Retrospective Cohort Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2016.
World J Transplant. Jun 24, 2016; 6(2): 356-369
Published online Jun 24, 2016. doi: 10.5500/wjt.v6.i2.356
Table 1 Demographic and clinical characteristics of the study population
WHO BMI classification
P value
Obese recipients
VariableTotal number of patients (n = 48281) (100%)Underweight (n = 914) (1.9%)Normal weight (n = 14529) (30.0%)Overweight (n = 16724) (34.6%)Class I (n = 9944) (20.5%)Class II (n = 4438) (9.2%)Class III (n = 1732) (3.5%)
Age in years, median (25th, 75th)53 (46, 59)50 (40, 57.2)52 (44, 58)53 (46, 58)53 (46, 58)53 (46, 58)52 (47, 58)0.000
Gender, n (%)
Male30250 (62.7)407 (44.5)8573 (59.0)11336 (67.8)6489 (65.3)2609 (58.8)836 (48.3)0.000
Female18.031 (37.3)507 (55.5)5956 (41.0)5388 (32.2)3455 (34.7)1829 (41.2)896 (51.7)
Recipient living status, n (%)
Alive27552 (57.1)496 (54.3)8040 (55.4)9534 (57.1)5825 (58.6)2642 (59.6)1015 (58.6)0.000
Dead16689 (34.6)346 (37.9)5123 (35.3)5804 (34.7)3344 (33.7)1471 (33.2)601 (34.7)
Lost at follow-up3987 (8.3)72 (7.9)1348 (9.3)1370 (8.2)765 (7.7)317 (7.2)115 (6.6)
Race, n (%)
Non-hispanic white36809 (76.2)664 (72.6)10850 (74.7)12820 (76.7)7687 (77.3)3475 (78.3)1313 (75.8)0.000
Non-hispanic black3962 (8.2)92 (10.1)1237 (8.5)1277 (7.6)815 (8.2)371 (8.4)170 (9.8)
Hispanic5535 (11.5)73 (8.0)1534 (10.6)2020 (12.1)1191 (12.0)500 (11.3)217 (12.5)
Asian1446 (3.0)78 (8.5)782 (5.4)415 (2.5)131 (1.3)30 (0.7)10 (0.6)
Other529 (1.1)7 (0.7)126 (0.8)192 (1.1)120 (1.2)62 (1.3)22 (1.2)
Recipient BMI, median (25th, 75th)27.05 (23.8, 31.1)17.63 (17.0, 18.1)22.73 (21.2, 23.9)27.26 (26.0, 28.5)32.01 (30.3, 33.3)36.85 (35.8, 38.1)42.24 (41.1, 44.2)0.000
Primary indication for liver transplantation, n (%)
HCV13838 (28.7)176 (19.3)3538 (24.4)5248 (31.4)3101 (31.2)1302 (29.3)473 (27.3)0.000
Alcohol8111 (16.8)163 (17.8)2543 (17.5)2909 (17.4)1686 (17.0)622 (14.0)188 (10.9)
Idiopathic5073 (10.5)77 (8.4)1179 (8.1)1656 (9.9)1270 (12.8)628 (14.2)263 (15.2)
Alcohol + HCV3601 (7.5)44 (4.8)1033 (7.1)1370 (8.2)762 (7.7)310 (7.0)82 (4.7)
PSC2799 (5.8)101 (11.1)1396 (9.6)903 (5.4)282 (2.8)92 (2.1)25 (1.4)
Congenital/metabolic disease2567 (5.3)80 (8.8)870 (6.0)826 (4.9)455 (4.6)215 (4.8)121 (7.0)
PBC2485 (5.1)92 (10.1)1122 (7.7)765 (4.6)342 (3.4)116 (2.6)48 (2.8)
NASH2247 (4.7)13 (1.4)226 (1.6)585 (3.5)660 (6.6)522 (11.8)241 (13.9)
HBV1896 (3.9)33 (3.6)798 (5.5)646 (3.9)291 (2.9)92 (2.1)36 (2.1)
Other5664 (11.7)135 (14.7)1824 (12.5)1816 (10.8)1095 (11.0)539 (12.1)291 (14.7)
MELD score, median (25th, 75th)21 (16, 28)22 (16, 28)21 (16, 29)20 (15, 28)21 (16, 28)21 (15, 29)22 (16, 31)0.000
