](%)	N[pat](%)	N[pat+ND G[ABL]](F,%)
Hakeberg et al[33] 1993^c	180	N[m-teeth] (mean,SD,rg)[pat]/G[spec,gender,age]	N[surfaces](mean,SD,rg)[pat]/G[spec, gender,age]	N[surfaces](mean,SD,rg) [pat]/G[spec,gender,age]	ND	N[m-teeth] (mean,SD,rg)[pat]/G[spec,gender,age]	N[lesions](mean,SD,rg)[pat]/G[spec,gender,age]	N[lesions](mean)[pat]/G[grade,spec]
Corbet et al[24] 1992^b	165	N[m-teeth] (mean,SD)[pat]/G[age]; N[m-teeth](%)[FDI]	ND	ND	N[pontics,cantilever,crowns](%)[FDI]; N[FPD](%)[units]; N[units,retainers](mean,SD)[all FPD]	ND	ND	ND
Lindqvist et al[15] 1989^d	50	N[r-teeth](mean,rg)[pat]	N[pat+”seriously decayed teeth”](F,%)			N[teeth,pat](F); N[“Inadequate” RCF](F,%)	N[pat](F)/G[lesions]	N[pat](F,%)/ G[“periodontits”]; N[pat?](F)[spec]
Stermer Beyer-Olsen et al[37] 1989^c	141	ND	ND	ND	ND	N[teeth](F), N[pat](F,%)	N[teeth,RCF-teeth](F), N[pat](F,%)	N[pat](F,%)
Grover et al[7] 1982^a	5000	N[pat](F,%)/G[m-teeth]	Combined for all carious as N[findings,pat](F,%)			ND	N[findings,pat](F,%)	N[pat+G[periodontits]](F,%)
Langland et al[16] 1980^b	2921	ND	ND	N[pat+lesion?](F,%)	N[pat+FPD](F,%)	N[pat+tooth](F,%)	N[pat+lesion?](F,%)	N[pat+G[periodontits]](F,%)
Meister et al[25] 1977^b	5783	ND	ND	ND	N[pat+FPD](F,%)	ND	N[findings](F,%)	N[pat+G[periodontits]](%)
Pelton et al[20] 1973^d	200	ND	ND	N[findings](F)/G[jaw,spec]	ND	ND	ND	ND
Christen et al[27] 1967^b	1338	ND	ND	ND	“Many ill fitting crowns”	ND	N[pat+tooth](F)	N[pat+”gross periodontits”](F,%)
Lilly et al[8] 1967^d	1285	N[pat](F,%)/G[r-teeth]	ND	ND	ND	N[teeth](F)/G[tooth-type]; N[pat,canals](F)	N[teeth](F)G[spec]	ND

The date is followed by a discretionary index for the 5 year Impact Factor of the journal in 2010 (a < 1.5; b < 3; c > 3; d: None). Please see caption: Operationalization of findings in “Materials and Methods” section to decipher content in columns Ia-IV. Column IIb “Implants” is not shown for a comprehensive view and due to the lack of noteworthy reports. RCF: Root-canal-fillings; apF: Apical findings; ABL: Alveolar bone loss; ND: Not defined; NR: Not reported.

Citation: Huettig F, Axmann D. Reporting of dental status from full-arch radiographs: Descriptive analysis and methodological aspects. World J Clin Cases 2014; 2(10): 552-564
URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/2307-8960/full/v2/i10/552.htm
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.12998/wjcc.v2.i10.552