Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2020.
World J Psychiatr. Jul 19, 2020; 10(7): 162-174
Published online Jul 19, 2020. doi: 10.5498/wjp.v10.i7.162
Table 3 Summary Ballard et al[44], 2018
Ref.OutcomesTolerabilityLimitations
Ballard et al[44], 2018Primary outcome: At week 6: (1) Significant improvement in NPI-NH psychosis score (mean change was -3.76 points (SE 0.65) for pimavanserin group and -1.93 points (0.63) for placebo (mean difference -1.84 [95%CI: -3.64, -0.04]; P = 0.045) without negative effects on cognition or motor function; (2) Response (≥ 30% improvement) in 55% (pimavanserin) vs 37% (placebo); and (3) In NPI-NH < 12 subgroup: Mean change of the score from baseline to week 6 was -0.58 (95%CI: -2.10, 0.95) for pimavanserin vs -0.16 (-1.60 to 1.28) for placebo [mean difference -0.42 (95%CI: -2.52, 1.68)], Cohen’s d = –0.77; P = 0.694. At week 12: No significant advantage for pimavanserin vs placebo was observed for the overall study population [treatment difference -0.51 (95%CI: -2.23, 1.21); P = 0.561]. Secondary outcome: At weeks 6 and 12: No significant differences between placebo and pimavanserin for ADCS–CGIC, NPI–NH agitation/aggression, NPI–NH sleep and nighttime behavior disorders, and CMAI–SFAdverse events (pimavanserin vs placebo). Most common: (1) Agitation (21% vs 14%); (2) Aggression (10% vs 4%); (3) Falls (21% vs 21%); (4) Urinary tract infection (20% vs 25%); and (5) Peripheral edema (8% vs 2%). Less common: (1) Weight loss (-0.7 kg vs -0.1 kg); (2) QTc prolongation (9.4 ms vs -0.2 ms); and (3) Death (4 vs 4)Limitations: (1) Study was not sufficiently powered to control for secondary outcomes; (2) Limited number of participants in severe psychosis subcategory or prior history of antipsychotic use; (3) Biomarker confirmation for patients diagnosed with Alzheimer’s was not possible in the nursing home patients; (4) Possibility of trial participants inclusion of non-Alzheimer’s type and mixed dementia; (5) High attrition rate: 26% (pimavanserin) and 20% (placebo); and (6) Absence of active comparator to assess efficacy/tolerability between pimavanserin and other antipsychotics. Strengths: (1) Rigorous diagnosis of psychosis – high completion rate at week 12; (2) Participants assessed in the community care homes providing access to the elderly population to be included in the clinical study; and (3) Researchers were able to study frail, elderly participants in their “natural” environment