Cold ischemia time, hours, median (25th, 75th)7.0 (5.4, 9.2)7.1 (5.3, 9.0)7.0 (5.3, 9.1)7.0 (5.3, 9.1)7.1 (5.4, 9.2)7.2 (5.5, 9.3)7.3 (5.7, 9.4)0.288
Warm ischemia time, minutes, median (25th, 75th)44 (34, 55)44 (35, 55)43 (34, 55)44 (35, 55)44 (35, 56)45 (35, 57)41 (31, 50)0.000
Waiting time, days (including days on hold), median (25th, 75th)120 (27, 335)91 (21, 286)106 (24, 308)124 (28, 336)131 (30, 358)134 (31, 355.5)86 (12, 314)0.000
Hospital stay after liver transplant, days, median (25th, 75th)11 (8, 19)13 (7, 23)11 (8, 19)11 (8, 18)11 (8, 18)12 (8, 19)13 (9, 22)0.000
Preoperative comorbidities, n (%)
Diabetes type I536 (1.1)9 (1.7)108 (0.8)181 (1.1)155 (1.6)60 (1.4)23 (1.3)0.000
Diabetes type II8541 (18.0)81 (9.1)1827 (12.9)2896 (17.6)2179 (22.2)1105 (25.2)453 (26.6)
Dialysis3538 (7.3)80 (8.8)1059 (7.3)1160 (6.9)693 (7.0)366 (8.2)180 (5.1)0.000
Hypertension4124 (8.5)54 (5.9)989 (6.8)1424 (8.5)990 (10.0)481 (10.8)186 (10.7)0.000
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease447 (0.9)13 (1.4)133 (0.9)153 (0.9)86 (0.9)45 (1.0)17 (1.0)0.000
Table 2 Donor demographic and clinical characteristics
WHO recipients’ BMI
P value
Obese recipients
Donor variableTotal number of donors (n = 48281) (100%)Underweight (n = 914) (1.9%)Normal weight (n = 14529) (30.0%)Overweight (n = 16724) (34.6%)Class I (n = 9944) (20.5%)Class II (n = 4438) (9.2%)Class III (n = 1732) (3.5%)
Age in years, median (25th, 75th)40 (24, 53)37 (20, 52)39 (22, 53)40 (24, 53)41 (24, 53)41 (25, 53)41 (25, 54)0.000
BMI, median (25th, 75th)25.2 (22.3, 29.0)23.6 (20.7, 27.1)24.6 (21.7, 28.2)25.3 (22.3, 29.0)25.7 (22.7, 29.8)25.9 (23.0, 29.9)25.8 (22.8, 30.0)0.000
Gender, n (%)
Male29034 (60.1)486 (53.2)8171 (56.2)10219 (61.1)6280 (63.2)2801 (63.1)1077 (62.2)0.000
Female19247 (39.8)428 (46.8)6358 (43.8)6505 (38.9)3664 (36.8)1637 (36.9)655 (37.8)
Primary cause of death, n (%)
Anoxia6895 (14.3)163 (17.8)2004 (13.8)2337 (33.9)1465 (14.7)675 (15.2)251 (14.5)0.040
Cerebrovascular19840 (41.1)355 (38.8)5980 (41.2)6869 (41.1)4079 (41.0)1826 (41.1)731 (42.3)
Head trauma20273 (42.0)372 (40.7)6161 (42.4)7098 (42.5)4110 (41.4)1831 (41.3)701 (40,5)
Central nervous system tumor357 (0.7)8 (0.9)107 (0.7)116 (0.7)92 (0.9)24 (0.5)10 (0.6)
Other892 (1.8)16 (1.8)272 (1.9)292 (1.7)193 (1.9)82 (1.8)37 (2.1)
Race, n (%)
Non-hispanic white34907 (72.3)639 (69.9)10488 (72.2)12078 (72.2)7196 (72.4)3264 (73.5)1242 (71.7)0.000
Non-hispanic black6758 (14.0)127 (13.9)1938 (13.3)2334 (14.0)1458 (14.7)640 (14.4)261 (15.1)
Hispanic5118 (10.6)109 (11.9)1623 (11.2)1790 (10.7)994 (10.0)427 (9.6)175 (10.1)
