Wang RX, Boland GJ, Hattum JV, Gast GC. Long term persistence of T cell memory to HBsAg after hepatitis B vaccination. World J Gastroenterol 2004; 10(2): 260-263
Corresponding Author of This Article
Dr. Ru-Xiang Wang, Shenyang Center for Disease Control and Prevention, 37 Qishan Zhong Lu, Huanggu District, Shenyang 110031, Liaoning Province China. firstname.lastname@example.org
Article-Type of This Article
Open-Access Policy of This Article
This article is an open-access article which was selected by an in-house editor and fully peer-reviewed by external reviewers. It is distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
World J Gastroenterol. Jan 15, 2004; 10(2): 260-263 Published online Jan 15, 2004. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v10.i2.260
Long term persistence of T cell memory to HBsAg after hepatitis B vaccination
Ru-Xiang Wang, Greet J. Boland, Jan van Hattum, Gijsbert C. de Gast
Ru-Xiang Wang, Shenyang Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Shenyang 110031, Liaoning Province, China
Greet J. Boland, Jan van Hattum, Department of Gastroenterology, University Hospital Utrecht, the Netherlands
Gijsbert C. de Gast, Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, the Netherlands
ORCID number: $[AuthorORCIDs]
Author contributions: All authors contributed equally to the work.
Correspondence to: Dr. Ru-Xiang Wang, Shenyang Center for Disease Control and Prevention, 37 Qishan Zhong Lu, Huanggu District, Shenyang 110031, Liaoning Province China. email@example.com
Telephone: +86-24-86853243 Fax: +86-24-86863778
Received: April 12, 2003 Revised: October 4, 2003 Accepted: October 11, 2003 Published online: January 15, 2004
AIM: To determine if the T cell memory to HBsAg can persist for a long time after hepatitis B (HB) vaccination.
METHODS: Thirty one vaccine recipients who were healthcare workers (18 females and 13 males aged 34-58 years) from Utrecht University Hospital, Netherlands, and had previously received a standard course of vaccination for hepatitis B were investigated and another 9 unvaccinated healthy volunteers from the same hospital were used as the control. Blood samples were taken just before the experiment to test serum anti-HBs levels and the subjects were classified into different groups according to their serum titers of anti-HBs and vaccination history. Their peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were isolated from freshly heparinized venous blood and the proliferative response of T lymphocytes to the recombinant hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) was investigated.
RESULTS: Positive serum anti-HBs was found in 61.3% (19/31) vaccine recipients and a significant in vitro lymphocyte proliferative response to recombinant HBsAg was observed in all the vaccinees with positive anti-HBs. Serum anti-HBs level ≤ 10 IU/L was found in 38.7% (12/31) subjects. In this study, we specially focused on lymphocyte proliferative response to recombinant HBsAg in those vaccine recipients with serum anti-HBsAg less than 10 IU/L. Most of them had received a standard course of vaccination about 10 years before. T lymphocyte proliferative response was found positive in 7 of the 12 vaccine recipients. These results confirmed that HBsAg-specific memory T cells remained detectable in the circulation for a long time after vaccination, even when serum anti-HBs level had been undetectable.
CONCLUSION: The T cell memory to HBsAg can persist for at least 10 years after HB vaccination. Further booster injection is not necessary in healthy responders to HB vaccine.
