Jin Nü Fang¹, Chang Ji Jin¹, Lian Hua Cui¹, Zhen Yu Quan¹, BoYoul Choi², Moran Ki³ and Hung Bae Park^2
1Department of Epidemiology, Yanbian University College of Medicine, Yanji 133000, Jilin Province, China
²Department of Preventive Medicine, Hanyang University College of Medicine, Seoul 133791, Korea
³Department of Preventive Medicine, Eulji University School of Medicine, Taejon 301110, Korea
Dr. Jin Nü Fang, graduated from Norman Bethune University of Medical Sciences in 1985, Hanyang University College of Medicine with a doctoral degree in 1999, now associate professor of epidemiology, specialized in infectious disease epidemiology and cardiovascular epidemiology, having 10 papers published.
Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China, No. 39560074 and Korea Science and Engineering Foundation, 965-0700-001-2.
Correspondence to: Dr. Jin Nü Fang, Department of Epidemiology, Yanbian University College of Medicine, Yanji 133000,
Jilin Province, China
Telephone: 0086-433-2660621 Email. epidem@public.yj.jl.cn
Received: 2000-09-19  Accepted: 2000-09-29

Subject headings: hepatitis B virus; immunoenzyme techniques; serologic tests; hepatitis B surface antigens; hepatitis B/epidemiology; enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay

Fang JN, Jin CJ, Cui LH, Quan ZY, Choi BY, Ki MR, Park HB. A comparative study on serologic profiles of virus hepatitis B.
World J Gastroenterol, 2001;7(1):107-110

INTRODUCTION
Hepatitis B viral infection, one of the most-prevalent liver disorders in China and Korea, is a serious infectious disease as it has the potential of progressing into liver cirrhosis and primary hepatic carcinoma. China and Korea both belong to high-risk endemic regions of viral hepatitis^［1］. The HBsAg positive rates in China ranged from 6.9%-17.9% by age, race and test methods^［2-5］. In Korea, they were 6.5%-13.3% in all age groups^［6-9］, and 3.9%-5.9% in childhood groups^［10-11］. There have been few comparative studies on Korean-Chinese and other Chinese. Considering the high mortality rates of liver cirrhosis or hepatoma among Korean-Chinese, HBsAg positive rate of Korean-Chinese must be higher than that of other Chinese. The positive rates of Korean-Chinese in Yanji and Longjing cities of Yanbian area by RPHA method were 7.5% and 7.1% respectively, which were higher than 6.2% and 4.7% in Han-Chinese respectively^［12］.
      In regard to the possible reasons of such differences, some studies have laid special emphasis on social, economic and demographic variables such as age, sex, life style, and environment.
      This study was conducted in order to assess the pattern of hepatitis B infection prevailing among Han-Chinese, Korean-Chinese, and Koreans. For collection of data, two serological surveys were carried out in 1996 in Korea and China respectively.

MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study areas
Study areas were Yangpyung County of Kyonggi Province in Korea and Helong County of Yanbian, a Korean Autonomous Prefecture in China. In Helong County, the proportion of residents by ethnicity were 55% for Korean-Chinese and 44% for Han-Chinese^［13］. To compare the prevalence of hepatitis B between Korea and China, we carefully considered the characteristics of selected areas. In both areas, 70% of the residents were farmers. But the pattern of age distribution was different; the majority residing in Yangpyung County in Korea were more than 50 years old, while those in Helong County in China were over 40 years old.

Study subjects
Study subjects among ethnic groups were 556 Korean (male 41.7%, female 58.3%, P＜0.05) , 541 Korean-Chinese (male 51.6%, female 48.4%) and 261 Han-Chinese (male 39.5%, female 60.5%, P＜0.05). These distributions by gender were statistically significant in Korean and Han-Chinese. Age distributions by ethnic groups were also significantly different; and the Koreans had older age and the Chinese had younger age. Age distributions by gender were not different between Korean and Korean-Chinese, but they were significantly different in Han-Chinese (Table 1). Therefore, this study showed the results with age-adjusted rates by gender.

Table 1 Characteristics of subject by ethnic groups^d

^aP＜0.05 between sex, by χ² test; ^bP＜0.05 among age groups, by χ² test;^cP＜0.05 among age groups by sex, by χ² test;
dKoreans-Chinese: Koreans in Yanbian in China, Han-Chinese: Chinese in Yanbian in China, Koreans: Koreans in Yangpyung in Korea.

Questionnaires
The questionnaire survey gave direct interviews, including the relative factors on hepatitis B infection such as demographic characteristics, life style, vaccination and disease history.

Serologic tests
Serological markers on hepatitis B virus (HBsAg, anti-HBs and anti-HBc) were tested by EIA (enzyme immunoassays). Sera were stored in a deep freezer, at -30℃ until this test. The serologic tests were all done in Korea.  