Asian885 (1.8)28 (3.1)299 (2,1)309 (1.8)162 (1,6)55 (1.2)32 (1.8)
Other673 (1.3)11 (1.2)241 (1.6)213 (1.2)134 (1.3)52 (1.1)22 (1.2)
Table 3 Mean and median overall survival by recipients' body mass index class
Means and medians for survival time (yr)
Recipient’s BMIMean1
Median
EstimateStd. error95%CI
EstimateStd. error95%CI
Lower boundUpper boundLower boundUpper bound
Underweight10.80.310.211.411.50.610.412.7
Normal11.60.111.411.713.10.212.613.6
Overweight11.50.111.411.712.80.212.513.2
Obese-class I11.30.111.211.512.40.211.912.8
Obese-class II11.10.110.811.412.20.311.612.9
Obese-class III10.70.210.211.111.30.510.312.3
Overall11.50.011.411.512.70.112.512.9
Table 4 Univariate and multivariate Cox analysis of predictors of overall survival
Univariate analysis
Multivariate analysis
VariableHazard rate (95%CI)P valueHazard rate (95%CI)P value
Recipient BMI0.0030.000
Normal weight (reference)11
Underweight1.125 (1.009-1.255)0.0341.265 (1.096-1.461)0.001
Overweight1.005 (0.968-1.043)0.8070.908 (0.864-0.954)0.000
Obese class I1.024 (0.980-1.070)0.2840.947 (0.893-1.004)0.067
Obese class II1.042 (0.983-1.104)0.1690.971 (0.898-1.051)0.470
Obese class III1.163 (1.069-1.266)0.0001.157 (1.031-1.299)0.013
Donor BMI0.0010.000
Normal weight (reference)11
Underweight0.962 (0.897-1.033)0.2881.017 (0.928-1.114)0.716
Overweight1.060 (1.023-1.098)0.0011.009 (0.962-1.057)0.717
Obese class I1.049 (0.998-1.102)0.0590.986 (0.921-1.057)0.695
Obese class II1.129 (1.045-1.220)0.0021.020 (0.912-1.140)0.729
Obese class III0.988 (0.999-1.112)0.9880.889 (0.765-1.034)0.128
Recipient age0.0000.000
18-45 (reference)11
46-551.264 (1.212-1.319)0.0001.207 (1.143-1.276)0.000
56-651.536 (1.471-1.603)0.0001.490 (1.405-1.580)0.000
66-752.005 (1.887-2.130)0.0002.069 (1.904-2.247)0.000
≥ 763.224 (2.099-4.951)0.0002.476 (1.462-4.194)0.001
Donor age0.0000.000
0-17 (reference)11
18-451.107 (1.050-1.166)0.0001.066 (0.996-1.141)0.066
46-551.297 (1.223-1.376)0.0001.266 (1.170-1.370)0.000
56-651.502 (1.411-1.598)0.0001.413 (1.300-1.537)0.000
66-751.706 (1.583-1.840)0.0001.609 (1.453-1.782)0.000
≥ 761.661 (1.448-1.883)0.0001.609 (1.340-1.932)0.000
Recipient sex (male)1.063 (1.030-1.097)0.0001.025 (0.979-1.073)0.297
Donor sex (male)0.951 (0.922-0.980)0.0010.967 (0.926-1.008)0.967
Cold ischemia time (h)1.010 (1.006-1.013)0.0001.008 (1.003-1.013)0.001
Warm ischemia time (min)1.002 (1.001-1.003)0.0001.002 (1.001-1.003)0.000
Year of transplantation0.996 (0.992-0.999)0.0170.987 (0.980-0.993)0.000
Dialysis1.507 (1.422-1.598)0.0001.492 (1.367-1.629)0.000
Diabetes1.406 (1.355-1.460)0.0001.314 (1.248-1.383)0.000
