|
Jin-Hai
Wang, Jin-Yan Luo, Lei Dong, Jun Gong, Department of
Gastroenterology, Second Hospital of Xi’an Jiaotong University,
Xi’an 710004, Shaanxi Province, China
Ming Tong, Department of Preventive Medicine, Medical College
of Xi’an Jiaotong University, Xi’an 710061, Shaanxi Province,
China
Correspondence to: Dr. Jin-Hai Wang, Department of
Gastroenterology, Second Hospital of Xi’an Jiaotong University,
Xi’an 710004, Shaanxi Province, China.
jinhaiwang@hotmail.com
Telephone: +86-29-7679290
Fax: +86-29-7231758
Received: 2003-11-21
Accepted: 2003-12-16
Abstract
AIM: Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is a common disorder
in the Western population, but detailed population-based data in
China are limited. The aim of this study was to understand the
epidemiology of symptomatic gastroesophageal reflux (SGER) in adults
of Xi’an, a northwestern city of China, and to explore the
potential risk factors of GERD.
METHODS:
Symptoms suggestive of GERD, functional dyspepsia (FD), irritable
bowel syndrome (IBS), upper respiratory diseases and some potential
risk factors were investigated in a face-to-face manner in a
region-stratified random samples of 2 789 residents aged 18-70 years
in Xi’an by using a standardized questionnaire.
RESULTS: With a response rate of 91.8%, the prevalence of SGER was
16.98% (95% CI, 14.2-18.92) in Xi’an adults, and no gender-related
difference was observed (P>0.05). SGER was more common
among subjects aged 30-70 years than in those aged 18-29 years (P<0.05).
The prevalence of SGER in rural, urban and suburban subjects was
21.07%, 17.44% and 12.12%, respectively, and there was a significant
difference between rural, urban and suburban regions (P<0.05).
Compared with subjects without SGER, the prevalence of symptoms
suggestive of FD and IBS, pneumonia, asthma, bronchitis, laryngitis,
pharyngitis, chronic cough, wheeze, globus sensation, oral ulcer and
snore was significantly increased in subjects with SGER (P<0.01).
Heavy smoking (OR=4.94; CI, 3.70-6.61), heavy alcohol use (OR=2.85;
CI, 1.67-4.49), peptic ulcer (OR=5.76; CI, 3.99-8.32), cerebral
palsy (OR=3.97; CI, 1.97-8.00), abdominal operation (OR=2.69; CI,
1.75-4.13), obesity (OR=2.16; CI, 1.47-3.16), excessive food intake
(OR=1.43; CI, 1.17-1.75), sweet food (OR=1.23; CI, 0.89-1.54), and
consumption of coffee (OR=1.23; CI, 0.76-2.00) were independently
associated with SGER. The episodes of GERD were commonly
precipitated by dietary factors (66.05%), followed by body posture
(26.54%), ill temper (23.72%), fatigue (22.32%) and stress (10.93%).
CONCLUSION: GERD is common in Xi’an’s adult population with a
mild or moderate degree. The etiology and pathogenesis of GERD are
probably associated with FD, IBS, and some respiratory,
laryngopharyngeal and odontostological diseases or symptoms. Some
lifestyles, diseases and dietary factors are the risk factors of
GERD.
Wang JH, Luo JY, Dong
L, Gong J, Tong M. Epidemiology of gastroesophageal reflux disease:
A general population-based study in Xi’an of Northwest China.
World J Gastroenterol
2004; 10(11): 1647-1651
http://www.wjgnet.com/1007-9327/10/1647.asp
INTRODUCTION
Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is a common disorder, and
approximately 17-38% of adults in the Western population experienced
heartburn and/or acid regurgitation, the main symptoms of GERD, at
least once per week; with 4-9% having daily symptoms[1-3].