Statistical analysis
For comparison by ethnic groups, age-adjusted rates by direct method were used. The statistical significance was determined using χ² test or Mantel-Haenszel＇s χ²-test on SPSS or EPISTAT.

RESULTS
There were no vaccinees on hepatitis B among Chinese, but the vaccination rate among Koreans was 32.4% (36.5% for males and 29.0% for females). The vaccination rate was 44.2% for the age group of 20-39 years, 45.4% for the age group of 40-49 years, and 24.4% among those aged 50 and over (Table 2). In order to compare hepatitis B virus markers among ethnic groups, the vaccinees were excluded.
      HBsAg positive rate of males was higher than that of females in the three ethnic groups. Age-adjusted HBsAg positive rates were 7.2%, 12.0% and 4.1% in Han-Chinese, Korean-Chinese, and Korean respectively (P＜0.05). This order was same in both genders. But, the difference was statistically significant only in males (P＜0.05). Anti-HBs positive rates of males were higher than those of females in Korean-Chinese and Korean, but the differences were not statistically significant. There was also no difference by gender in the Han-Chinese. The age-adjusted anti-HBs positive rate of Korean (62.5%) was the highest, of Korean-Chinese was 57.6%, and of Han-Chinese 49.2%. This order was true in males and females, but the differences among the three ethnic groups were not significant. Anti-HBc positive rates of males were higher than those of females in all three groups, but these differences were not significant. Age-adjusted anti-HBc positive rate was 69.7%, the highest in Korean-Chinese, 60.9% in Korean and 54.0% in Han-Chinese. This order was also found by gender, and these differences were all statistically significant (P＜0.05).
      The definition of hepatitis B infection was determined as cases that have any hepatitis B virus markers among HBsAg, anti-HBs and anti-HBc. The infection rate was higher in males than in females among the three ethnic groups. But the difference was significant only in Koreans (P＜0.05). Age-adjusted infection rates were 78.6% in Korean, 77.0% in Korean-Chinese and 60.7% in Han-Chinese. These differences among the three ethnic groups were significant (P＜0.05) in males, females and the total.
      In Koreans, the HBsAg positive rate was lower than that of Korean-Chinese, but the HBV infection rate was not different from Korean-Chinese, and was higher than that of the Han-Chinese. In Korean-Chinese, the HBsAg positive rate and HBV infection rate were higher than those of the Han-Chinese. In the Han-Chinese, the HBV infection rate was the lowest and the percentage of those who are susceptible was the highest (Table 3). We classified the serologic profiles into 8 types by 3 HBV markers, which are HBsAg, anti-HBc and anti-HBs. Mushahwar et al (1981)^［21］ used 15 classifications by 5 HBV markers including HBeAg and anti-HBe, to determine the HBV infectivity. We used 8 types for the description of HBV serologic profiles in the cross-sectional study. Type Ⅰ of our classification means those susceptible who have all three negative markers. These percentages of those susceptibles were higher in females than in males in all three ethnic groups. The percentage was 18.6% for Koreans or Korean-Chinese, and 36.7% for Han-Chinese. In females, the percentage was 40.5% for Han-Chinese, 29.6% for Korean, and 23.7% for Korean-Chinese. Among HBsAg positive serologic profiles, type Ⅶ was dominant. But, varied types such as Ⅴ, Ⅵ and Ⅷ were found only in Korean-Chinese and Han-Chinese excluding Koreans. Koreans had only one type Ⅶ, among HBsAg positive profiles. The percentage of HBsAg negative combination (HBsAg- and anti-HBs+ and/or anti-HBc+), were 78.5% and 65.5% for Korean, 67.5% and 67.6% for Korean-Chinese and 53.1% and 52.1% for Han-Chinese. Among these profiles, type Ⅳ was dominant in all three ethnic groups (Table 4).

Table 2 Rate of vaccination by sex and age in Koreans^b

^aP＜0.05 among age groups, by χ² test; bKoreans: Koreans in Yangpung in Korea.

Table 3 Positive rates and infection rate of Hepatitis B virus by sex and ethnic groups^e

^aP＜0.05 among 3 ethnic groups in male, by χ² test; ^bP＜0.05 among 3 ethnic groups in female, by χ² test; ^cP＜0.05 among 3 ethnic groups in total, by χ² test; ^dAge-standardized rates (standard population; Helong in 1997 and Yangpyung in 1995);^eKorean-Chinese: Koreans in Yanbian in China, Han-Chinese: Chinese in Yanbian in China, Koreans: Koreans in Yangpyung in Korea.

