|
Xiao-Zhong
Wang, Gu-Zhen Lin, Department of Gastroenterology, Union
Hospital, Fujian Medical University, Fuzhou 350001, China
Dr. Xiao-Zhong Wang, male, born on 1962-08-13 in Fuzhou City, Fujian
Province, graduated from Hubei Medical University, with a master
degree of gastroenterology, now associate professor, having 58
papers published.
Correspondence to: Dr. Xiao-Zhong Wang, Department of
Gastroenterology, Union Hospital, Fujian Medical University, 29
Xinquan Road, Fuzhou 350001, Fujian Province, China
Telephone:
+86-591-3357896 ext 8482
Received: 1998-05-04
Subject
headings:
dyspepsia/drug therapy; famotidine/therapeutic use; cisapride/therapeutic
use; peptic ulcer; gastrointestinal motility
Wang XZ, Lin GZ.Functional dyspepsia of ulcer-dysmotility type:
clinical incidence and therapeutic strategy.
World J Gastroenterol, 1998;4(4):367-368
Functional dyspepsia is a commonly occurring chronic digestive
disorder affecting 20%-40% of the general population [1].
It is a syndromic term applied to patients who complain of symptoms
presumably arising from the upper abdomen, often in response to meal
ingestion, but with absence of organic abnormalities demonstrable by
conventional diagnostic tests. Although functional dyspepsia is very
common in the community, the classification and the clinical therapy
are still uncertain. Therefore this study deals with the clinical
incidence and the therapeutic strategy of functional dyspepsia of
the ulcer-dysmotility mixed type.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Diagnostic criteria[2]
The patients who fulfilled the
following criteria were selected: postcibal abdominal fullness or
bloating with other associated symptoms, including early satiety,
upper abdominal pain, nausea, and vomiting; symptoms of moderate to
severe intensity, and of more than 3 months duration; absence of
clinical, biochemical, and morphological evidence of
gastrointestinal, biliary, and systemic diseases assessed by
negative results of anamnesis, physical examination, laboratory
tests, upper gut endoscopy and ultrasonography; and no previous
abdominal surgery.
Classification
Functional dyspepsia is now conventionally divided into ulcer (those
with symptoms suggestive of peptic ulceration), dysmotility (those
with gastric stasis including upper abdominal bloating, abdominal
fullness, early satiety, belching, nausea, and vomiting), reflux
(those with symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux), and unspecified
dyspepsia (the remainder)[1].
Because many of subjects with dyspepsia could be classified into
more than one group, we classified the patients with overlapped
symptoms of peptic ulceration and gastric stasis into ulcer
dysmotility mixed type of functional dyspepsia.
Treatment
The patients with ulcer-dysmotility mixed type of functional
dyspepsia were randomly divided into three groups: group 1 received
famotidine (gaster, 40mg qd) for 3 weeks; group 2 received cisapride
(prepulsid, 5mg tid) for 3 weeks; and group 3 treated with both
famotidine and cisapride for 3 weeks. No additional medication was
given. One month after termination of the treatment, the patients
were followed up for symptoms disappearance and side-effects.
Statistics
Statistical analyses were made using x2 test.
RESULTS
A total of 220 patients with functional dyspepsia (122 males and 98
females; aged 19-62 years, averaging 36 years) were included in this
study. All patients fulfilled the diagnostic criteria mentioned
above. According to the symptoms, 59 cases (26.8%) were classified
as ulcer type; 57 cases (25.9%), dysmotility type; 2 cases (0.9%) of
reflux type; and 102 cases (46.4%), ulcer-dysmotility mixed type.
The ulcer-dysmotility mixed type (59 males and 43 females,
aged 21-61 years, mean 39 years) were randomly allocated to three
groups (34 patients each group) and treated with famotidine,
cisapride, and famotidine plus cisapride respectively. One month
after termination of the treatment, the symptom disappearance of the
patients are shown in Table 1. Three patients withdrew from the
treatment because of diarrhea caused by cisapride. The results
demonstrated that a single drug (famotidine or cisapride) could not
efficiently eliminate the symptoms of the patients, while the
combined therapy with famotidine plus cisapride seem to be an
effective treatment for those patients.
Table 1 Symptom disappearance after treatment
|
Groups
|
n
|
Ulcer-line
symptoms(%)
|
Dysmotility-like
symptoms(%)
|
Both
symptoms
(%)
|
|
Famotidine
|
34
|
33
(97.1)
|
10
(29.4)a
|
10
(29.4)a
|
|
Cisapride
|
32
|
9
(28.1) a
|
30
(93.8)
|
9
(28.1)a
|
|
Famotidine
plus cisapride
|
33
|
33
(100)
|
32
(97.0)
|
32
(97.0)
|
aP<0.01
vs famotidine plus cisapride group.
DISCUSSION
Like other functional disorders of the gastrointestinal system such
as irritable bowel syndrome and gastro-oesophageal reflux, our
understanding of the pathophysiological mechanisms underlying this
condition still remains elusive. Motor, neurohumoral, and sensory
abnormalities in both the stomach and small bowel have been
demonstrated in some patients with functional dyspepsia[3].
It has been proposed that the previous symptom classification in
patients with functional dyspepsia may reflect, to a certain extent,
different pathophysiological entities, but distinct symptom
classification can not be accomplished. So the investigation and
treatment of functional dyspepsia can be benefited by the symptom
classification[4].
Our study indicated that the ulcer and dysmotility (46.4%) type was
overlapped in patients with functional dyspepsia, therefore we
suggested the concept of ulcer-dysmotility mixed type which may be
beneficial to the classification and treatment of those patients.
In present study, a total of 102 patients with ulcer
dysmotility mixed type of functional dyspepsia were randomly divided
into three groups and treated with famotidine, cisapride, and
famotidine plus cisapride respectively. The results demonstrated
that famotidine plus cisapride could more efficiently eliminate the
symptoms of the patients as compared with the group using famotidine
or cisapride alone. Although the previous study suggested that the
peripheral kappa agonist fedotozine could modify both sensory and
motor responses to stimuli and effectively relieve the key symptoms
associated with functional dyspepsia including ulcer and dysmotility-like
symptoms[5],
famotidine plus cisapride may be an effective and economic therapy
for the ulcer-dysmotility mixed type of functional dyspepsia based
on the modified symptom related classification.
REFERENCES
1 Talley NJ, Zinsmeister AR, Schleck CD, Melton LJ.
Dyspepsia and dyspepsia subgroups: a population-
based study.Gastroenterology,1992;102(4):1259-1268
2 Coffin B, Azpiroz F, Guarner F, Malagelada JR.
Selective gastric hypersensitivity and reflex hyporeactivity in
functional
dyspepsia.Gastroenterol,1994;107(5):1345-1351
3 Lemann M, Dederding JP, Flouric B, Franchisseur
C, Rambaud JC, Jian R. Abnormal perception of visceral pain in
response
to gastric distention in chronic idiopathic dyspepsia: the
irritable stomach syndrome.Dig Dis Sci, 1991;36(9):1249-1254
4 Drossman DA,Thompson WG,Talley NJ, Funch-Jensen
P, Janssens J, Whitehead WE. Identification of subgroups of
functional gastrointestinal disorders.Gastroenterol Intern,
1990;3(1):159-172
5 Read NW, Abitbol JL, Bardhan KD, Whorwell
PJ, Fraitag B. Efficacy and safety of the peripheral kappa agonist
fedotozine
versus placebo in the treatment of functional
dyspepsia.Gut,1997;41(5):664-668
| |