Key Words: $[Keywords]
Citation: Wang RX, Boland GJ, Hattum JV, Gast GC. Long term persistence of T cell memory to HBsAg after hepatitis B vaccination. World J Gastroenterol 2004; 10(2): 260-263
Since the introduction of hepatitis B vaccination in the early 1980s, many epidemiological studies have been done to determine the efficacy of the vaccine in eliciting protective immunity against HBV infection. The antibody response to HB vaccine has been found occurring in more than 90% of the healthy vaccinees[1-15]. Kinetic studies showed serum anti-HBs levels decreased with time following vaccination[5,9,14,16]. Several demographic and behavioral factors have been found to be associated with a lower rate of antibody response to hepatitis B vaccine[17,18]. In a considerable percentage of vaccinated persons the anti-HBs level was expected to drop to below 10 IU/L after 5-10 years[5,19,20]. The decline seemed to be proportional to the antibody titer originally obtained[15,21]. The necessity of implementing booster injections for those with their anti-HBs levels less than 10 IU/ L has remained to be determined.[13,16,20,22,23]
A correlation between in vivo antibody production and in vitro T cell proliferative response following immunization with HBsAg vaccine has been reported[24,25]. In previous studies we demonstrated that the B cell memory to HBsAg persisted for a long time after HB vaccination. The purpose of this study was to determine whether the HBsAg-specific T lymphocyte memory could persist for a long time after HB vaccination especially in vaccine recipients whose serum anti-HBs level was less than 10 IU/L in an attempt to determine the optimal policy of booster vaccination.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Forty healthy healthcare personnel from Utrecht University Hospital, the Netherlands participated in the study. Of them, 31 subjects (18 females and 13 males aged 34-58 years) had previously received a standard course of hepatitis B vaccination of 10 or 20 µg HB vaccine from Merck Sharp & Dohme, West Point, PA, USA (MSD) or Smith Kline and Beecham (SKB, Rixensart, Belgium) at 0, 1, and 6 months about 10 years before. Another 9 unvaccinated healthy volunteers (5 females and 4 males aged 29-57 years) from the same hospital functioned as the control.
Recombinant HBsAg free of preservatives was a gift from Merck Sharp & Dohme, West Point, PA, USA. Hepatitis B vaccine used in vivo in the study was HB-Vax (MSD). Anti-HBs levels were measured in the study by means of Ausab EIA test (Abbott, Chicago, IL, USA).
The serum from all the volunteers was tested for HBV markers and the subjects were classified into four groups according to their serum titers of anti-HBs and vaccination history. Group I, unvaccinated (n = 9); group II, vaccinated and with anti-HBs ≤ 10 IU/L (n = 12); group III, vaccinated and with anti-HBs 10-100 IU/L (n = 6); group IV vaccinated and with anti-HBs greater than 100 IU/L (n = 13). The unvaccinated healthy volunteers had no evidence of natural HBV infection (negative in the detection of serum HBsAg, anti-HBc or anti-HBs). Blood from all the subjects was collected, serum was tested for anti-HBs levels and peripheral mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were used for lymphocyte proliferation. All the subjects from whom blood was drawn gave their written informed consent for the study. This study was approved by the Medical Ethical Committee of Utrecht Hospital, the Netherlands, under No 92/82.
Cell culture and proliferation assays
PBMCs were isolated from freshly heparinized venous blood by Ficoll-Hypaque density gradient centrifugation. Blood samples were taken just before the experiment.
PBMCs were suspended in RPMI 1640 culture medium supplemented with 10% heat-inactivated pooled human AB serum (Red Cross Blood Bank, Utrecht, the Netherlands), 25 mM HEPES, 2 mmol/L L-glutamine, 50 U/ml penicillin and 50 µg/ml streptomycin. PBMCs (4×105 cells/well) from each sample were prepared in 96-well U-bottom plates and stimulated with different doses of HBsAg (10 ng/mL, 30 ng/mL, 100 ng/mL, 300 ng/mL and 1.0 µg/ml) for 7 days at 37 °C in 95% humidified air with 5% CO2. Concanavalin A (Con A) at 240 µg/ml, tetanus toxoid and diphtheria toxoid at 3.3 µg/ml served as each sample’s positive control for lymphocyte proliferation. Negative control cultures were made by incubating cells in medium alone. During the final 18 h incubation, the cells were pulsed with 1.0 µCi of (3H)-thymidine per well. Sixteen to twenty hours after the cultures were harvested onto glass filters using a multichannel cell harvester the incorporated (3H)-thymidine was measured by liquid scintillation counting. Since there were individual variations in the concentration of maximal stimulation and 300 ng/mL and 1.0 µg/ml of HBsAg gave the maximal stimulation and the least variability in the triplicates, we chose the maximal stimulation at the concentration of 300 ng/mL and 1.0 µg/ml of HBsAg as the optimal result for each subject. Results were expressed as net counts (the value of (3H)-thymidine incorporation of HBsAg stimulation culture minus the value of (3H)-thymidine incorporation of medium). A net count was considered positive if the value of (3H)-thymidine incorporation was higher than the average in the unvaccinated control group + 2 SD.