Some patients with GERD would develop Barrett’s esophagus,
intestinal metaplasia of esophageal mucosa that predisposes to
adenocarcinoma of the esophagus[4-8], which has increased
rapidly since 1970s[9,10]. Patients with esophageal
carcinoma have been proved to have a low 5-year survival rate[11,12]
In addition to the risk of cancer, GERD is well recognized to be
associated with some upper respiratory diseases, having an adverse
impact on the quality of life, and the cost of long-term medical
therapy is substantial. Therefore, it is of much importance to
understand the prevalence of GERD and to identify the potential risk
factors to prevent GERD and GERD- related diseases. As detailed
population-based data on GERD in China are currently limited, we
aimed in this study to estimate the prevalence of SGER in Xi’an
adults, to determine the relationship between GERD and FD, IBS, and
upper respiratory diseases, and to explore the risk factors of GERD.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Subjects
Xi’an is a northwestren city of China, consisting of 7
administrative districts and 3 counties. Of the administrative
districts 4 are in the urban region and 3 in the suburban region,
and the counties are all in the rural region. Each district includes
numerous neighboring communities including multiple residential
areas, and each of the county covers several townships governing a
number of villages. Based on the 1997 census data obtained from the
local government and the proportion of population within the
regions, we randomly selected one or more residential areas or
villages in the urban, suburban and rural regions, respectively.
Finally, a total of 2 789 subjects entered this survey, including
911 subjects from the urban region, 853 from the suburban region,
and 1 025 from the rural region. The proportion of subjects in
different regions was similar to that of Xi’an population (P>0.05),
and the selected samples were matched for age and gender with
Xi’an population (P>0.05).
Questionnaire
The questionnaire was designed on the basis of previous
works from two university hospitals[13], but modified to
suit the local conditions. The modified version contained 8
fractions covering a total of 130 relative questions (items), of
which 15 were specifically concerned with the frequency and severity
of symptoms suggestive of GERD in the past years. Other questions
included those concerning general condition of the subject
(self-reported height and weight), the symptoms suggestive of
functional dyspepsia (FD) and irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) in the
past year, symptoms or history of respiratory, laryngopharyngeal,
and odontostological diseases in the past year; history of illness
and operation, personal habits (smoking, alcohol), and dietary
habits.
Definitions
The following definitions for symptom categories and
diseases were used. Only symptoms occurring in the past year before
the interview were considered. (1) Heartburn: a burning pain or
burning sensation behind the sternum in the chest. (2) Acid
regurgitation: a bitter or sour-tasting fluid reflux into the throat
or mouth. (3) Food regurgitation: eaten food reflux into the mouth.
Heartburn, acid regurgitation, and food regurgitation were
considered to be the main symptoms of GERD. Each of the typical
symptoms was estimated according to its severity and frequency,
which measured on a 4-score scale. The severity was assessed as
follows: 0, none; 1, mild (could be ignored); 2, moderate (could not
be ignored but did not affect lifestyle); 3, severe (affected
lifestyle). The score of symptom frequency was estimated as follows:
0, none or less than one occasion per month on average; 1, several
occasions (1 to3) a month; 2, several occasions (1 to 6) a week; 3,
one or more than one occasions daily. Based on the scores of the
severity and frequency of the main GERD symptoms, a total score
(range, 0 to 18) of each subject was calculated. (4) SGER: subjects
with a total score (St) no less than 3. (5) Chest pain: any pain or
discomfort felt inside the chest more than once per month on average
but not including any pain caused by diagnosed heart disease. (6)
Dysphagial: a feeling that food stuck in the throat or chest more
than one per month. (7) Symptoms suggestive of FD and IBS and
symptoms of respiratory, laryngopharyngeal, and odontostological
diseases: any of these symptoms presented more than once a week on
average in the past year. (8) History of diseases or operations: any
disease or operation diagnosed or performed in a hospital before the
interview. (9) Alcohol use: taking 300 g of alcohol per month. (10)
Heavy alcohol use: taking 210 g or more of alcohol per week. (11)
Smoking status: defined as current smoking, current non-smoking, and
heavy smoking (more than one pack a day). (12) Obesity: a body mass
index ≧30
kg/m2. (13) Coffee and special beverages: drinking more
than one cup per day on average. (14) Dietary habits: taking special
food more than one servings per day on average.