COPD1.384 (1.218-1.573)0.0001.250 (1.075-1.454)0.004
Hypertension1.207 (1.150-1.267)0.0001.057 (0.998-1.120)0.059
Primary indication0.0000.000
HCV1.356 (1.313-1.400)0.0001.429 (1.335-1.530)0.000
Alcohol + HCV1.214 (1.152-1.281)0.0001.477 (1.351-1.616)0.000
HCV + other viral hepatitis1.093 (0.932-1.283)0.2741.342 (1.098-1.638)0.004
Other1.020 (0.951-1.094)0.5831.111 (0.993-1.244)0.067
Alcohol1.060 (1.018-1.103)0.0051.188 (1.102-1.282)0.000
HBV0.669 (0.613-0.729)0.0000.782 (0.691-0.883)0.000
PSC0.597 (0.554-0.644)0.0000.709 (0.634-0.792)0.000
PBC0.670 (0.623-0.721)0.0000.715 (0.641-0.797)0.000
NASH0.906 (0.821-1.001)0.0510.953 (0.783-1.160)0.630
Autoimmune0.807 (0.742-0.878)0.0000.916 (0.810-1.036)0.164
Acute liver failure0.801 (0.689-0.931)0.0041.049 (0.822-1.339)0.701
Congenital or metabolic disease0.758 (0.703-0.817)0.0000.825 (0.736-0.926)0.001
Table 5 Mean and median graft survival by recipients' body mass index class
Means and medians for graft survival time (yr)
Recipient’s BMIMean1
Median
EstimateStd. error95%CI
EstimateStd. error95%CI
Lower boundUpper boundLower boundUpper bound
Underweight10.40.39.81111.10.410.112.1
Normal11.10.0710.911.3120.211.612.5
Overweight11.10.071111.3120.111.612.4
Obese-class I110.0910.811.211.70.211.312.1
Obese-class II10.80.1410.511.111.70.311.112.3
Obese-class III10.30.249.810.810.70.59.711.7
Overall110.041111.111.80.111.612
Table 6 Summary of the primary causes of graft loss stratified by recipients' body mass index n (%)
WHO recipients’ BMI class
P value
Obese recipients
All recipients (n = 16715)Underweight (n = 346)Normal weight (n = 5129)Overweight (n = 5813)Class I (n = 3351)Class II (n = 1473)Class III (n = 603)
Primary cause of graft failure(I)(II)(III)(IV)(V)(VI)
Primary graft non-function603 (3.6)11 (3.2)178 (3.5)221 (3.8)128 (3.8)48 (3.3)17 (2.8)≥ 0.05
Biliary complications89 (0.5)2 (0.6)18 (0.4)34 (0.6)23 (0.7)6 (0.4)6 (1.0)≥ 0.05
Vascular thrombosis119 (0.7)2 (0.6)45 (0.9)39 (0.7)16 (0.5)11 (0.7)6 (1.0)≥ 0.05
Recurrent disease829 (4.9)14 (4.0)240 (4.6)306 (5.2)172 (5.1)75 (5.0)22 (3.6)≥ 0.05
Acute rejection158 (0.9)2 (0.6)57 (1.1)55 (0.9)27 (0.8)10 (0.7)7 (1.2)≥ 0.05
Chronic rejection270 (1.6)7 (2.0)104 (2.0)82 (1.4)50 (1.5)17 (1.1)10 (1.6)≥ 0.05
Infection589 (3.5)11 (3.2)163 (3.2)216 (3.7)119 (3.6)53 (3.6)27 (4.5)≥ 0.05
Recipient death10172 (60.9)224 (64.7)3107 (60.6)3480 (59.9)2037 (60.8)945 (64.2)379 (62.9)≥ 0.05
Unknown3886 (23.2)73 (21.1)1217 (23.7)1380 (23.7)779 (23.2)308 (20.9)129 (21.4)≥ 0.05
Table 7 Summary of the primary causes mortality during the index admission for liver transplantation stratified by recipients body mass index n (%)