Table 4 Serological profiles of hepatitis B virus markers by sex and ethnic groups^a

^aKorean-Chinese: Koreans in Yanbian in China, Han-Chinese: Chinese in Yanbian in China, Koreans: Koreans in Yangpung in Korea.

DISCUSSION
Since 1980, China has produced hepatitis B vaccines and by regulations, children must be vaccinated. However, vaccination against HBV was not mandatory in adults. Therefore, none of study subjects in China were vaccinated, while in Korea, 32.4% were vaccinated. It implies that the circumstances of HBV infection and transmission were different between China and Korea. Age-adjusted HBsAg positive rate of Korean-Chinese was 12.0%, higher than the 10% previously reported in China as a whole^［14］. Moreover, the rate was higher than the 8.0% for the Korean-Chinese in Yanbian area during the 1980s^［12］. The rate for Han-Chinese (7.2%) was less than the national level (10%) in China, and the same or less than that of other reports^［2-5］. However, no other reports were found from Yanbian area, the differences did not reflect the chronological change. In Koreans, the rate for non-vaccinees was 4.1%, which was less than other reports (6.5%-13.3%)^{［6-10,15,16］}.
      Korean and Korean-Chinese are the same race, but HBsAg positive rates were different and increased with time for Korean-Chinese and decreased with time for Koreans. The difference between Korean and Korean-Chinese seems to be caused mostly by vaccination. Other factors such as socioeconomic status, sanitary status and medical support appear to influence HBV infection and transmission^{［6,7,11,17］}. The difference between Korean-Chinese and Han-Chinese resulted from cultural difference such as life style, food habits and susceptibility^{［6,7,11,17］}. The rate for Korean-Chinese was more similar to the Han-Chinese than to Koreans, which suggests that environmental factors are more important than genetic factors on HBV.
      Positive anti-HBc is difficult to determine definitely. Type Ⅳ (anti-HBs+, anti-HBc+, and HBsAg-) and Ⅷ (anti-HBs+ anti-HBc+, and HBsAg+) are in recovery phases caused by the positive anti-HBs. But type Ⅲ (anti-HBs-, anti-HBc+, and HBsAg-) and Ⅶ (anti-HBs- anti-HBc+, and HBsAg+) mean acute or chronic infection. The order of high anti-HBc positive rates among the three ethnic groups was Korean-Chinese, Korean and Han-Chinese. This order was too difficult to interpret like the anti-HBc.
      Positive anti-HBs means having immunity against HBV. Age-adjusted anti-HBs positive rate for Chinese (57.6% for Korean-Chinese and 49.2% for Han-Chinese) was higher than that of other reports^［2-5］, however, in Korean (the 62.5%) it was higher^［8,18］ or lower than that of other reports^［7,19］. Even though the difference among the three ethnic groups was not statistically significant, the reason why the anti-HBs positive rate for Korean (62.5%) was the highest, can be explained by the different serological profiles. Among the anti-HBs positive Koreans, 20.9% was type Ⅱ (anti-HBs+, anti-HBc-, and HBsAg-), which indicates remote past infection, but, 10.3% and 9.5% among Korean-Chinese and Han-Chinese. Other types like Ⅳ (anti-HBs+, anti-HBc+, and HBsAg-), Ⅵ (anti-HBs+, anti-HBc-, and HBsAg+) and Ⅷ (anti-HBs+, anti-HBc+, and HBsAg+) indicate the recovery phase of acute infection as a whole (Ⅳ, recovery phase of HBV infection; Ⅵ, unknown; and Ⅷ, circulating immune complex of HBsAg or reinfection with different HBsAg subtype or process of seroconversion from HBsAg to anti-HBs). Therefore, positive anti-HBs Koreans had more remote infections than Korean-Chinese and Han-Chinese, which could be also applied to the exploration of HBV infection rates. HBV infection was determined by having had any one of the positive HBV markers among HBsAg, anti-HBs and anti-HBc. The order of high HBV infection rates among the three ethnic groups was the same as anti-HBs, Korean, Korean-Chinese and Han-Chinese. The difference was statistically significant (P＜0.05).
      HBV infection rates in Korean-Chinese were 81.4% in males and 76.3% in females, which were 80.8% in males of Hunan area and 75.5% in female of Guangxi of China^［5］. The rates for Koreans were 81.4% in males and 70.4% in females. Therefore, even if the HBsAg rates have been decreasing as compared with that of the 1980s, HBV infection rate did not drop. According to Maynard et al^［20］. 70%-90% of the population were infected with HBV in the highly endemic areas. Hence, Korea and Yanbian were included in the endemic area.
      The fact that HBV infection rates for Korean-Chinese and Koreans were higher than those of the Han-Chinese seems to be caused by susceptibility and cultural factors such as life style and dining habits. Ahn et al^［19］ reported the association between HBV infection and behavioral characteristics such as life style, dining habit and sanitary status. Therefore, to determine the reason for the higher rate of HBV in Koreans and Korean-Chinese, more studies dealing with genetic factors and behavioral factors are needed.
      In regard to positive HBsAg rate, the results showed difference by ethnic groups in the same area. Consequently, for each of the areas and the ethnic groups, the HBV infection and transmission must be differentiated^［21］. For the clarification of the natural course on HBV, more detailed immigration studies and follow-up efforts should also be made.