Training of interviewers
The team of interviewers was constituted mainly by medical
students studying preventive medicine in our university, who were
trained by the same two professors, one was a physician of
gastroenterology and understood well the relative definitions, and
the other was a specialist in preventive medicine and had rich
experience in survey.
Assessment of feasibility
Before the actual study, a pilot study was conducted among
100 unselected outpatients attending our gastroenterological clinic,
to test the appropriateness of the questionnaire and to familiarize
the interviewers with the survey procedure and the definitions. The
problems that the interviewers encountered during the pilot study
were discussed and their solutions were provided accordingly.
Survey
design and response rate
According to the list of selected subjects and guiding by
the members of residents or village’s committee, all subjects were
interviewed face to face at their home by the interviewers. The
completed questionnaires were checked and kept by same physician.
The absent subjects were registered and two reminder interviews were
conducted at weekly intervals. Finally, the survey was closed after
16 wk. Among the 2 789 selected subjects, 74 had moved away, 58
could not be interviewed due to their absence during the survey
period, 6 died, and 91 explicitly refused to participate in the
study. A total of 2 560 subjects were successfully interviewed
within a period of 4 mo, resulting in a response rate of 91.8%.
There was no difference between the responders and non-responders
with respect to their age and gender (P>0.05), and the
constitution of the non-responder in different regions was
reasonably similar (P>0.05). Twenty-eight individuals were
subsequently excluded from the analysis because of inadequately
questionnaires. Data from 2 532 questionnaires were entered in a
computer.
Statistical analysis
The questionnaires were coded for analysis, and the data
were entered in a computer and analyzed by using DBASEⅢ
software. The prevalence was derived with 95% confidence intervals
(95%CI). Comparison of the data was performed using EP15.0 x2
test. The odds ratios (OR) and 95% CI for each significant variable
in the final model were calculated from the coefficients estimated
in the logistic regression model. All P values were two-tailed, with
the level of statistical significance specified at 0.05.
RESULTS
Main symptoms of GERD
The prevalence of heartburn for at least once monthly,
weekly and daily episodes was 10.98% (278/2 532), 4.07% (103/2 532)
and 1.66% (42/2 532), respectively. That for acid regurgitation
monthly was 21.01%
(532/2 532), weekly 7.78% (197/2 532), and daily 3.53% (89/2
532). For food regurgitation, the prevalence was 8.57% (217/2 532),
3.28% (83/2 532), and 1.42% (36/2 532) for at least one occasion
monthly, weekly, and daily, respectively.
Symptomatic
gastroesophageal reflux
The distribution of the total score of main GERD symptoms in
the responders is shown in Table 1. The prevalence of SGER was
16.98% (95%CI, 14.20-18.92), of which, 13.11%, 2.92%, and 0.95% were
considered as mild, moderate, and severe, respectively.
Responders with SGER were more likely to be a mild or
moderate degree.
Table
1
The distribution of total score of main GERD symptoms of
responders (n=2 532)
| Total
score (St) |
Responders
(n) |
Rate
(%) |
| ≦2
|
2 102
|
83.02
|
| ≧3(SGER)
|
430
|
16.98
|
| 3-7
(mild)
|
332
|
13.11
|
| 8-12
(moderate)
|
74
|
2.92
|
| 13-18
(severe)
|
24
|
0.95
|
Relationship
between SGER and gender, age, and region
There
was no statistically significant difference between men and women in
the prevalence of GERD (61.71% vs 17.25%, P>0.05), and the
ratio of male/female was 1:1.03. The prevalence of SGED was
relatively constant across each of 10-year age interval (Table 2, x2
for trend; P= 0.075), but by cutting x2 apart, we found that
the prevalence of GERD was significantly higher in the responders
aged 30-70 years than in those aged 18-29 years (x2=4.40, P<0.05),
and the group aged 50-59 years had the highest prevalence of SGEG
(21.39%). The responders in the urban and rural regions were more
likely than the responders in suburban regions to have SGER (21.07%
and 17.44% vs 12.12%, P<0.05). However, SGER was similarly prevalent in the
urban and rural regions (P>0.05).
