Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Gastroenterol. Nov 21, 2015; 21(43): 12482-12497
Published online Nov 21, 2015. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v21.i43.12482
Table 2 Reported outcome for cooperative laparoscopic endoscopic techniques with > 10 patients
AuthorsYearTechniqueCasesLesionLocationLesion size (mm)Operative time (min)Blood loss (mL)LOS (d)
Choi et al[20]2000EAWR21SMT, leiomyo-sarcomaStomach(20-60)(80-180)NR(6-7)
LIGS10
Proximal gastrectomy1
Shimizu et al[26]2002EAWR11SMTStomachNR145 ± 4398 ± 10713.2 ± 3.7
Matthews et al[30]2002EAWR15GISTStomach45 (17-82)169 (65-300)106 (20-200)3.8 (2.7)
EATR3
Needlescopic LIGS (enucleations)3
Ludwig et al[27]2002EAWR18SMT, EGCStomachNR44.3 (31-67)NR7.5 (3-11)
LIGS867.1 (49-102)10.2 (6-16)
Bouillot et al[19]2003EAWR20SMTStomach38 (15-100)104 (40-120)NR6 (2-12)
Walsh et al[36]2003LIGS13SMTStomach38 (15-70)186NR3.8 (3-8)
Hindmarsh et al[21]2005EAWR30SMTStomach46.6 (12-90)73.8 (26-160)196 (0-1000)5 (1-11)
Schubert et al[28]2005EAWR16SMT, EGCStomach36 (16-47)53 (35-115)NRNR
LIGS7SMT, EGCStomach36 (16-47)83 (56-130)
Mochizuki et al[24]2006EAWR12SMTStomach27 (15-48)1100 (65-180)10 (0-100)17 (5-12)1
Novitsky et al[13]2006EAWR30SMTStomach44 (10-85)135 (49-295)NRNR
LIGS17
other3
Huguet et al[22]2008EAWR11SMTStomach39 (5-10.5)1NRNR3 (1-40)1
EATR
Privette et al[15]2008EAWR5SMTStomach52 (25-60)180 (122-262)80 (50-100)3.4 (2-5)
Distal gastrectomy355 (35-70)322 (256-340)167 (100-200)8.3 (8-9)
LIGS446 (25-75)236 (202-265)100 (50-200)3.3 (3-4)
Wilhelm et al[16]2008LAER1SMTStomach525NR2 (2)
EAWR5525 (3-65)81.2 (35-202)7.68 (4-19)
EATR3426 (5-55)114 (40-275)7.48 (2-14)
Sasaki et al[25]2010EAWR35SMTStomach32 (16-74)73 (30-150)3 (1-80)7 (5-14)
LIGS3145 (100-240)10 (3-65)8 (5-9)
Single port LIGS3
EATR4
Kang et al[14]2013EAWR97SMTStomach(10-82)113 ± 3636 ± 184.5 ± 2.1
Ohata et al[29]2014EAWR22SMT, EDCDuodenum13.3 ± 11.6133 ± 4516 ± 21.115.1 ± 7.7
Qiu et al[6]2013LAER5GISTStomach28 ± 1681.6 ± 31.829.8 ± 15.44.6
EAWR64GISTStomach86.3 ± 28.531.4 ± 11.6
Dong et al[68]2014MLIGS8SMTStomach27.5 ± 10.785 ± 25.7720 ± 10.47.5 ± 1.1
EFR1016.5 ± 5.9120 ± 34.7248 ± 31.910.2 ± 9.1
Tsujimoto et al[49]2012LECS20SMTStomach37.9 (18-66)157.5 (89-316)3.5 (0-20)11.6 (6-13)
Kawahira et al[46]2012LECS16SMTStomachNR172NR10
Hoteya et al[45]2014LECS25SMTStomachNR156NR10.5
Cho et al[56]2011LAEFR + Lymphadenectomy14EGCStomach26 (12-90)1143 (110-253)116 (5-30)16 (4-10)1
Hur et al[57]2014LAEFR + Lymphadenectomy9EGCStomach12 (4-32)181 (125-240)NR5.9 ± 1.3 (4-8)
LADG4
Mori et al[54]2015LAEFR16GISTStomach28.3 (8-54)271 (100-480)NR12.3 (10-15)
Shiwaku et al[71]2010Clean-NET16EGCStomachNR182.119.4NR