ANOVA and Mann-Whitney U-test were used to compare the results between the different groups and the different concentrations.
HBsAg-induced in vitro proliferative response in vaccinated groups
The lymphocyte proliferation correlated with serum antibody levels. The highest proliferative response was observed in those vaccinated with serum anti-HBs greater than 100 IU/L (Table 1). The difference of proliferative responses between those with serum anti-HBs levels ≤ 10 IU/L and those with serum anti-HBs level > 10 IU/L was statistically significant (P = 0.0022). The PBMCs from the unvaccinated control group did not respond to HBsAg (in comparison with those with serum anti-HBs levels ≤ 10 IU/L, P = 0.0093). As shown in Figure 1, neither the proliferative response to diphtheria and tetanus toxoid, nor the response to mitogen ConA did differ significantly between groups I-IV.
Table 1 Lymphocyte proliferation to HBsAg in controls and vaccine recipients.
aP-value of statistical comparison of net counts of group II (anti-HBs ≤10 IU/L) with group I (unvaccinated control): P = 0.0093,
bP-value of statistical comparison of group II with group III + group IV (anti-HBs > 10 IU/L): P = 0.0022 (Mann-Whitney).
Figure 1 T cell proliferation to HBsAg, ConA and Tet/diph toxoid.
The lymphocyte proliferation correlates with serum anti-HBs levels. Neither the proliferative response to diphthe-ria and tetanus toxoid nor to the mitogen ConA did differ sig-nificantly between groups I-IV.
Lymphocyte proliferative response in vaccine recipients with serum anti-HBs less than 10 IU/L
A positive lymphocyte proliferative response was observed in 7 of the 12 subjects with serum anti-HBs less than 10 IU/L. Compared with other groups (with anti-HBs > 10 IU/L), the mean proliferative response was lower. There was no correlation between the presence of low anti-HBs titer (4-10 IU/L) or the absence of anti-HBs (≤ 2 IU/L) with the proliferative response, nor with the time from vaccination to testing (Table 2).
Table 2 Lymphocyte proliferation to HBsAg in vaccine recipi-ents with anti-HBs serum levels ≤ 10 IU/L.
aIf the net count of a subject was more than the net count of unvaccinated control group + 2 SD, it was considered positive. Abbreviation: F = female, M = male.
The humoral immune response to hepatitis B after vaccination has been studied systematically. However, duration and the quality of long term protection from HB infection in healthy vaccinees remain a matter of discussion[1-8]. Especially the T cell response to hepatitis B vaccine has not been fully characterized. Several studies were performed to detect the lymphocyte proliferative response in vitro with purified HBsAg, recombinant HBsAg, preS1, preS2 and peptides of HBsAg, but results were not consistent[26-29]. The immune response to HBsAg in vitro was difficult to detect and might not be detected in all vaccinated individuals. T cell responses in vitro after vaccination in individuals responding to vaccination were significantly diminished after 12 weeks, a time when the antibody response was still vigorous. It has been suggested that there were many variables such as geometry of the wells, the quality of culture media and in particular that of the added serum that influenced the assay results. In addition, the number of cultured PMBCs and duration of the culture might be important. In our previous experiments, we tested the influence of variables such as cell density, culture time and dose of antigen for lymphocyte proliferation. We observed that 1.0 µg/ml HBsAg, 4×105 cells/ well, use of human AB+ serum and 6 days of culture achieved optimal results. These results confirmed the assay conditions described by G. Leroux-Roels.