Table
2
The prevalence of SGED in each age group
| Age
group (yr) |
Responders
(n) |
Responders
with SGED (n) |
Prevalence
of SGED(%) |
| <20
|
64
|
9
|
14.06
|
| 20-29
|
517
|
73
|
14.12
|
| 30-39
|
621
|
106
|
17.07
|
| 40-49
|
584
|
100
|
17.12
|
| 50-59
|
360
|
77
|
21.39
|
| 60-69
|
354
|
60
|
16.95
|
| 70
|
32
|
5
|
15.63
|
| 18-70
|
2 532
|
430
|
16.98
|
Association
between SGER and respiratory, laryngopharyngeal, and odontostoloical
diseases
Table
3 summarized the prevalence of some respiratory, laryngopharyngeal,
and odontostological diseases or symptoms in responders with and
without SGER. The responders with SGER reported a higher prevalence
of pneumonia, asthma, bronchitis, pharyngitis, laryngitis, chronic
cough, wheeze, globus sensation, oral ulcer, and snore than the
responders without SGER.
Table
3
The prevalence of respiratory, laryngopharyngeal, and
odontostological diseases or symptoms in responders with and without
SGER
| Disease
or symptom
|
Responders with
SGER(n=430) |
Responderswithout
SGER(n=2 102) |
P value |
| n
|
Rate
(%)
|
n
|
Rate
(%)
|
| Pneumonia
|
12
|
2.79
|
15
|
0.73
|
<0.01
|
| Asthma
|
28
|
6.51
|
46
|
2.19
|
<0.01 |
| Bronchitis
|
66
|
15.35
|
187
|
8.90
|
<0.01
|
| Pharyngitis
|
35
|
8.14
|
82
|
3.90
|
<0.01
|
| Laryngitis
|
102
|
23.73
|
248
|
11.80
|
<0.01
|
| Chronic
cough
|
92
|
21.40
|
232
|
11.04
|
<0.01
|
| Wheeze
|
33
|
7.67
|
80
|
3.80
|
<0.01
|
| Globus
sensation
|
102
|
23.72
|
104
|
4.95
|
<0.01
|
| Oral
ulcer
|
77
|
17.91
|
162
|
7.71
|
<0.01
|
| Snore
|
121
|
28.14
|
362
|
12.27
|
<0.01
|
Relationship
between SGER and other common gastrointestinal symptoms
The
prevalence rate of pain behind the sternum, dysphagia, retching,
nausea, vomiting, epigastric discomfort, epigastric fullness,
epigastric pain, diarrhoea, and constipation in responders with SGER
was significantly higher than that in the responders without SGER (P<0.01,
Table 4).
Table
4
Other common gastrointestinal symptoms in responders with and
without GERD
| Symptom
|
Responders with
SGER (n=430) |
Responders without
SGER (n=2 102) |
P value |
| n
|
Rate (%)
|
n
|
Rate (%)
|
| Pain
behind breastbone
|
100
|
23.25
|
84
|
4.14
|
<0.01
|
| Dysphagia
|
24
|
5.58
|
20
|
0.95
|
<0.01 |
| Retching
|
164
|
38.14
|
228
|
10.85
|
<0.01
|
| Nausea
|
137
|
31.86
|
148
|
7.04
|
<0.01
|
| Vomiting
|
78
|
| |