WHO recipients' MBI class
Group comparisonsP value
Obese recipients
Primary cause of perioperative mortalityAll recipients (n = 48281)Underweight (n = 914)Normal weight (n = 14529)Overweight (n = 16724)Class I (n = 9944)Class II (n = 4438)Class III (n = 1732)
(I)(II)(III)(IV)(V)(VI)
Infections or multiorgan failure718 (1.4)22 (2.4)202 (1.3)229 (1.3)155 (1.5)67 (1.5)43 (2.4)≥ 0.05
Cerebrovascular complication155 (0.3)4 (0.4)47 (0.3)60 (0.3)25 (0.2)14 (0.3)5 (0.2)≥ 0.05
Hemmorrhagic128 (0.2)3 (0.3)38 (0.2)41 (0.2)32 (0.3)11 (0.2)3 (0.1)≥ 0.05
Single organ failure102 (0.2)1 (0.1)25 (0.1)35 (0.2)21 (0.2)13 (0.2)7 (0.4)≥ 0.05
Intraoperative complications75 (0.1)2 (0.2)30 (0.2)21 (0.1)12 (0.1)4 (0.09)6 (0.3)≥ 0.05
Cardiovascular or embolic event53 (0.1)1 (0.1)8 (0.05)16 (0.09)13 (0.13)12 (0.2)3 (0.17)(II) vs (V) ≤ 0.05
Vascular thrombosis22 (0.04)05 (0.03)9 (0.05)2 (0.02)4 (0.09)2 (0.1)≥ 0.05
Biliary complication2 (0.004)001 (0.005)1 (0.01)00≥ 0.05
Primary graft non-function62 (0.12)1 (0.1)11 (0.07)27 (0.16)12 (0.12)5 (0.1)6 (0.3)≥ 0.05
Rejection9 (0.01)03 (0.02)3 (0.01)2 (0.02)1 (0.02)0≥ 0.05
Other causes751 (1.5)12 (1.3)203 (1.3)235 (1.4)177 (1.7)91 (2.0)33 (1.9)≥ 0.05
Unknown172 (0.3)1 (0.1)57 (0.3)61 (0.3)32 (0.3)13 (0.2)8 (0.4)≥ 0.05
Total2249 (4.6)47 (5.1)629 (4.3)738 (4.4)484 (4.8)235 (5.2)116 (6.6)
Table 8 Multivariate logistic analysis of in hospital, 90-d and 1-year mortality stratified by recipients’ body mass index at the time of liver transplantation
Multivariate analysis: In hospital mortality
Multivariate analysis: 90-d mortality
Multivariate analysis: 1-yr mortality
VariableOdds ratio (95%CI)P valueOdds ratio (95%CI)P valueOdds ratio (95%CI)P value
Recipient BMI
Normal weight111
Underweight1.359 (0.865-2.135)0.1841.737 (1.185-2.548)0.0051.505 (1.105-2.048)0.009
Overweight0.942 (0.798-1.112)0.4810.995 (0.856-1.157)0.9500.886 (0.792-0.992)0.036
Obese class I1.171 (0.974-1.408)0.0941.185 (1.000-1.430)0.0500.900 (0.792-1.028)0.120
Obese class II1.135 (0.889-1.450)0.3091.197 (0.959-1.495)0.1121.004 (0.846-1.193)0.960
Obese class III1.749 (1.276-2.397)0.0011.956 (1.473-2.597)0.0001.458 (1.154-1.842)0.002
Donor BMI
Normal weight111
Underweight1.581 (1.214-2.060)0.0011.449 (1.131-1.857)0.0031.200 (0.978-1.472)0.080
Overweight1.025 (0.881-1.194)0.7461.008 (0.878-1.158)0.9071.025 (0.922-1.140)0.647
Obese class I0.983 (0.788-1.226)0.8781.016 (0.832-1.239)0.8791.061 (0.913-1.233)0.437
Obese class II1.217 (0.878-1.686)0.2391.189 (0.880-1.606)0.2591.223 (0.973-1.536)0.996
Obese class III1.013 (0.647-1.585)0.9550.952 (0.626-1.448)0.8170.999 (0.731-1.365)0.996