To our knowledge, few reports have elucidated the long term efficacy of hepatitis B vaccination on T- cell immunity. In the past, a few groups have induced HBsAg-specific lymphocyte proliferative response in culture of fresh PBMCs from the individuals who were just vaccinated with hepatitis B vaccine or received a booster dose during the experiment[24,30,31]. In our study 31 healthy persons (healthcare personnel) volunteered to give blood to test the specific response to hepatitis B. All of them were vaccinated several years ago. Our data showed that a lymphocyte proliferative response to HBsAg should be detected in vitro in all the vaccine recipients with positive anti-HBs. This result further confirms that in vivo humoral and in vitro cellular immune responses to HBsAg are closely correlated. In addition, we found that the HB vaccine has the capacity to stimulate the cellular immune response in vitro.
However, the most interesting group in our study was the vaccine recipients with serum anti-HBs levels less than 10 IU/L. We observed positive lymphocyte proliferative responses in 7 of the 12 subjects, although the maximal proliferation was lower than that in vaccine recipients with positive serum anti-HBs. We previously reported that an immunological B cell memory to hepatitis B after a vaccination existed in healthcare personnel though serum anti-HBs titers were decreased with time or not measurable in some cases. The long term efficacy of hepatitis B vaccination was also investigated in China and it was found that the protective efficacy of hepatitis B vaccination was still existed with a low risk of becoming a carrier and a low serum level of neutralizing antibody even at the time of 12 years after vaccination. These findings suggest that immunity can persist for a long time after vaccination even when the serum antibody levels are below 10 IU/L. It is therefore possible that the T cell immune response plays an important role in protecting against hepatitis B virus infection and becoming a carrier in the absence of antibodies, either directly or indirectly by providing help to produce antibodies.
Our group previously showed a sensitive in vitro method for the study of B cell memory to HBsAg. A good correlation between in vitro mitogen induced IgG anti-HBs spots and immune memory after a booster dose of HB vaccination was observed in naturally infected subjects and vaccine recipients. Our results that 58% of the HB vaccine recipients with anti-HBs ≤ 10 IU/L have kept lymphocyte proliferative responses many years after vaccination could confirm that HB vaccine not only induces humoral immunity but also cell-mediated immunity and that T cell memory often persists longer than serum anti-HBs titers.
We conclude that T cell memory to HBsAg can be demonstrated by lymphocyte proliferation many years after HB vaccination, even in the majority of persons with serum anti-HBs ≤ 10 IU/L. Booster vaccination in those persons is probably not necessary as T cell memory is still existed, which means that the protective antibodies will reappear rapidly or that effector cytotoxic T cells can rapidly eliminate virus infected hepatocytes after exposure to HBV. Our results are of practical value because of high prevalence of hepatitis B in Asia, especially in China.
Edited by Wang XL
Liao SS, Li RC, Li H, Yang JY, Zeng XJ, Gong J, Wang SS, Li YP, Zhang KL. Long-term efficacy of plasma-derived hepatitis B vaccine among Chinese children: a 12-year follow-up study.World J Gastroenterol. 1999;5:165-166.
Li H, Li RC, Liao SS, Yang JY, Zeng XJ, Wang SS. Persistence of hepatitis B vaccine immune protection and response to hepatitis B booster immunization.World J Gastroenterol. 1998;4:493-496.
Kojouharova M, Teoharov P, Bahtchevanova T, Maeva I, Eginlian A, Deneva M. Safety and immunogenicity of a yeast-derived recombinant hepatitis B vaccine in Bulgarian newborns.Infection. 2001;29:342-344.
