Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2018.
World J Gastrointest Endosc. Dec 16, 2018; 10(12): 422-441
Published online Dec 16, 2018. doi: 10.4253/wjge.v10.i12.422
Table 2 Assessment of risk of bias by JADAD scale
#STUDYRandomized? (1 pt)Randomization methodAdequate randomization? (1 pt)Double blind? (1 pt)Masking methodAdequate masking? (1 pt)Loss description? (1 pt)Jadad (0-5 pts)GENERAL QUALITY
1Regev et al[34]YesRandomization per patients' ID (odd or even numbers)NoNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes2Intermidiate
2Lawrance et al[35]YesRandomized using Generator Pro 1.69 (Segobit software) in ratio 2:1:1 (PEG:NaP:Pico)YesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
3Kao et al[36]YesRandomization in blocks of 8 and stratified per AM/PM using a computer-generated tableYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
4Katz et al[15]YesRandomization numbers allocated sequentially by voice systemYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
5Manes et al[37]YesRandomization by computer-generated sequenceYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
6Rex et al[15]YesRandomization numbers allocated sequentially by voice systemYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
7Jeon et al[38]YesRandomization by computer-generated tableYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
8Kang et al[39]YesRandomization in blocks using website randomization.comYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
9Kim et al[40]YesNot describedNoNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoNo1Low
10Kim et al[41]YesRandomization by computer-generated sequenceYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
11Leitao et al[28]YesRandomization 1:1 with blocks of 10 by endoscopy-unit secretaryYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoNo2Intermidiate
12Kim et al[29]YesRandomization by computer-generated tableYesNoNot describedNoNo2Intermidiate
13Munsterman et al[30]YesRandomization by computer-generated 1:1 stratified by age (18-64) or (65-80)YesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoNo2Intermidiate
14Pohl et al[31]YesRandomization 1:1 in blocks of 4 by statistician list-generatedYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
15Yoo et al[32]YesRandomization 1:1 in blocks of 4 by a a computer-generated listYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimenNoYes3High
16Kojecky et al[33]YesRandomization 1:1 using a software generated random tableYesNoEndoscopist blind for the preparation regimentNoYes3High