Recipient age
18-45111
46-551.305 (1.089-1.563)0.0041.324 (1.122-1.583)0.0011.302 (1.146-1.479)0.000
56-651.563 (1.292-1.891)0.0001.719 (1.447-2.041)0.0001.650 (1.443-1.888)0.000
66-752.251 (1.737-2.917)0.0002.451 (1.941-3.094)0.0002.570 (2.146-3.078)0.000
≥ 765.081 (1.410-18.316)0.0136.345 (2.060-20.105)0.0012.694 (0.871-8.328)0.344
Donor age
0-17111
18-451.207 (0.961-1.516)0.1061.216 (0.988-1.496)0.0651.138 (0.968-1.337)0.118
46-551.492 (1.154-1.929)0.0021.411 (1.117-1.784)0.0041.464 (1.221-1.755)0.000
56-651.357 (1.027-1.793)0.0321.388 (1.079-1.785)0.0111.365 (1.123-1.660)0.002
66-751.308 (0.929-1.843)0.1241.379 (1.014-1.875)0.0411.550 (1.230-1.954)0.000
≥ 760.639 (0.291-1.403)0.2650.864 (0.456-1.638)0.6541.527 (1.034-2.253)0.033
Recipient sex (male)0.909 (0.787-1.050)0.1940.966 (0.847-1.102)0.6081.051 (0.948-1.164)0.344
Donor sex (male)1.017 (0.888-1.164)0.8071.009 (0.892-1.142)0.8880.993 (0.904-1.092)0.888
Cold ischemia time (h)1.033 (1.019-1.047)0.0001.021 (1.007-1.035)0.0031.024 (1.013-1.035)0.000
Warm ischemia time (min)1.008 (1.005-1.011)0.0001.007 (1.005-1.010)0.0001.006 (1.004-1.008)0.000
Year of transplantation0.987 (0.968-1.006)0.1820.970 (0.953-0.987)0.0001.003 (0.989-1.016)0.686
Dialysis2.922 (2.378-3.590)0.0002.824 (2.326-3.429)0.0002.436 (2.071-2.865)0.000
Diabetes1.165 (0.990-1.371)0.0651.149 (0.992-1.331)0.0631.226 (1.095-1.374)0.000
COPD1.276 (0.803-2.027)0.3031.155 (0.996-1.341)0.0571.233 (0.883-1.720)0.219
Hypertension0.957 (0.796-1.151)0.6420.959 (0.810-1.135)0.6241.027 (0.905-1.166)0.680
Primary indication for transplant
HCV1.369 (1.114-1.682)0.0031.215 (1.049-1.408)0.0090.980 (0.847-1.135)0.791
Alcohol + HCV1.307 (0.976-1.752)0.0731.038 (0.808-1.332)0.7720.961 (0.788-1.173)0.698
HCV + Other viral hepatitis1.307 (0.976-1.752)0.0730.895 (0.509-1.575)0.7010.876 (0.564-1.362)0.558
Other0.730 (0.549-0.970)0.0300.693 (0.544-0.883)0.0030.843 (0.677-1.050)0.128
Alcohol1.380 (1.095-1.740)0.0061.172 (0.988-1.391)0.0681.366 (1.153-1.618)0.000
HBV1.230 (0.871-1.737)0.2391.263 (0.912-1.747)0.1591.326 (1.023-1.719)0.033
PSC1.749 (1.229-2.489)0.0021.608 (1.190-2.172)0.0021.777 (1.377-2.293)0.000
PBC1.989 (1.394-2.837)0.0001.834 (1.352-2.487)0.0001.754 (1.365-2.252)0.000
NASH1.564 (0.899-2.722)0.1131.043 (0.660-1.649)0.8571.298 (0.902-1.869)0.160
Autoimmune1.179 (0.825-1.686)0.3650.879 (0.648-1.191)0.4051.027 (0.794-1.329)0.840
Acute liver failure0.839 (0.462-1.522)0.8390.797 (0.450-1.410)0.4351.183 (0.712-1.964)0.517
Congenital or metabolic disease1.139 (0.832-1.522)0.5631.094 (0.821-1.458)0.5401.162 (0.919-1.469)0.211