Rendi-Wagner P, Kundi M, Stemberger H, Wiedermann G, Holzmann H, Hofer M, Wiesinger K, Kollaritsch H. Antibody-response to three recombinant hepatitis B vaccines: comparative evaluation of multicenter travel-clinic based experience.Vaccine. 2001;19:2055-2060.
Ozaki T, Mochizuki H, Ichikawa Y, Fukuzawa Y, Yoshida S, Morimoto M. Persistence of hepatitis B surface antibody levels after vaccination with a recombinant hepatitis B vaccine: a 3-year follow-up study.J Oral Sci. 2000;42:147-150.
Jain A, Mathur US, Jandwani P, Gupta RK, Kumar V, Kar P. A multicentric evaluation of recombinant DNA hepatitis B vaccine of Cuban origin.Trop Gastroenterol. 2000;21:14-17.
Al-Faleh FZ, Al-Jeffri M, Ramia S, Al-Rashed R, Arif M, Rezeig M, Al-Toraif I, Bakhsh M, Mishkkhas A, Makki O. Seroepidemiology of hepatitis B virus infection in Saudi children 8 years after a mass hepatitis B vaccination programme.J Infect. 1999;38:167-170.
Li H, Li RC, Liao SS, Gong J, Zeng XJ, Li YP. Long-term effectiveness of infancy low-dose hepatitis B vaccine immunization in Zhuang minority area in China.World J Gastroenterol. 1999;5:122-124.
Liu HB, Meng ZD, Ma JC, Han CQ, Zhang YL, Xing ZC, Zhang YW, Liu YZ, Cao HL. A 12-year cohort study on the efficacy of plasma-derived hepatitis B vaccine in rural newborns.World J Gastroenterol. 2000;6:381-383.
Li H, Wang L, Wang SS, Gong J, Zeng XJ, Li RC, Nong Y, Huang YK, Chen XR, Huang ZN. Research on optimal immunization strategies for hepatitis B in different endemic areas in China.World J Gastroenterol. 2000;6:392-394.
Zeng XJ, Yang GH, Liao SS, Chen AP, Tan J, Huang ZJ, Li H. Survey of coverage, strategy and cost of hepatitis B vaccination in rural and urban areas of China.World J Gastroenterol. 1999;5:320-323.
Shokri F, Jafarzadeh A. High seroprotection rate induced by low doses of a recombinant hepatitis B vaccine in healthy Iranian neonates.Vaccine. 2001;19:4544-4548.
Trivello R, Chiaramonte M, Ngatchu T, Baldo V, Majori S, Moschen ME, Simoncello I, Renzulli G, Naccarato R. Persistence of anti-HBs antibodies in health care personnel vaccinated with plasma-derived hepatitis B vaccine and response to recombinant DNA HB booster vaccine.Vaccine. 1995;13:139-141.
Whittle HC, Maine N, Pilkington J, Mendy M, Fortuin M, Bunn J, Allison L, Howard C, Hall A. Long-term efficacy of continuing hepatitis B vaccination in infancy in two Gambian villages.Lancet. 1995;345:1089-1092.
Jilg W, Schmidt M, Deinhardt F. Decline of anti-HBs after hepatitis B vaccination and timing of revaccination.Lancet. 1990;335:173-174.
Wismans PJ, van Hattum J, Mudde GC, Endeman HJ, Poel J, de Gast GC. Is booster injection with hepatitis B vaccine necessary in healthy responders A study of the immune response.J Hepatol. 1989;8:236-240.
Wood RC, MacDonald KL, White KE, Hedberg CW, Hanson M, Osterholm MT. Risk factors for lack of detectable antibody following hepatitis B vaccination of Minnesota health care workers.JAMA. 1993;270:2935-2939.
Roome AJ, Walsh SJ, Cartter ML, Hadler JL. Hepatitis B vaccine responsiveness in Connecticut public safety personnel.JAMA. 1993;270:2931-2934.