REFERENCES
1    Kim DJ, Choi BY, Park HB. A study of hepatitis B infection rates of the school children in a rural area of korea. Hanyang
      Daxue Yixuexuebao, 1986;6:99-107
2    Wang HT, Jiang YT, Ma J, Zhu MB, Zhang XD. An epidemiological study of hepatitis B virus infection in a rural 
      production brigade in the suburb of Beijing. Zhonghua Liuxingbingxue Zazhi, 1985;6:141-144
3    Mi EY, Zhang FK, Liu YP, Lu TL. A seroepidemiologic study on HBV infection among villagers in Shanxi Province.
      Zhonghua Liuxingbingxue Zazhi,1984;5:325-327
4    Viral hepatitis investigation group of Zhengding County, Hebei Province. The prevalence of HBV infection in rural area 
      of Hebei Province. Zhonghua Liuxingbingxue Zazhi, 1987;8:70-74
5    Xiao YJ, Tang XM, Tang SL, Yang TB, Wen SW, Peng KJ. Seroepidemiologic study of HBV infection in Hunan Area.
      Zhonghua Liuxingbingxue Zazhi, 1990;11:133-137
6    Kim JS, Lee WY, Lee SW, Yoon HS, Yang SJ, Lee DH, Kim HC. An epidemiological study on HBsAg and anti-HBs 
      prevalence in relation to liver function tests among farmers in korea. Korean J Epidemiol, 1985;7:16-27
7    Choo IH, Han DH, Hwang SJ, Min CH, Cho MK, Yoon CS. An epidemiological study on the occurrence of hepatitis B virus 
      markers in a part of the population of Kwangwon Province. Korean J Epidemio, 1986;8:314-322
8    Kim IS, Oh HC, Lee Y, Kim JD, Lee WY. Prevalence and changes of HBsAg and anti-HBs for one year period in natural 
      status and after hepatitis B vaccination. Korean J Epidemio, 1987;9:40-48
9    Shin HC, Kim JS. A study on HBsAg positive rate among Korean adults and the immunogenicity of hepatitis B vaccine.
      Korean J Epidemio, 1989;11:98-106
10  Choi BY, Song JC, Park HB, Ko UR. A seroepidemiological study on the aspects of hepatitis B virus infection in a rural 
      community. J Hanyang Med Coll, 1990;10:245-265
11  Kim JS, Chung MH, Suh SC. HBsAg positive rate among korean urban and rural middle school children. Korean J 
      Epidemio, 1986;8:115-126
12  Li WY, Li CJ, Jin H. Epidemiology of hepatitis B virus infection in the population of Yanji city. Zhonghua Yufangyixuehui
      Yanbian Fenhui Lunwenji, 1987;1:56
13  Yanbian Renmin Chubanshe. Yanbian Tongji Nianjian, 2000. 2000:75
14  Wo GK, Yuan W, Chen HP, Duan XX, Mao MJ. Baseline survey of hepatitis B virus infection in ningbo city. Zhonghua
      Liuxingbingxue Zazhi, 1994;15:191
15  Chun BY, Lee MK, Rho YK. The prevalence of hepatitis B surface antigen among Korean by literature review. Korean
      J Epidemio, 1992;14:54-62
16  Shin HR, Kim JB. Markers after vaccination among healthy worker. Korean J Epidemio, 1994;16:163-171
17  Yoo KY. A review study on epidemiology of viral hepatitis. Korean J Epidemio, 1982;4:11-34
18  Hahm YS, Shin HR, Park HJ, Kim SR. A study on the relationship between HBsAg and hepatitis B virus DNA among 
      healthy HBsAg carriers. Korean J Epidemio, 1992;14:13-23
19  Ahn YO, Yoo KY, Park BJ. An epidemiology study on risk factors of hepatitis B infection in Korea. Korean J Epidemio,
      1987;9:57-65
20  Maynard JE, Kane MA, Hadler SC. Global control of hepatitis B through vaccination: Role of hepatitis B vaccine in the
      expanded program on immunization. Rev Infect Dis, 1989;11(Suppl 3):574-578
21  Mushahwar IK, Dienstag JL, Polesky HF. Interpretation of various serological profiles of hepatitis B virus infection. Am J 
      Clin Path, 1981;76:773-777

Reviews	Add
more>>