Watson B, West DJ, Chilkatowsky A, Piercy S, Ioli VA. Persistence of immunologic memory for 13 years in recipients of a recombinant hepatitis B vaccine.Vaccine. 2001;19:3164-3168.
Wiström J, Ahlm C, Lundberg S, Settergren B, Tärnvik A. Booster vaccination with recombinant hepatitis B vaccine four years after priming with one single dose.Vaccine. 1999;17:2162-2165.
Banatvala J, Van Damme P, Oehen S. Lifelong protection against hepatitis B: the role of vaccine immunogenicity in immune memory.Vaccine. 2000;19:877-885.
García Llop L, Asensi Alcoverro A, Coll Más P, Ramada Benedito MA, Grafiá Juan C. [Anti-HBs titers after a vaccination program in children and adolescents. Should a booster dose be given].An Esp Pediatr. 2001;54:32-37.
Huang LM, Chiang BL, Lee CY, Lee PI, Chi WK, Chang MH. Long-term response to hepatitis B vaccination and response to booster in children born to mothers with hepatitis B e antigen.Hepatology. 1999;29:954-959.
Leroux-Roels G, Van Hecke E, Michielsen W, Voet P, Hauser P, Petre J. Correlation between in vivo humoral and in vitro cellular immune responses following immunization with hepatitis B sur-face antigen (HBsAg) vaccines.Vaccine. 1994;12:812-815.
Are booster immunisations needed for lifelong hepatitis B immunity European Consensus Group on Hepatitis B Immunity. Lancet. 2000;355:561-565.
De Gast GC, Houwen B, Nieweg HO. Specific lymphocyte stimulation by purified, heat-inactivated hepatitis-B antigen.Br Med J. 1973;4:707-709.
Fernan A, Cayzer CJ, Cooksley WG. HBsAg-induced antigen-specific T and B lymphocyte responses in chronic hepatitis B virus carriers and immune individuals.Clin Exp Immunol. 1989;76:222-226.
Ferrari C, Penna A, Bertoletti A, Cavalli A, Valli A, Schianchi C, Fiaccadori F. The preS1 antigen of hepatitis B virus is highly immunogenic at the T cell level in man.J Clin Invest. 1989;84:1314-1319.
Cupps TR, Tibbles J, Hurni WM, Miller WJ, Ellis RW, Milich D, Wetter N. In vitro T cell immune responses to the preS2 antigen of the hepatitis B virus envelope protein in preS2 + S vaccine recipients. Absence of cross-reactivity of subtypes at a major T cell recognition site.J Immunol. 1993;151:3353-3360.
Deulofeut H, Iglesias A, Mikael N, Bing DH, Awdeh Z, Yunis J, Marcus-Bagley D, Kruskall MS, Alper CA, Yunis EJ. Cellular recognition and HLA restriction of a midsequence HBsAg peptide in hepatitis B vaccinated individuals.Mol Immunol. 1993;30:941-948.
Degrassi A, Mariani E, Honorati MC, Roda P, Miniero R, Capelli M, Facchini A. Cellular response and anti-HBs synthesis in vitro after vaccination with yeast-derived recombinant hepatitis vaccine.Vaccine. 1992;10:617-622.
Wismans PJ, van Hattum J, de Gast GC, Bouter KP, Diepersloot RJ, Maikoe T, Mudde GC. A prospective study of in vitro anti-HBs producing B cells (spot-ELISA) following primary and supplementary vaccination with a recombinant hepatitis B vaccine in insulin dependent diabetic patients and matched controls.J Med Virol. 1991;35:216-222.
Wismans PJ, van Hattum J, De Gast GC, Endeman HJ, Poel J, Stolk B, Maikoe T, Mudde GC. The spot-ELISA: a sensitive in vitro method to study the immune response to hepatitis B surface antigen.Clin Exp Immunol. 1989;78:75-79.